yeah why exactly does does the new O line routine put 3-4 blockers on the LDE every play?
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Fundamental sim illogic is fundamentally illogical.
Strokke
offline
offline
Originally posted by griffin8r
5) QB passing slider = stupid. One prescribed style of throwing does not work for every situation. In the flat, a touch pass is often necessary to float over the defender to the receiver on the run. The long ball must have enough air under it to allow the receiver to adjust to it, but properly lead him. The slant must be fired as though it were shot out of a cannon. If the "throwing" attribute were really a measure of a QB's mechanical skills, it would reflect the QB knowing which type of throw was appropriate for the given situation. Fact is, throwing is the only thing that prevents a QB from driving it into the ground or overthrowing his receiver by 50 yards every play - and that is only when throwing gets up into the 90+ range. Which leads me to....
OMG YES. This is my first season OCing and I have been introduced to this silly slider. If you use too much bullet for better dump offs and slants... then the long passes don't make it over the secondary and are picked off/deflected. Too much loft improves long passes but gives the psychic defense time to get on top of your receiver before the ball even reaches him on anything else.
5) QB passing slider = stupid. One prescribed style of throwing does not work for every situation. In the flat, a touch pass is often necessary to float over the defender to the receiver on the run. The long ball must have enough air under it to allow the receiver to adjust to it, but properly lead him. The slant must be fired as though it were shot out of a cannon. If the "throwing" attribute were really a measure of a QB's mechanical skills, it would reflect the QB knowing which type of throw was appropriate for the given situation. Fact is, throwing is the only thing that prevents a QB from driving it into the ground or overthrowing his receiver by 50 yards every play - and that is only when throwing gets up into the 90+ range. Which leads me to....
OMG YES. This is my first season OCing and I have been introduced to this silly slider. If you use too much bullet for better dump offs and slants... then the long passes don't make it over the secondary and are picked off/deflected. Too much loft improves long passes but gives the psychic defense time to get on top of your receiver before the ball even reaches him on anything else.
Strokke
offline
offline
Originally posted by Darkstrand
yeah why exactly does does the new O line routine put 3-4 blockers on the LDE every play?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=803225&pbp_id=2064780
No clue.
yeah why exactly does does the new O line routine put 3-4 blockers on the LDE every play?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=803225&pbp_id=2064780
No clue.
kHarmaKillz
offline
offline
Originally posted by czman
The game has been in beta for a year and a half, what do you expect?
A working Sim?
Consistency?
Moderators who read above a 3rd grade level?
You forgot my favorite one. Players running the wrong direction and it being blamed on vision. Only in GLB does a failed roll=a player running away from the play.
Also passing in the low levels is terrible this season. Although that is what happens when testers only test high level players, because we all know that is all that matters.
The game has been in beta for a year and a half, what do you expect?
A working Sim?
Consistency?
Moderators who read above a 3rd grade level?
You forgot my favorite one. Players running the wrong direction and it being blamed on vision. Only in GLB does a failed roll=a player running away from the play.
Also passing in the low levels is terrible this season. Although that is what happens when testers only test high level players, because we all know that is all that matters.
kHarmaKillz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Originally posted by maz621
all good points... sadly none will be taken into consideration
Yup. Great post but every post like this dies...unless it spawns a 700 post whine thread.
Originally posted by maz621
all good points... sadly none will be taken into consideration
Yup. Great post but every post like this dies...unless it spawns a 700 post whine thread.
Staz
offline
offline
Originally posted by griffin8r
Come on, Bort. This stuff is beyond the pale now.
