User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Blocking TE not actually blocking anyone
Page:
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
I've had a post on the team forum for seasons of this stuff happening...These are not isolated incidents...They are very very common.


Well I assume they are if you pick out just the bad ones. Understand that I see nothing as far as data. What I'm saying is take that play and run your offensive scout tool for all 15 games played so far. Take the total # of times that play was called against the total # of times the TE looks drunk and get me a percentage.....If it's happening 10% or less I'd say just failing vision checks. If it's anything over 10% we could have a legitimate problem.

What is your TE(s) vision for the sake of curiosity. Over/Under 60?
Edited by jbleich on Nov 11, 2009 15:20:21
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Well I assume they are if you pick out just the bad ones. Understand that I see nothing as far as data. What I'm saying is take that play and run your offensive scout tool for all 15 games played so far. Take the total # of times that was played against the total # of times the TE looks drunk and get me a percentage.....If it's happening 10% or less I'd say just failing vision checks. If it's anything over 10% we could have a legitimate problem.

What is your TE(s) vision for the sake of curiosity. Over/Under 60?


64


%'s on a widescale basis would skew what you are trying to get at because it depends on the defense. If there is nobody in the strong side area the TE goes to block...He just fails...
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vagrant God
If it is too much speed/agility, then there is something wrong with the sim.
If it is too little vision, then there is something wrong with the sim.

Builds should not affect common sense, such as running down the field when you are suppose to block. Until they make an intelligence attribute, you cannot blame the build for this.

Either this is a bug, or (even scarier) it is working as intended. If it is truly the latter, there is something wrong with Bort.


Vision = Intelligence

And I guess you've never watched a football game where a blocker goes upfield, looks around, realizes he has no one to block, gets a bit lost, and just decides to block the first guy he sees so at least he's doing something.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by jbleich

Well I assume they are if you pick out just the bad ones. Understand that I see nothing as far as data. What I'm saying is take that play and run your offensive scout tool for all 15 games played so far. Take the total # of times that was played against the total # of times the TE looks drunk and get me a percentage.....If it's happening 10% or less I'd say just failing vision checks. If it's anything over 10% we could have a legitimate problem.

What is your TE(s) vision for the sake of curiosity. Over/Under 60?


64


%'s on a widescale basis would skew what you are trying to get at because it depends on the defense. If there is nobody in the strong side area the TE goes to block...He just fails...


64 is not enough.

 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Also, on pitches his vision is 83 with outside blocker VA.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
64 is not enough.



See next post.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
64 is not enough.



And, in terms of reality and not your assumption, of course it isn't enough...because it's f*cked up...1000 vision wouldn't help this.
Edited by Jiddy78 on Nov 11, 2009 15:29:57
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Vision = Intelligence

And I guess you've never watched a football game where a blocker goes upfield, looks around, realizes he has no one to block, gets a bit lost, and just decides to block the first guy he sees so at least he's doing something.


He fails on the line if there is nobody up top like the example where the SS is lined up over the line. It's as simple as that.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
64


%'s on a widescale basis would skew what you are trying to get at because it depends on the defense. If there is nobody in the strong side area the TE goes to block...He just fails...


Understood, but you also cant just pick out a few plays and say something is broken if you dont have the proof to back it up. You have to have a way of duplicating that exact off/def and run it 100 times and see what you get

*cough* Test Server *cough*
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
He fails on the line if there is nobody up top like the example where the SS is lined up over the line. It's as simple as that.


Well, it really isn't all that simple, because it's a matter of if the sim isn't good enough for him to actually throw a proper block out of ideal conditions, if despite you thinking you have enough Vision to make that check, if that is true or not (and then there's the matter of if it "should" be enough), or if there's "too much Speed/Agility" (which really means that he needs to start to try to throw a block sooner if he gets out there faster, which goes right back to either needing more Vision to make the read faster or the sim needs to compensate for the fact that he's out there faster and allow him to try to make the read faster.....or have it work something like a HB following a slower FB where he doesn't go top speed and slows down so he's in better position to throw a block).


So really, it's not that simple at all.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Understood, but you also cant just pick out a few plays and say something is broken if you dont have the proof to back it up. You have to have a way of duplicating that exact off/def and run it 100 times and see what you get

*cough* Test Server *cough*


I will report back every single play over the past 12 seasons that Fructose has done this on this mother f*cking board if you promise to spend your every waking glb moment working on getting it fixed thereafter...because I'll make your ass look silly with the countless examples....but I want a return on my investment.

Deal?
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Well, it really isn't all that simple, because it's a matter of if the sim isn't good enough for him to actually throw a proper block out of ideal conditions, if despite you thinking you have enough Vision to make that check, if that is true or not (and then there's the matter of if it "should" be enough), or if there's "too much Speed/Agility" (which really means that he needs to start to try to throw a block sooner if he gets out there faster, which goes right back to either needing more Vision to make the read faster or the sim needs to compensate for the fact that he's out there faster and allow him to try to make the read faster.....or have it work something like a HB following a slower FB where he doesn't go top speed and slows down so he's in better position to throw a block).


So really, it's not that simple at all.


That's a good point. If he gets out there too damn fast the vision check is going to be harder hence not seeing the SS at all and going downfield.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
I will report back every single play over the past 12 seasons that Fructose has done this on this mother f*cking board if you promise to spend your every waking glb moment working on getting it fixed thereafter...because I'll make your ass look silly with the countless examples....but I want a return on my investment.

Deal?


I need the same play and show when it works as well. You cant get a fail percentage w/out that.

And make my ass look silly? I'm not doubting you buddy, I'm just saying that you probobly arent even noticing the times it works. It really does have to be tested in a controlled environment.

PM a tester and ask them to setup this test, give him your TE's build and have them run the same freaking play and then we can get our tallies.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Well, it really isn't all that simple, because it's a matter of if the sim isn't good enough for him to actually throw a proper block out of ideal conditions, if despite you thinking you have enough Vision to make that check, if that is true or not (and then there's the matter of if it "should" be enough), or if there's "too much Speed/Agility" (which really means that he needs to start to try to throw a block sooner if he gets out there faster, which goes right back to either needing more Vision to make the read faster or the sim needs to compensate for the fact that he's out there faster and allow him to try to make the read faster.....or have it work something like a HB following a slower FB where he doesn't go top speed and slows down so he's in better position to throw a block).


So really, it's not that simple at all.


Much like after a one night stand and asking the girl to leave the next morning, I am kindly asking if you would refrain from responding to me ever again regarding this issue...and I will return the favor in kind. You and I are not going to see eye-to-eye. So no use running the hamster cage.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
That's a good point. If he gets out there too damn fast the vision check is going to be harder hence not seeing the SS at all and going downfield.


How fast is too fast? This should be laughable.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.