User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > 38 Cap games are becoming 1-dimensional (only rushing)
Page:
 
Falanor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
The premise I disagree with is that speed is actually a prerequisite to effective pass blocking. I had a LOT that never put a point in speed, and he was starting in AAA last year as a level 48-51, and gave up no sacks in the regular season. He had spent the prior three seasons just training it.


That's quite possible to just train instead of putting any points in it. Three season of training is a lot of points, figure you got around 45-50 at that point, which is helpful when messing with a DE that's got around 90/90. It's something that has helped on other teams that I've worked with in keeping the ends from getting through unimpeded to the QB. Anyways, back to the original poster, enough hijacking.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by headsigh
I've been fine passing the ball so far. Maybe I'm not getting the protection as much as I want, but in no way have I relied on the run so much.

As a question: how many hurries has your QB had in the previous games?


Well it's hard to say. This game, I got most linemen to focus on run blocking. The past 2 regular season games, we played gutted teams. Some of our scrimmages have been very competitive. There, I think the protection has been pretty good...it's just that somehow we can't pass well.

I'm kind of starting to agree with everyone that's saying that it can be fixed with tactics/builds. It's still unlikely that passing will become equal to running this season (for this league).
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Falanor
That's quite possible to just train instead of putting any points in it. Three season of training is a lot of points, figure you got around 45-50 at that point, which is helpful when messing with a DE that's got around 90/90. It's something that has helped on other teams that I've worked with in keeping the ends from getting through unimpeded to the QB. Anyways, back to the original poster, enough hijacking.


Meh. OP's question has been answered, both here and in PM. I think rabbit trails are fair game in this situation.

And yes, he was around 45 last season, and has climbed all the way to 52 this season, again strictly training Spd/Stam. He's not starting on that same team in Pro, but you wouldn't really expect a level 55 to be able to start and be effective at that level. It's one thing taking on 2nd rate level 60 builds as a 48, it's completely different taking on top-shelf level 65-70 as a 55.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
IMO the problem is the inability for WRs to get separation from CBs. Because I'm lazy I'm going to quote what I have said in another thread. Most of it is relevant and I think you can get my points.

Originally posted by butler312
So fix the ability for WRs to beat CBs. IMO that is the source of this problem. Even though it seems to be the trend here, the way to solve a problem is not to compensate for it someplace else. If a 110 speed, 70 agility WR could easily create lots of separation from a 90 speed, 60 agility corner when in single coverage than we wouldn't have a problem with all the deflected and knocked loose passes.


Originally posted by butler312
But QBs SHOULD be missing open receivers and having bad throws. You act like 100+ throwing and 80 vision is great but that actually is not that uncommon at the capped level. Players should not be making every throw halfway through their career. Not every QB should be able to throw like Manning and the ones that can shouldn't be able to until the very end of their career.


Originally posted by butler312
But they should be right now (CBs should be overmatched by WRs). And thats really the way it is in most phases of football. Most decent WRs can beat single coverage. A true shutdown corner is pretty rare. That is why it is so important to get pressure on a QB.

Also, on the other side players should require much more strength and catching to come down with passes in traffic. Right now its pretty ridiculous seeing all these WRs with no strength and only average catching coming down with passes in triple coverage. I think vision should also play a pretty heavy role in running good routes. Those could keep the corners from being overmatched against the pure speed WRs.


Originally posted by butler312
Along the same lines, changes like I mentioned a few points back could allow for a true possession WR to emerge. I'd love to see slot WRs who only have average speed but who have great vision and catching, combined with the possession WR VA, who are monsters on catching short passes in coverage. Add in an option for the QB to go to this WR when everything else is covered and you really start to make some huge progress in the passing game and diversifying builds.



 
Link
 
Passing doesnt work very well at medium levels anymore. Low levels are worse. Bort designed the game to work at high levels, late in players' careers... The rest of the game doesn't scale well.
 
TheSandman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Passing doesnt work very well at medium levels anymore. Low levels are worse. Bort designed the game to work at high levels, late in players' careers... The rest of the game doesn't scale well.


With all of the uneven builds at the middle and lower levels it shouldn't. I think that it's a silly notion that Bort should make further changes to the game because people don't like the fact that their player isn't playing all that great in the minors. In all honesty, Bort's biggest mistake was making tons of changes early in the game based off what was happening with the earlier builds of the older players. Everything is out of whack now because of it imo.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheSandman
With all of the uneven builds at the middle and lower levels it shouldn't. I think that it's a silly notion that Bort should make further changes to the game because people don't like the fact that their player isn't playing all that great in the minors. In all honesty, Bort's biggest mistake was making tons of changes early in the game based off what was happening with the earlier builds of the older players. Everything is out of whack now because of it imo.


I agree, but to me this all comes back to slow/cap building. I know the majority of posters will hate me for saying this, but I honestly believe it is in the best interest of the game to get rid of all incentives to slow build. If builds are more balanced at the lower levels it will be more fun for everyone.
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
Also, passing is less effective, because blitzing is nerfed.
So DC's aren't blitzing players, which makes it harder to complete passes.

