User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > How the minors should be handled
Page:
 
Tim26
one
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I'd rather see a level 7 cap than 1.


 
xsujx
offline
Link
 
+2

Added bonus point for addressing age along with caps.
 
BearsFan09
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djp68
+1


 
maddoggy71
offline
Link
 
+1

YESSSSSSSSSSS!!!! Where do I sign???
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
I would support this as being better than the current system.

I would prefer teams be sorted by skill point value, however.
 
kondor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xsujx
+2

Added bonus point for addressing age along with caps.


+1
 
Xcesiv7
offline
Link
 
+1
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
+1
 
tobewon
offline
Link
 
How do non-boosters fit in here?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tobewon
How do non-boosters fit in here?


Most likely they would find teams in their cap they also fit the age requirement for or possibly play in leagues 1 cap up.
 
maddoggy71
offline
Link
 
Our Lv 22 team got placed with a team having players on average of 180 days older than our players.

The current system doesn't even penalize SSB teams for 3-4 seasons.

Win L14 ---------> L22 (with all the other playoff teams who don't SSB)
Win L22 ---------> L30 (with all the other playoff teams who don't SSB)
Win L30 ---------> L38 maybe at this point a playoff team goes to L34

So if you really want trophies, SSB for 2-3 seasons... it's almost automatic.
Edited by maddoggy71 on Jan 21, 2010 16:46:59
 
jaylien1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Rather than using a promotiion system for the minors which creates imbalance and gutting and ends up causing several leagues with numerous CPU teams, and regular teams facing SSB teams, there needs to be a different system.

1. At rollover, minor league teams are placed into a capped league level equal to the lowest level the highest level player is equal to or under. Teams with players above the highest cap will be assigned to fill AA leagues first then form minors uncapped leagues if all AA leagues are full.

2. Assign teams in each league level by oldest player on team. So the 32 teams with the oldest player(s) would go to #1, then the next 32 to #2. Of course there would be some discrepancy and you may have 56 teams rather than 32 or 64 who have oldest player created on same date, but it would help.

3. Add an age cap to each minor league that is equal to the oldest player in the league.


I like the general idea, because I definitely think player age is overlooked. What about changing #2 to use the average age of the players on the team? There are some teams that may be 95% made up of players around 100d with 1 or 2 SSB's that are around 200d...they shouldn't sort up with a team that is 100% SSB as they will still get killed.
 
maddoggy71
offline
Link
 
I don't think player age is enough.

By grouping the "oldest" 32 teams together, there will still be a wide disparity.

Take the L22 team which is 180 days older than our non-SSB team.... if they are the 1st oldest... the 32nd oldest is still gonna be a huge difference of probably 100+ days.

Our only loss last season was close games to a +60 day SSB team. We actually kept it very close, but our offense was shutout both games. A really good SSB team should have killed us.
 
tobewon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by tobewon

How do non-boosters fit in here?


Most likely they would find teams in their cap they also fit the age requirement for or possibly play in leagues 1 cap up.


That could leave some non-boosters fairly under-leveled though would it not?

For instance, a non (or sometimes booster) created in Season 6 would make him around level 33-34. A regular (non SSB) boosting player created in the same season would be around level 50. That's more than 15 levels between the two.

Of course, the difference grows the longer they are around and the difference wouldn't be so great in younger players (at least I wouldnt think so) but it is something that should be considered.
 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tobewon

For instance, a non (or sometimes booster) created in Season 6 would make him around level 33-34. A regular (non SSB) boosting player created in the same season would be around level 50. That's more than 15 levels between the two.


the lvl 34 would be in a 34 cap league and the level 50 would be in an AA league. wouldnt even need to bother comparing creation dates
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.