User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > The whole cover man stopping completely is getting real old
Page:
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Moar vision

But vision is over 90 (with mentor)!

Moar vision, bitch!

*sigh*
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
IF this is a pump fake that I will once again state what I and many others have stated in previous threads similar to this. That is a flat out inexcusable coding for fakes. In football a player does not get faked out by a receiver (or ball carrier) who is already by them and running full speed. They should be turned around and sprinting to catch up.

And in general, almost anytime a player is faked out while covering a receiver they should not simply stop. They should take a step or two in the wrong direction or react slowly to a receivers cuts. The only time I can think of when a fake would cause a receiver to stop is on maybe a stop and go route where the defender gets caught looking for the hitch or maybe some other type of double move. But in most of these replays that is clearly not the case as the receiver is just running a straight route.
 
URL54MVP
offline
Link
 
Anytime I see something like that I just assume pump fake anymore. Right or wrong? I dunno. But I agree it is annoying to see a defender just flat out stop in his tracks like that.

That is a very high risk defense against single back though. You are essentially playing a Cover 0 there against a very talented Pro league offense. And the play call itself just exposed that risk as the WR2 and TE routes just acted to completely clear out that side of the field for the HB route and yeah, I would never trust a LB to cover in a situation like that.

And not just a Cover 0 but a 4-3 Cover 0 against Single Back 3WR. That has fail written all over it from the outset.
Edited by URL54MVP on Oct 16, 2009 23:38:23
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
I'm sure there will be the typical "it's a pump fake" garbage, but there is zero pump animation on this play as far as I can tell. The LB just - hold it - stops.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=834427&pbp_id=3946157

It's really getting old.


I see the pump fake animation clearly,
a few ticks before the LB stops dead, QB is moving backwards, the ball doesn't go backwards for 2 ticks (this the pump fake, fake throw) then the ball comes back and then the throw
Edited by EagleOtto on Oct 17, 2009 02:29:35
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
Originally posted by Toriq

I'm sure there will be the typical "it's a pump fake" garbage, but there is zero pump animation on this play as far as I can tell. The LB just - hold it - stops.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=834427&pbp_id=3946157

It's really getting old.


I see the pump fake animation clearly,
a few ticks before the LB stops dead, QB is moving backwards, the ball doesn't go backwards for 2 ticks (this the pump fake, fake throw) then the ball comes back and then the throw


Yeah. I'm sure that's a pump fake. You have to really slow it down - frame by frame. It seems that the new animation (and the somewhat recent addition of the third axis for height) makes it harder to spot a pump fake.

There's really nothing you can do to defend against pump fakes. I see it happen to players with 50 vision, 70 vision and even 90 vision. If the QB makes his fake roll, then you're screwed. The problem with how it works, as others have said, is the length of time that the faked player just stands there.

A pump fake should give the receiver a couple steps, and the advantage he needs to catch the pass, not open up the entire field to him.





Also...

Originally posted by URL54MVP
Anytime I see something like that I just assume pump fake anymore. Right or wrong? I dunno. But I agree it is annoying to see a defender just flat out stop in his tracks like that.

That is a very high risk defense against single back though. You are essentially playing a Cover 0 there against a very talented Pro league offense. And the play call itself just exposed that risk as the WR2 and TE routes just acted to completely clear out that side of the field for the HB route and yeah, I would never trust a LB to cover in a situation like that.

And not just a Cover 0 but a 4-3 Cover 0 against Single Back 3WR. That has fail written all over it from the outset.



I really doubt that a pro caliber DC isn't aware of that. I'm guessing they were expecting runs, and were playing accordingly. They got burnt. Nothing wrong with a little gambling now and then. Yeah, the play call was horrible against that particular play, but that's not the issue. The pump fake and the dot just standing there for a full second is the problem.
Edited by Forbin on Oct 17, 2009 02:48:46
 
turkishkamel
offline
Link
 
maybe the defender fell down? that happens sometimes, right?
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
I think one of the key points that everyone fails to see is that if this is a pump fake, nothing says it was a fake to the HB being covered by the LB who "stops". Sure, he may have fallen or got tangled up in a juke... or he could have failed his vision check on the pump fake to another receiver and just stopped his pursuit until he realized what was going on. That, unfortunately, does happen in real life.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Pump Fakes should be about fooling zone defenders, and individual WR fakes should be about fooling man cover guys.

 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Pump Fakes should be about fooling zone defenders, and individual WR fakes should be about fooling man cover guys.



/\
HS, College, and Pro ball. It looks the same when I watch the games.

Zone defense plays the Receiver & the QB.
M2M plays the Receiver.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Did Bort really intend for fakes to last over a second? It seems like they would be more realistic and appropriately powerful if they only stopped the defender for a couple of ticks.


This.

If it's working as intended, then bort's intentions are not right.

Either way, these types of plays are wrong and should be addressed.
Edited by tjking82 on Oct 17, 2009 09:01:45
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Pump Fakes should be about fooling zone defenders, and individual WR fakes should be about fooling man cover guys.



If a CB is set to aggressively go for the pick (or even the PD), a pump fake should still fool him.
 
Makalele
offline
Link
 
As it currently stands, all D players immediately start making a beeline towards an intended receiver when the ball is thrown (assuming they pass a vision check).

Wouldn't it be more consistent then to have a player that gets faked by a pump fake to spend 2-3 ticks running towards the receiver they believed was a target before returning to there coverage assignment. It would make more sense than stopping dead in their tracks, which is opposite of the typical reaction concerning a thrown ball.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
I believe the LOLB was in the strong 3rd flat zone.

Zone Players
-RDE
-NT
-ROLB
-MLB

M2m Players
-CB1 -> WR1
-CB2 -> WR2
-FS -> WR3
-SS -> TE

Your LOLB would have been lined up:
-Cover Man HB -> In the middle
-Cover Man HB Strong -> Outside near the WR

The only option that would have placed him there would have been Cover Man Without Move HB. That seems odd, as no other player m2m players were using Cover Man Without Move (at least not the FS or SS).

I would recommend you scrap this play. Don't use Zones uncovered. You abandoned the Strong Side by putting everyone into m2m on it. If you had put the LOLB in man against the TE, and pushed the SS down into the flat zone or underneath zone 3rd the HB would have been covered.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
fell down?
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
I'm sure there will be the typical "it's a pump fake" garbage, but there is zero pump animation on this play as far as I can tell. The LB just - hold it - stops.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=834427&pbp_id=3946157

It's really getting old.


there is a pump fake just a tick before he passes

the ball will make a subtle shuffle on a pump fake, it only gets passed when it is in the center of the QB dot
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.