I am learning that many things in the game are related to other things.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Defensive builds are made to stop the pass first, run second.
Offensive builds are made to run first, pass second.

Leads to a lot of imbalance.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
When my CBs have racked up INTs and PDs it's been mostly been from the mid-30's to mid 40's, and then slowly evened out from there.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
IMO the problem is the inability for WRs to get separation from CBs. Because I'm lazy I'm going to quote what I have said in another thread. Most of it is relevant and I think you can get my points.


Some of us have figured out how to get separation from CB's.

I'm sorry that you haven't.

 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Originally posted by AMP


That's because the offense was nerfed in in the WRONG WAY. QBs with GREAT BUILDS are now missing open receivers and throwing "Bad Throw"s despite having 100+ throwing and 80-90+ vision. That's a nerf for sure, but it's still wrong.


But they SHOULD be missing open receivers and having bad throws. You act like 100+ throwing and 80 vision is great but that actually not that uncommon at the capped level. Players should not be making every throw halfway through their career. Not every QB should be able to throw like Manning and the ones that can't shouldn't be able to until the very end of their career.


This is true, I would like to see a GOOD throw every once in a while though too. I think making speed more linear would solve a lot of the problems.CB/WR Interaction would be much better. WR's could burn CB's and CB's could still keep their angles and cushions. DE/O-Line interaction would be better as well if speed was linear.


Another Fix that would help is defensive pathing for the secondary (Contain/Attack Combo's) Instead of just 100% Contain all the time. The ability to get pressure from the DT/NT spots would help as well. If the DT/NT were useful positions you could then have collapsing pockets, more pressure, and sacks.

Change Blocking Focus on the O-Line to boost/subtract att's. For example

Originally posted by Adderfist

Run Block
+Blocking
+Strength
-Agility

Pass Blocking
+Blocking
+Agility
-Strength

Balanced Blocking
+Blocking



When the ball changes hands -ever- a vision check should have to be in place that scales with time. Currently short passing over the middle is still terrible because BLITZING DE's can go back and deflect passes/tackle players.

Play action needs to be implemented. Using said vision checks- Play action could be very easy to implement. When a Play action is used, you would have everyone try and pass a vision check that scales with time. If they fail the check they act like the play action player has the ball. When they succeed in fooling the defense it could open some plays up.

Both the Vision check, and the Play Should modify how M2M is adjusted.

Slotting system on vision- In vision it shouldn't be a matter of 1's or 0's. It should be a 3 zoned area. Didn't Notice|Faked|Beat the fake. Sometimes not even seeing the fake is the reason for a plays success in real life.



Currently, running- At all levels is still Much, Much better then passing. After making the defense able to create pressure and attack the Offense correctly, the long ball for QB needs to be easier.

-Adder

(ib4 tl;dr)
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
I think the passing game is extremely ugly this season. QBs so rarely throw to the open man that even when WRs get separation they don't get thrown to. Then when the QB throws to the deep man even when wide open he is pretty inconsistent even compared to pretty bad NFL QBs. WRs catch way too many balls with great coverage and several defenders in position to make the play and drop (or bad throw) too many wide open passes. The entire offensive line can set to run block and not have to worry about leaving guys in to block.

The running game is powerful since so many teams are dropping 8-9 men in coverage since blitzing is pointless and with zone specialist they can recover against the run and still only give up a few yards against the run.

Fix QBs and fix offensive/defensive line interaction plus blitzing and it will fix everything.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
I think the passing game is extremely ugly this season. QBs so rarely throw to the open man that even when WRs get separation they don't get thrown to.


Fix your gameplan, and fix your QB's tactics.

Originally posted by
Then when the QB throws to the deep man even when wide open he is pretty inconsistent even compared to pretty bad NFL QBs. WRs catch way too many balls with great coverage and several defenders in position to make the play and drop (or bad throw) too many wide open passes. The entire offensive line can set to run block and not have to worry about leaving guys in to block.


Fix your tactics.

Originally posted by
The running game is powerful since so many teams are dropping 8-9 men in coverage since blitzing is pointless and with zone specialist they can recover against the run and still only give up a few yards against the run.

Fix QBs and fix offensive/defensive line interaction plus blitzing and it will fix everything.


Fix your tactics and your gameplan, and all will be well, I promise.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
Some of us have figured out how to get separation from CB's. I'm sorry that you haven't.

Comments like these are why people don't like you. Remember a month ago when I said that I had never seen you post anything productive in the public forums? You responded by posting a couple of good things that prompted some interesting discussion. Unfortunately you went right back to your old habits. If you know something that might help another user, either share that information or just keep quiet. Claiming that you know an "answer" and then mocking someone else over it makes you look incredibly bad.


Oh, and PierreThomas knows infinitely more about this game than you do. Telling him to "fix his ______" makes you look like a complete idiot to anyone who actually knows his username.
Edited by jdbolick on Oct 18, 2009 19:44:45
Edited by jdbolick on Oct 18, 2009 19:44:31
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.