User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
with football genius he was at 91 vision.....

The Sim should be recognizing it is 3rd and 17.5, and when the qb threw the ball the hb was closing in on the 1st down marker, further down field then the receiver who was targeted. I feel like everything you just typed was completely wrong in every sense of the word.


I was joking about the needs more vision that seems to be the canned answer when things like this happen


But aside from the "needs more vision" I dont feel I am wrong. I figure, I put myself at QB in that play. I see my primary WR is double covered and as I take step 2-3 on my 5 step dropback, the HB is basically right next to me so I'm going to look to my #3 option who I know is further down field just based off the play called. I see he is in single coverage, I know he can make the catch when he makes the turn and the DB creates separation when my guy cuts back. But then I see a DE with a free running lane at me while I'm looking right at my #3 receiver. I'm not going to look back across the field the opposite direction and hope by now my HB is where I want him to be and still be uncovered (which is key because he may not have the hands to make a catch with a defender all over him) and hope I have time to throw to him if I do see that he is uncovered. Instead, I'll throw to the guy right in front of me where I'm looking to avoid getting hit by what looks like an unblocked DE at that point.

Yes, game logic should say, I know the HB is running a longer route and we need longer yards (which btw, is your QB set to open man, or route distance or wheres his slider?) but should the game logic know if that DE is going to get slowed by the OT or not?

Theres just too many variables imo, for it to be so black and white "he should have thrown it here" type of thing regardless if he had 300 vision.


IMO anyway.
Edited by deez11010 on Oct 24, 2009 02:42:27
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818061&pbp_id=7206728
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818061&pbp_id=7207929

Here's 2 more
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
It is as if Bort tweaked the sim, so that qb's have no brain. They used to throw to open man almost all of the time, something changed, and now it is completely random, and qb's have 0 brain. His goal for realistic stats is destroying the game. He should be aiming for making the passing game work, not making it pure random.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
It is as if Bort tweaked the sim, so that qb's have no brain. They used to throw to open man almost all of the time, something changed, and now it is completely random, and qb's have 0 brain.


QBs never had a brain. There are a lot of missing mechanics to the passing game as well. I have a suggestions thread to get up (along w/ 8 others ) that details it further, but basically QBs need to have a sense of throwing to open space (throwing to where only the receiver can get it, etc.). How often do we see a QB throw to a WR who has gotten open, but the QB throws it right to a location filled w/ defenders?

Anyways, QBs are going to "miss" wide open men occasionally. It's just the way it works, especially if they find themselves under pressure and/or they see another target moderately open. Even w/ 90+ vision, he's going to make the occasional mistake. If you want a QB that doesn't make mistakes, I suggest you hire a robot.

 
nottom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
QBs never had a brain. There are a lot of missing mechanics to the passing game as well. I have a suggestions thread to get up (along w/ 8 others ) that details it further, but basically QBs need to have a sense of throwing to open space (throwing to where only the receiver can get it, etc.). How often do we see a QB throw to a WR who has gotten open, but the QB throws it right to a location filled w/ defenders?

Anyways, QBs are going to "miss" wide open men occasionally. It's just the way it works, especially if they find themselves under pressure and/or they see another target moderately open. Even w/ 90+ vision, he's going to make the occasional mistake. If you want a QB that doesn't make mistakes, I suggest you hire a robot.



I think this is a good point about QBs throwing to space. Basically there aren't nearly enough passes missed because they are thrown away from the defense and the WR just doesn't get there. Has a WR ever been overthrown in this game?

In real football, a relatively small % of incompletions are actually a result of the defender getting a hand on the ball but it seems like this is the cause of most GLB incompletions.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by David Stern

It is as if Bort tweaked the sim, so that qb's have no brain. They used to throw to open man almost all of the time, something changed, and now it is completely random, and qb's have 0 brain.


QBs never had a brain. There are a lot of missing mechanics to the passing game as well. I have a suggestions thread to get up (along w/ 8 others ) that details it further, but basically QBs need to have a sense of throwing to open space (throwing to where only the receiver can get it, etc.). How often do we see a QB throw to a WR who has gotten open, but the QB throws it right to a location filled w/ defenders?

Anyways, QBs are going to "miss" wide open men occasionally. It's just the way it works, especially if they find themselves under pressure and/or they see another target moderately open. Even w/ 90+ vision, he's going to make the occasional mistake. If you want a QB that doesn't make mistakes, I suggest you hire a robot.



I think that right there is the biggest problem

Look how freakin LATE this throw comes:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=881011&pbp_id=7284015

If the QB threw it more often right as the route breaks, and lead them properly, the passing game would be a lot better.

BTW that QB has nearly 100 vision.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Oct 24, 2009 16:20:40
 
jpjn94
doc ock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe Buck
Hmmm last time we had a situation like this, it was the SB Flanker Drag play and the culprit was a misplaced comma that invalidating both HB and WR1 as valid targets in the checkdown list for the QB. (The checkdown lists for the QB's each play are separated by commas, like so: HB,WR1,WR2,TE, WR3, etc. For the Flanker Drag bug the first comma was missing and so it was telling the QB to look for a player with the id HBWR1, and HB and WR1 were never thrown to because they didnt exist in the QB's binary eyes....)

Do we have any instances of the HB ever getting a pass target from this specific play?


This point shouldn't be lost in this thread.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jpjn94
This point shouldn't be lost in this thread.


I suspect this is the exact issue fucking with WR3 on Reverse Slant
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom


I think this is a good point about QBs throwing to space. Basically there aren't nearly enough passes missed because they are thrown away from the defense and the WR just doesn't get there. Has a WR ever been overthrown in this game?

.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=834648&pbp_id=6929151

 
nottom
offline
Link
 
Wow, I've honestly never seen that.

That was actually a great example because if you look as the ball goes past, the WR dot was just starting to create a little distance between himself and the CB dots. There should be a lot more of that type of throw rather than the typical jump-ball against 3 defender dots.
 
Link
 
We actually think that the QB forgot he was throwing to Speedy, we think he though he was throwing to Bizarro superman and was hoping his flying cap VA would kick in.



But yea, thats the first time I've seen that throw myself.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.