User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > AI is Getting More and More Buggy - Calling Incorrect Plays
Page:
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
I appreciate the feedback, and have caught myself many times making the little errors you are referring to.

But these don't fall under those. I have tested them to death.

The AI couldn't be more basic.

If they are in Str I - Use X play
If they are in Goalline - Use Y play
etc.

The reason it is so glaring to me this season is that with this particular team, I am only using one output per formation, with another catchall play for 3rd and long 3WRs, and 2WRs.

The goalline defense should never be called unless the opponent is running goalline. My guess is that there is a problem with the way the players are lined up or something that is making the Def AI think the Offense is in goalline formation.


The most common error I found in previous seasons is that it would use the Shotgun defense when the opponent was lined up with 5WRs. For some reason the AI isn't picking up the opposition's formation. Again, this is a glaring error because it was almost always a TD, with two WRS running downfield uncovered.

Edit: And yes I had the 5WR input ahead of the Shotgun input.
Edited by The Duff Man on Oct 29, 2009 12:36:09
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
I appreciate the feedback, and have caught myself many times making the little errors you are referring to.

But these don't fall under those. I have tested them to death.

The AI couldn't be more basic.

If they are in Str I - Use X play
If they are in Goalline - Use Y play
etc.

The reason it is so glaring to me this season is that with this particular team, I am only using one output per formation, with another catchall play for 3rd and long 3WRs, and 2WRs.

The goalline defense should never be called unless the opponent is running goalline. My guess is that there is a problem with the way the players are lined up or something that is making the Def AI think the Offense is in goalline formation.


The most common error I found in previous seasons is that it would use the Shotgun defense when the opponent was lined up with 5WRs. For some reason the AI isn't picking up the opposition's formation. Again, this is a glaring error because it was almost always a TD, with two WRS running downfield uncovered.

Edit: And yes I had the 5WR input ahead of the Shotgun input.


My example was actually the same. In the last Snipers game we had a defense loaded, but at the very top I had 3 inputs, one for all 2WR sets, one for all 3WR sets, one for all 5WR sets. They were in effect anytime we were up by 14+. For most of the game it worked fine, but randomly different things started happening.

here's the play that was supposed to be called on all 1st and 2nd down 2WR sets at this point: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818612&pbp_id=9029592

This is a random play that showed up on a first down in the 4th quarter (note SS suddenly covering WR2): http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818612&pbp_id=9030954

There were some 3-4 zones that showed up during this quarter, but they were correct as I had them in the 4th Quarter AI for some situations. Where that play that has the SS doubling the WR came from I have no idea. SS's only assignment for the play that could be active there is to cover man w/o move TE, or blitz.

Only one output per input, everything filled in (less than 900 seconds, 1st through 4th down, 0-100 yards to go, no one tagged, any formation, 2WRs score between +14 and +500). I always fill it all out and I have almost never been able to find an AI error that wasn't caused by me. There is no room for interpretation on this though - AI just decided to call an audible on us.
 
Warthog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roger6363
The best thing to do is go to test AI and put the exact situation in and see what comes up..


We lost a game today by two points when we ran a FB dive at the opponents 19 yard line with 7 seconds to go. Run the AI test for the exact situation we were in and it said:

Matching Input
Input Named: End of Half FG (0 TO's)

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)

In fact, the play before this, because the clock was at 30 secs, also comes back with the output to kick the FG.

So this BS cost us a game today, as long as our kicker could make a 36 yard FG.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=817821&mode=pbp

 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warthog
Originally posted by Roger6363

The best thing to do is go to test AI and put the exact situation in and see what comes up..


We lost a game today by two points when we ran a FB dive at the opponents 19 yard line with 7 seconds to go. Run the AI test for the exact situation we were in and it said:

Matching Input
Input Named: End of Half FG (0 TO's)

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)

In fact, the play before this, because the clock was at 30 secs, also comes back with the output to kick the FG.

So this BS cost us a game today, as long as our kicker could make a 36 yard FG.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=817821&mode=pbp



99% chance this is an AI error somehow. This isn't exactly the same as a random play being called. I've seen a lot of AIs and a lot of plays, and I have yet to see the sim fail to kick a FG when the AI was set properly to do so. I've seen it run the wrong play in many situations, but never in this situation.

I don't trust the tester, tbh. I'd go over my AI more carefully, about 20 times if required.
 
Warthog
offline
Link
 
For the ball spot, the AI says " Between Opponent 35 and Opponent Goal" in that order. Does it make a difference which way that sequence is?
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warthog
Originally posted by Roger6363

The best thing to do is go to test AI and put the exact situation in and see what comes up..


We lost a game today by two points when we ran a FB dive at the opponents 19 yard line with 7 seconds to go. Run the AI test for the exact situation we were in and it said:

Matching Input
Input Named: End of Half FG (0 TO's)

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)

In fact, the play before this, because the clock was at 30 secs, also comes back with the output to kick the FG.

So this BS cost us a game today, as long as our kicker could make a 36 yard FG.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=817821&mode=pbp



Do you have this input for the 4th quarter and if so is it at the top of the 4th quarter inputs?
 
Warthog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sixx
Do you have this input for the 4th quarter and if so is it at the top of the 4th quarter inputs?


Yes, in fact we have TWO outputs at the top of the fourth quarter inputs that address kicking the FG.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.