User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > Huckabee says a big tent is a bad idea. I, for one, agree with him.
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


Originally posted by Tony Dungy

has to do a better job of is convincing people that all the money we dump into social programs is efficient use of that money...... and that none/little is being wasted.

sure, although that's honestly not much of a concern for socialists. for example, i don't care how efficiently we feed our nation's children -- i just want it fucking done. making sure kids don't starve is never a waste of money, and if that means some member of american nobility doesn't get a beemer this year, i really don't care. feeding starving kids is way more important than status symbols.


This is exactly what I mean. There are many different ways to feed the children and some are more efficient than others. Here are some options of the top of my head:

1.) Children are allowed to walk into any store and eat/order anything they want. Parents are allowed to order anything they want for their kids under age 7.
2.) We can give $400 cash to parents each month for each child
3.) We can give $400 of food to parents for each child
4.) We can give $400 cash for each child to parents who make less than $60K per year.
.
.
.
.
200.) We can have churches, synagogues, and private charity organizations raise funds and supply food for all poor children

As you can see, there are many many ways you can solve the problem. And if we can solve the problem with 100% private donations (like #200), then you can use tax payer funds to do things like hire more cops or build more/better roads and bridges. So to say that you don't care about how we do it isn't very bright. Conservatives definitely want all kids to have food also, but just think that there is a more efficient route to take than to give food stamps which parents trade for alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs rather than food for their children.

 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
This is exactly what I mean. There are many different ways to feed the children and some are more efficient than others. Here are some options of the top of my head:
1.) Children are allowed to walk into any store and eat/order anything they want. Parents are allowed to order anything they want for their kids under age 7.
2.) We can give $400 cash to parents each month for each child
3.) We can give $400 of food to parents for each child
4.) We can give $400 cash for each child to parents who make less than $60K per year.
.
.
.
.
200.) We can have churches, synagogues, and private charity organizations raise funds and supply food for all poor children
As you can see, there are many many ways you can solve the problem. And if we can solve the problem with 100% private donations (like #200), then you can use tax payer funds to do things like hire more cops or build more/better roads and bridges. So to say that you don't care about how we do it isn't very bright. Conservatives definitely want all kids to have food also, but just think that there is a more efficient route to take than to give food stamps which parents trade for alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs rather than food for their children.


aaand you've totally missed the point.

you're speaking in the future tense as if this is some thought experiment we may encounter down the road. uh, no. children are starving now and your little #200 option has completely failed them. it has failed beyond a shadow of a doubt. it flat-out doesn't work. you are advocating a 'solution' that doesn't work.

and the bolded sentence above proves yet again that you can't read. i never said i didn't care how it was done (e.g. i don't think we should end child starvation by slaughtering kids), i only said i don't care "how efficiently" it gets done. learn how to read, learn how to read, learn how to read. protip -- every time you think i've said something that "isn't very bright", chances are it's you failing at reading comprehension again. learn how to read, learn how to read, learn how to read. i am so fucking sick of opinionated morons who don't know how to read.

vote education.
Edited by Catullus 16 on Sep 22, 2010 10:36:31
 
Roughneck
offline
Link
 
Maybe it's another case of best intentions not following through. One group can claim that they wanted to feed other kids by issuing food stamps and another group can claim that they wanted to feed their children by recieving food stamps. However, if the one group fails to issue stamps for some reason, and the other group is too high or drunk to go shopping for food, children remain hungry. This doesn't mean all of the children, but I can see how a percentage still get the short end of the stick. I believe there is always money somewhere to help with this issue, but it boils down to administration, one way or another.

It's like issuing monies to the native reservations in Canada, but watching it get tied up in Band beauracracy and siphoned to the Chief and his/her family and friends while their homes crumble and their children keep joining gangs.

I think this is a good example of why it's important to set up a specific service as opposed to just giving money with an intended purpose, and why method is very under-rated.
Edited by Roughneck on Sep 22, 2010 10:48:03
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roughneck
Maybe it's another case of best intentions not following through. One group can claim that they wanted to feed other kids by issuing food stamps and another group can claim that they wanted to feed their children by recieving food stamps. However, if the one group fails to issue stamps for some reason, and the other group is too high or drunk to go shopping for food, children remain hungry. This doesn't mean all of the children, but I can see how a percentage still get the short end of the stick. I believe there is always money somewhere to help with this issue, but it boils down to administration, one way or another.
It's like issuing monies to the native reservations in Canada, but watching it get tied up in Band beauracracy and siphoned to the Chief and his/her family and friends while their homes crumble and their children keep joining gangs.
I think this is a good example of why it's important to set up a specific service as opposed to just giving money with an intended purpose, and why method is very under-rated.


i fully agree that foodstamps are inefficient, but they are effective. i'm just saying i'd rather overfund them until the problem is addressed, and then go through and tweak the process for efficiency.
 
Gnosis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NObodyn0se
The Democrats are the party in power now. They are in no way an opposition party.


They are an opposition party to the majority of Americans.


Originally posted by NObodyn0se
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/1209/30393.html

The faster the Republicans die off, the faster a sane opposition party can come take its place.


So you and your radical leftist ideology is the definition of "sane"?

Thanks for the laugh.

Edited by Canaan Cracker on Sep 22, 2010 11:22:27
Edited by Canaan Cracker on Sep 22, 2010 11:21:28
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Canaan Cracker
They are an opposition party to the majority of Americans.

lol?!?

oh sulfa, you just get better and better.
 
Gnosis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NObodyn0se

The Republicans have gone off the fucking DEEP END the last few years.


Do tell.

 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
It's only a democracy when my side wins -- Einstein
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.