1) The whole level-up bonus thing needs scrapping and complete retooling. It is beyond insane that certain positions get enormous level-up bonuses on abilities that actually make them better, while many positions get shitball level-up bonuses and get them on attributes that don't do anything.
a) Tackling on O-linemen. I have yet to see a situation where any O-lineman failed to make a tackle on a fumble recovery because their tackling wasn't softcapped. In fact, I'm not aware of anyone ever softcapping tackling. I've also never seen tackling help an O-lineman catch and subsequently tackle a CB returning an INT.
b) Blocking on ALL defensive players, and you can't deny this, because whatever imaginary buff 60 blocking gives to a defensive lineman is far outweighed by same investment in other skills that actually help them reach ball carriers and tackle them).
c) The fact that LB's, CB's, WR's, and safeties all have stamina as a primary is beyond stupid. That's what depth charts are for.
d) O-Linemen don't get auto-level in speed, yet, if you ask a 10 speed guard to pull on a running play from your own 5 yard line, he will likely still be trying to make the corner when your RB is cashing it in the end zone. Oh, and this is more on your O-linemen making tackles bit - how is an O-lineman supposed to catch anyone to make a tackle on a turnover if they have no speed and they're up against a defense with speed at all positions?
I agree on all accounts. The thing is, why does this information not get to Bort? If it does, why can't we get SOME sort of reaction to it?
2) Blocking interaction is FUBAR. We all know it, so do you. Whatever anchor formula you have for blocking interaction is the problem, not all these tweaks back and forth.
a) When one lineman just stand there and does nothing while another lineman has to cut in FRONT of him to go make a block on the guy that was HIS RESPONSIBILITY in the blocking scheme, there is a problem with the basic formula.
b) When a TE is on one side of the line specifically to pick up a blitzer, yet ignores the blitzer and triple-teams the DE (along with the RB who is also in to pass block), despite the blitzer STANDING RIGHT IN FRONT OF HIM AT THE SNAP, there is a problem with the basic formula.
c) When a simple change of alignment TO THE INSIDE on a four man front can cause two O-Linemen to be completely incapable of blocking one DE, there is a problem with the basic formula.
d) O-Linemen on running plays don't do anything but push whoever is in front of them straight backwards. This is not how running lanes are opened in RL football. In fact, most of the time OL's take advantage of overly aggressive defenders by using their own momentum to push them just off to the side and out of the play so the RB can run through the now-vacated gap. Yet OL's in GLB are apparently not smart enough to figure out how to create a hole. More proof that the basic formula is broken.
Preach. The blocking code in GLB is all sort of 'funky'. It's not simple, it's not basic, and as far as I can tell, doesn't really follow REAL blocking behavior
3) CB's, SS's, and LB's with ESP is broken. This whole crap of coverage sticking to receivers like glue no matter where they go, as though they knew the routes in advance, is insane.
Again, truth. I would love to see a WR be able to run a streak a few times, and then hit the DB with a quick 10yd stop and watch the DB fall off the route and break his ankles. There is no "fooling" a defender, because there is no route memory or anticipation.
4) Pursuant to that point, RL receivers, when their QB is in trouble (granted, that lasts usually about 0.5 seconds in GLB before the QB is unceremoniously sacked by The Flash) break off their routes and try to find an opening. Again, doesn't happen in GLB. Once they reach the end of their assigned routes, they stand there, waiting for something to happen, as though the defenders assigned to cover them might get bored and wander off to make them open. Beyond stupidity, once again.
WRs in real life are often praised for their ability to "get open" when the QB is scrambling around. Hell, in NCAA Football 10, you get to choose HOW you want your WRs to get open after they finish their routes. Never, NEVER should a player be standing around while a play is live. Not even a Punter, and by NO means should the WR ever do this.
5) QB passing slider = stupid. One prescribed style of throwing does not work for every situation. In the flat, a touch pass is often necessary to float over the defender to the receiver on the run. The long ball must have enough air under it to allow the receiver to adjust to it, but properly lead him. The slant must be fired as though it were shot out of a cannon. If the "throwing" attribute were really a measure of a QB's mechanical skills, it would reflect the QB knowing which type of throw was appropriate for the given situation. Fact is, throwing is the only thing that prevents a QB from driving it into the ground or overthrowing his receiver by 50 yards every play - and that is only when throwing gets up into the 90+ range. Which leads me to....
Oh man. I don't know how many times I've gotten pissed about this. Like you mentioned, a slant is a totally different animal than a fade, or deep post. Not to mention, the passing PRIORITY is ridiculous as well. There are plays, like fades, streaks, posts, etc. where you want the QB to wait for the play to develop. But, stuff like slants, hooks, and most breaking routes, you want to hit the WR quickly. Basic football.
