User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Question to the Community - OL Blocking
Page:
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
It looks like the majority are exploit blitzes taking advantage of the ridiculous blocking code.


Sacker Backer clocks in at 40+ on the DB speed script on some of those plays. Is it an exploit to have a super fast guy? Nah.

It's just that the blocking code cant handle it, and pretty much needs to be scrapped and re-drawn from a clean slate to handle this and the myriad of other issues.
 
coach
offline
Link
 
Not an exploit. Overload blitzes happen in the NFL too. They often result in an unblocked defender getting to the QB very quickly. The guard sure doesn't get over there to pick him up. The "real life" options are a sack, a hurry, or blitzer picked up by a RB.

The only thing that needs fixing here is the HB/FB pass blocking logic, which has always been terrible. For now if you're playing against a blitzing LB, you better leave the TE in to block.

And don't be predictable. If the other team knows you're going to pass it's realistic that they can pin back their ears and get after the QB. Blitzing LBs are a fairly specialized build... make him try to tackle your power back.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coach
The "real life" options are a sack, a hurry, or blitzer picked up by a RB.

The only thing that needs fixing here is the HB/FB pass blocking logic, which has always been terrible. For now if you're playing against a blitzing LB, you better leave the TE in to block.



Or having the QB step up in the pocket. You're leaving out that one, and its a biggie.


 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coach
Not an exploit. Overload blitzes happen in the NFL too. They often result in an unblocked defender getting to the QB very quickly. The guard sure doesn't get over there to pick him up. The "real life" options are a sack, a hurry, or blitzer picked up by a RB.

The only thing that needs fixing here is the HB/FB pass blocking logic, which has always been terrible. For now if you're playing against a blitzing LB, you better leave the TE in to block.

And don't be predictable. If the other team knows you're going to pass it's realistic that they can pin back their ears and get after the QB. Blitzing LBs are a fairly specialized build... make him try to tackle your power back.


+1
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
First, using KC highlights is skewing your data plenty. Sacker backer is one of the all time great pass rush LBs, he will always do things few others can, nerfing based on what he does will make all LB blitzes useless again. He is now, and until overly declined, the top of the Blitzing LB spectrum, and should remain that way regardless of code changes. Some of his sacks may be exploity, but if they all were, then many more LBs would be putting up those numbers.

The O-line passing some checks pre-snap to slide coverage would be a good idea. Based on vision for them (somehow together), if they can spot blitz (based on the player's actual assignment) coming for players within a certain box (within 5 yards of LOS, within halfway between the OT and a slot WR), they shift their blocking assignments. OT takes the OLB, G takes the DE, etc. They should have false positives (call blitz, shift protection, no blitz, leading to confusions) sometimes. Additionally, the proximity to the line should influnence the check - currently, defenses face no penalty for brining 8 or 9 men down to the LOS.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't have a problem with overload blitzes if the line didn't stand there with their thumb up their butt. 3 man rush(one a LB) getting pressure should never happen, even against the 5 WR set.


And while the LB might be fast in some of those examples, his placement screams exploit because he is piggy backing on the DE taking advantage of a double team on the OT with no help from the guard.

And that particular defensive alignment is posted all over the defensive exploit forums.
Edited by Mightyhalo on Dec 4, 2009 14:00:12
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

And that particular defensive alignment is posted all over the defensive exploit forums.


invite plz
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe Buck
invite plz


 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Blitzing LBs should be buffed if anything, not nerfed. Overload blitzes should result in more sacks. If anything, it should be a high risk-reward scenario where the offense can find a gap in the coverage and make a big play, but also fall victim to the occasional sack.
 
GoHooterGo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coach
Not an exploit. Overload blitzes happen in the NFL too. They often result in an unblocked defender getting to the QB very quickly. The guard sure doesn't get over there to pick him up. The "real life" options are a sack, a hurry, or blitzer picked up by a RB.

The only thing that needs fixing here is the HB/FB pass blocking logic, which has always been terrible. For now if you're playing against a blitzing LB, you better leave the TE in to block.

And don't be predictable. If the other team knows you're going to pass it's realistic that they can pin back their ears and get after the QB. Blitzing LBs are a fairly specialized build... make him try to tackle your power back.


+1
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
None of the rerplays in the OP should are an overload blitz in mind view.
- HB/RB should allow to chip ? only if it can be set by play (user or Bort) and it should cost the HB about 1-2 second before he can go to the route
- TE should automatically chip before the taking on the route (unless one has a per play override)

In all these replays the OL had hard time defeating the blitz since it reacts slowly (or just don't make pre-snap read correctly). Here is a very clear examples:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=915442&pbp_id=328506
There are 5 defenders on the LOS, guess what is coming ? Since the HB/TE do not help in the protection the defenders on the LOS should be first priorities. Clearly the OL disregarded the LOLB pre-snap.

Bringing in a OLB blitz should be effective in my view, specially since in most of the replays the defense took a big gamble (leaving the inside open). An outside blitz like in the replay above is hard to block even when the OL is prepared. A good situation for the sim is that this kind of blitzes will give mixed result, sometime getting sack/hurries sometimes getting picked up.

In real life obvious blitzing players like that can be handled by audible/ hot route. For example the HB that see the LOLB passing by, shouts 'blitz' and look for a quick dump pass from the QB. Obviously GLB sim is not ready for this.


 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
None of the rerplays in the OP should are an overload blitz in mind view.
- HB/RB should allow to chip ? only if it can be set by play (user or Bort) and it should cost the HB about 1-2 second before he can go to the route
- TE should automatically chip before the taking on the route (unless one has a per play override)

In all these replays the OL had hard time defeating the blitz since it reacts slowly (or just don't make pre-snap read correctly). Here is a very clear examples:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=915442&pbp_id=328506
There are 5 defenders on the LOS, guess what is coming ? Since the HB/TE do not help in the protection the defenders on the LOS should be first priorities. Clearly the OL disregarded the LOLB pre-snap.

Bringing in a OLB blitz should be effective in my view, specially since in most of the replays the defense took a big gamble (leaving the inside open). An outside blitz like in the replay above is hard to block even when the OL is prepared. A good situation for the sim is that this kind of blitzes will give mixed result, sometime getting sack/hurries sometimes getting picked up.

In real life obvious blitzing players like that can be handled by audible/ hot route. For example the HB that see the LOLB passing by, shouts 'blitz' and look for a quick dump pass from the QB. Obviously GLB sim is not ready for this.





It should be noted too that the Rampage OAI had a massive snafu (so far havent reported it to bugs yet) where we ran 0 inside running plays despite having a vanilla offense set up to do that 33% of the time.

Our normal down / distance was turned off except for end of the half.
 
Bleeds
offline
Link
 
I think there were only 2 plays listed where at least 1 of the FB/HB/TE stayed in to block.

Both the O and D went High Risk/High Reward and the defense won the battle.

I wouldn't call it an exploit unless there's no way to counter it. Show some plays where guys stay in.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
It seems like the more we find blitz "exploits" and close them, the more pointless pass rushing and blitzing becomes. Something has to work, doesn't it?

This just looks like super fast LB and an OC who isn't interested in blocking him.

So many of these exploits just look like good DPC work to me. I've seen a lot of 1 sack and no sack games in this first round of sims.
Edited by Fumanchuchu on Dec 4, 2009 22:34:55
Edited by Fumanchuchu on Dec 4, 2009 22:34:45
 
Jaked08
offline
Link
 
Overload, HB on pass. Should HB chip him?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=915442&pbp_id=323489



I don't even think the HB seen him, lol.

He probably blinked and the OLB ran right by him.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.