Weird, I wonder what could be causing it. I'd like to trim down the cause of it before moving it towards being filed, but the lack of consistency is confusing me here.
OK, I think I may have found it. Turned on Compatibility View in IE8 and it triggered this issue. Turned it off and it went away.
For those of you with the problem, is Compatibility View (Tools > Compatibility View) on? I know some turned this on due to problems with QB vision lines, so this might be it.
unique issue that happens to one browser with one specific setting - not an issue we're going to resolve so will move it to Resolved Bugs and mark as WILL NOT RESOLVE