6) The whole 8-100 attribute system is completely broken, when viewed in the context of a player's career. It's a joke. Basically you have people with entry-level attributes that couldn't make the cut on a peewee team, and people with end-game attributes that are so far beyond superhuman it makes Marvel's roster look rather ordinary and pedestrian by comparison. 10 vision should not equal Down's Syndrome. 10 Speed should not equal Jabba The Hut. Why? Because, Bort, in your supreme wisdom, you decided on 11 seasons to be the functional life of a player. 11 seasons is just about right for the outer edge of a successful NFL career. Some defy those odds, but by and large most are washed up by that point. So why would players who are essentially NFL rookies when first rolled be so terrible that they cannot even function properly in a basic offense or defense? It boggles the mind.
Aight, getting off the soapox and bracing myself for the chorus of tl;dr.
Happy Columbus day.
And seriously, Bort. I rolled up 12 new players this season. If you can't fix this disaster of a sim before D41, I guarantee that I will drop my team ownership and retire every one of those little munchkins, because I don't have the patience for this shit anymore.
Come on, Bort. This stuff is beyond the pale now.
1) The whole level-up bonus thing needs scrapping and complete retooling. It is beyond insane that certain positions get enormous level-up bonuses on abilities that actually make them better, while many positions get shitball level-up bonuses and get them on attributes that don't do anything.
a) Tackling on O-linemen. I have yet to see a situation where any O-lineman failed to make a tackle on a fumble recovery because their tackling wasn't softcapped. In fact, I'm not aware of anyone ever softcapping tackling. I've also never seen tackling help an O-lineman catch and subsequently tackle a CB returning an INT.
b) Blocking on ALL defensive players, and you can't deny this, because whatever imaginary buff 60 blocking gives to a defensive lineman is far outweighed by same investment in other skills that actually help them reach ball carriers and tackle them).
c) The fact that LB's, CB's, WR's, and safeties all have stamina as a primary is beyond stupid. That's what depth charts are for.
d) O-Linemen don't get auto-level in speed, yet, if you ask a 10 speed guard to pull on a running play from your own 5 yard line, he will likely still be trying to make the corner when your RB is cashing it in the end zone. Oh, and this is more on your O-linemen making tackles bit - how is an O-lineman supposed to catch anyone to make a tackle on a turnover if they have no speed and they're up against a defense with speed at all positions?
I agree on all accounts. The thing is, why does this information not get to Bort? If it does, why can't we get SOME sort of reaction to it?
2) Blocking interaction is FUBAR. We all know it, so do you. Whatever anchor formula you have for blocking interaction is the problem, not all these tweaks back and forth.
a) When one lineman just stand there and does nothing while another lineman has to cut in FRONT of him to go make a block on the guy that was HIS RESPONSIBILITY in the blocking scheme, there is a problem with the basic formula.
b) When a TE is on one side of the line specifically to pick up a blitzer, yet ignores the blitzer and triple-teams the DE (along with the RB who is also in to pass block), despite the blitzer STANDING RIGHT IN FRONT OF HIM AT THE SNAP, there is a problem with the basic formula.
c) When a simple change of alignment TO THE INSIDE on a four man front can cause two O-Linemen to be completely incapable of blocking one DE, there is a problem with the basic formula.
d) O-Linemen on running plays don't do anything but push whoever is in front of them straight backwards. This is not how running lanes are opened in RL football. In fact, most of the time OL's take advantage of overly aggressive defenders by using their own momentum to push them just off to the side and out of the play so the RB can run through the now-vacated gap. Yet OL's in GLB are apparently not smart enough to figure out how to create a hole. More proof that the basic formula is broken.
Preach. The blocking code in GLB is all sort of 'funky'. It's not simple, it's not basic, and as far as I can tell, doesn't really follow REAL blocking behavior
3) CB's, SS's, and LB's with ESP is broken. This whole crap of coverage sticking to receivers like glue no matter where they go, as though they knew the routes in advance, is insane.
