User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add Gold / Silver / Copper Leagues For Each Level Cap And Change Promotion System
Page:
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
How would promotion and demolition work


you would go to whatever cap your team fit into. If you were a silver conference champ, you would move up to gold (probably depending on exactly how many silver leagues there are) Gold non playoff (and possibly 7 and 8 seeds) would move down to silver.

Copper would be mainly reserved for teams that were getting beaten up in silver leagues (like maybe 14, 15, and 16th seeds in the league) as well as CPU teams etc. A formula might be devised to count how many losses by 70+ you suffered in the season, and teams with excessive (somewhere around 6 seems excessive) 70+ point losses would be moved down.

Copper teams that performed well in the copper leagues, as well as have the roster, and scouting bars to warrant moving up, would move up to silver leagues
 
ravensb06
offline
Link
 
+21
 
Jaxon Voom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
Gold would consist of the conference winning teams (and good playoff teams from previous gold leagues).


Like it or not, this is the problem with the suggestion. This would only work if all the owners out there were sporting and actually after great competition. Unfortunately this is the same GLB that people refuse promotion to AA. Some owners just want trophies so they'll tank one season so they can be put in copper or silver league the next season and take an easy gold. For that reason this wont solve the parity problem.

In an ideal world this would be a great suggestion but the fact is, alot of GLB agents are asses who are quite content with getting one or two gold trophies in the lower leagues and then gutting and restarting to do the same again.

Also...

Originally posted by Chysil
At level 14 (would be only silver and copper). Copper leagues would consist of all gut job teams, teams with heavy CPU, teams that have a very low average level etc


Same reasoning, you'd get teams that would have empty rosters for the team assignments so they get into copper then just fill the roster with level 14's and wipe everyone else out to the gold.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Most of the teams that win, especially in the lower caps, SSB mainly, have no desire to play a competitive schedule.
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
I have seen similar suggestions.
Almost any system will show people trying to game the system.
I think the ONLY way to get it done up right is going to be by locking rosters once the shuffling is done & not allowing teams to decline promotions (which is pretty much NGTH).
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
This would only work if all the owners out there were sporting and actually after great competition. Unfortunately this is the same GLB that people refuse promotion to AA. Some owners just want trophies so they'll tank one season so they can be put in copper or silver league the next season and take an easy gold. For that reason this wont solve the parity problem.

In an ideal world this would be a great suggestion but the fact is, alot of GLB agents are asses who are quite content with getting one or two gold trophies in the lower leagues and then gutting and restarting to do the same again.

Same reasoning, you'd get teams that would have empty rosters for the team assignments so they get into copper then just fill the roster with level 14's and wipe everyone else out to the gold.


to the first part, I know there are some people that might tank a season etc to try and get a trophy... but the idea is that having a copper league trophy wouldn't be much of bragging rights, and the other incentives and penalties are to try to encourage owners to play legit. You will always have people trying to beat the system, I don't see how this is different than currently teams tanking a season and outleveling everyone in the league and walking to a championship, except for in this system the people they walk over are the less serious and CPU teams so they probably won't care as much

------------------------------

as for the empty rosters and then inviting to win copper leagues, again you have penalties to hurt them monetarily for going to copper, as well as the severe chemistry hit they'd take (new team with 75 to all, signing 40+ players at 1 chem hit per person they are dealing with terrible chem)
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
Like it or not, this is the problem with the suggestion. This would only work if all the owners out there were sporting and actually after great competition. Unfortunately this is the same GLB that people refuse promotion to AA. Some owners just want trophies so they'll tank one season so they can be put in copper or silver league the next season and take an easy gold. For that reason this wont solve the parity problem.


Excellent point....a new suggestion.

Gold League - Winner = gold trophy, runner-up = Silver
Silver League - Winner = silver, runner-up = copper
Copper League - Winner = copper, runner-up = nothing

Make gold trophies mean something.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Excellent point....a new suggestion.

Gold League - Winner = gold trophy, runner-up = Silver
Silver League - Winner = silver, runner-up = copper
Copper League - Winner = copper, runner-up = nothing

Make gold trophies mean something.


that's why I wanted a special trophy made for the gold leagues to show off that you are the best of your cap
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
I Like +1

But, what is to keep a team from moving its roster from one team to another, to another, to another, to another.

Say I own a team and we go 20-0 then get promoted to the tough Gold league, we could dump my roster, and move the entire team to Chysil's team.

Chysil's team then goes 20-0 in a poop copper or silver league and I take his roster and fail at life and fall back to Silver / Copper again.

Rinse, Repeat.
 
TruBucfan22
offline
Link
 
I remember suggesting this last season... and it was flamed out like most suggestions.


but still a +1
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by P@nda
I Like +1

But, what is to keep a team from moving its roster from one team to another, to another, to another, to another.

Say I own a team and we go 20-0 then get promoted to the tough Gold league, we could dump my roster, and move the entire team to Chysil's team.

Chysil's team then goes 20-0 in a poop copper or silver league and I take his roster and fail at life and fall back to Silver / Copper again.

Rinse, Repeat.


the benefits for being in gold and the serious chem penalties you'd take from getting hit...

no system is going to account for people bending / breaking the rules. The idea is just to make it harder (more of a hassle), or add enough benefits for not doing it that they wouldn't want to
 
TruBucfan22
offline
Link
 
I think for as many dirty owners there 10x the good owners, that actually want something like this. So they can have more fun within the normal game schedule, and not have to join a Tourney to actually face real competition.

Everyone brings up the scam artists but what about the people that actually want to play the game as it was intended. Im sure there are some people who will try to scam it... but really if a team is still in the same league as they should be then competition will last through out all 3 tiers. Im sure even the copper league will have more than enough good teams to go around, but give the people that actually want to face a tough schedule the chance to.


p.s. I've never seen a scam team or group of agents before... not to say they dont exist but I've just never seen any of them...
 
Link
 
I would also make the endorsements much better for gold vs copper.

How would teams that request to be demoted be handled? Odds are that they already have a complete roster and probably already have decent AIs.

When allocating teams to silver and copper, I would also look at the average age of the players to make sure that SSB teams don't end up in copper leagues. Also, when promoting teams, regular season record needs to be more of a consideration. I've never understood #1 seeds that throw playoff games.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SciFi not Syfy
I would also make the endorsements much better for gold vs copper.

How would teams that request to be demoted be handled? Odds are that they already have a complete roster and probably already have decent AIs.

When allocating teams to silver and copper, I would also look at the average age of the players to make sure that SSB teams don't end up in copper leagues. Also, when promoting teams, regular season record needs to be more of a consideration. I've never understood #1 seeds that throw playoff games.


I think #1 teams throw playoff games to prevent a 3 level cap promotion, but since this system you are always the level cap your team fits into, you don't need to worry about it.

as for demotion, they would start in silver 14 cap, if they fill their roster will level 1s they'd be shuffled to copper at the season rollover

SSB teams that are throwing games at first (while they are under level 14 etc) would be copper, when they get to the level their builds would make their teams get pushed to silver. (although usually SSB teams have their players spread out when they are in SSB build mode).

There might be an additional check for teams that are in 14 copper, that remain in 14 cap league due to their level (since first time they would be copper due to level, next time due to being in the 14s they would get bumped to silver)
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
How would one ever get to pro from the very bottom in this system?

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.