Warrior General Games

Originally posted by keith_dude
Originally posted by tuba_samurai

Originally posted by keith_dude


Sure...why not?

Can you imagine what the bugs forum would look like, and the uproar when the bugs mod say, "working as intended"?

Maybe Bort could add a line to the replay: (Defense confused), or (Wrong Read)

You could add that to about 50% of the replays randomly right now, without any coding changes, and it would make sense.

fumbled snaps imo

Originally posted by Deathblade
fumbled snaps imo

Illegal formation, offense lining up improperly, etc

If you're gonna have screw-ups like that one on side of the ball...

Nothing wrong with blown coverage calls, WR s running bad routes, OL missing blocking assignments...the issue that I see is that you have to have proper feedback to let you(and bug testers) know there was a "mental miscue". You could probably even add a stat called "Positional Errors" (feel free to think of a better term) which tracks these.

So, if the MLB misses the offense's personnel changes and didnt realize they went 5wr, instead of a standard 3wr SB...then this should be logged as a miscue. If you need to see it in the PBP...then add a line noting pre-snap miscues (as opposed to playrun miscues like bad routes or missed blocking assignments...which just get logged similar to a pancake).

the other question is, would this be completely random, or build based? Would increased vision per say decrease the number of times this happened?

as for the failing to recongnize going from 3wr to 5wr... coaches call subs on and off the field in that situation, since this game you pretty much have to run dime or quarter (thanks to LBer penalty for m2m vs WR) against 5 wide, I would hope the MLB would notice the personnel change on his side and figure out something was up...

realism can kill a game... this is just one of those things that really doesn't need to be in the game

horrible