Again, truth. I would love to see a WR be able to run a streak a few times, and then hit the DB with a quick 10yd stop and watch the DB fall off the route and break his ankles. There is no "fooling" a defender, because there is no route memory or anticipation.
4) Pursuant to that point, RL receivers, when their QB is in trouble (granted, that lasts usually about 0.5 seconds in GLB before the QB is unceremoniously sacked by The Flash) break off their routes and try to find an opening. Again, doesn't happen in GLB. Once they reach the end of their assigned routes, they stand there, waiting for something to happen, as though the defenders assigned to cover them might get bored and wander off to make them open. Beyond stupidity, once again.
WRs in real life are often praised for their ability to "get open" when the QB is scrambling around. Hell, in NCAA Football 10, you get to choose HOW you want your WRs to get open after they finish their routes. Never, NEVER should a player be standing around while a play is live. Not even a Punter, and by NO means should the WR ever do this.
5) QB passing slider = stupid. One prescribed style of throwing does not work for every situation. In the flat, a touch pass is often necessary to float over the defender to the receiver on the run. The long ball must have enough air under it to allow the receiver to adjust to it, but properly lead him. The slant must be fired as though it were shot out of a cannon. If the "throwing" attribute were really a measure of a QB's mechanical skills, it would reflect the QB knowing which type of throw was appropriate for the given situation. Fact is, throwing is the only thing that prevents a QB from driving it into the ground or overthrowing his receiver by 50 yards every play - and that is only when throwing gets up into the 90+ range. Which leads me to....
Oh man. I don't know how many times I've gotten pissed about this. Like you mentioned, a slant is a totally different animal than a fade, or deep post. Not to mention, the passing PRIORITY is ridiculous as well. There are plays, like fades, streaks, posts, etc. where you want the QB to wait for the play to develop. But, stuff like slants, hooks, and most breaking routes, you want to hit the WR quickly. Basic football.
6) The whole 8-100 attribute system is completely broken, when viewed in the context of a player's career. It's a joke. Basically you have people with entry-level attributes that couldn't make the cut on a peewee team, and people with end-game attributes that are so far beyond superhuman it makes Marvel's roster look rather ordinary and pedestrian by comparison. 10 vision should not equal Down's Syndrome. 10 Speed should not equal Jabba The Hut. Why? Because, Bort, in your supreme wisdom, you decided on 11 seasons to be the functional life of a player. 11 seasons is just about right for the outer edge of a successful NFL career. Some defy those odds, but by and large most are washed up by that point. So why would players who are essentially NFL rookies when first rolled be so terrible that they cannot even function properly in a basic offense or defense? It boggles the mind.
Aight, getting off the soapox and bracing myself for the chorus of tl;dr.
Happy Columbus day.
And seriously, Bort. I rolled up 12 new players this season. If you can't fix this disaster of a sim before D41, I guarantee that I will drop my team ownership and retire every one of those little munchkins, because I don't have the patience for this shit anymore.
fallingmercury
offline
offline
I pretty much agree with everything in the OP.
Except sliders are a horrible idea for all positions, not just QB.
Except sliders are a horrible idea for all positions, not just QB.
xsujx
offline
offline
Originally posted by fallingmercury
...sliders are a horrible idea for all positions, not just QB.
...sliders are a horrible idea for all positions, not just QB.
tsherr
offline
offline
Originally posted by Strokke
OMG YES. This is my first season OCing and I have been introduced to this silly slider. If you use too much bullet for better dump offs and slants... then the long passes don't make it over the secondary and are picked off/deflected. Too much loft improves long passes but gives the psychic defense time to get on top of your receiver before the ball even reaches him on anything else.
You want to talk about stupid settings, try the Pass/Run/No Focus block on o-linemen. I may be the only person who knows this, but when the offense huddles up, the QB actually tells the players what sort of play they are going to run. So when it's a passing play, the o-linemen are prepared for that and block according, and the same on a running play. The idea that the o-linemen should have one setting for an entire game is ridiculous.
And then there's defensive focus - same issue: pass/run/no focus. Ok, it's 3rd and 15 - probably going to be a pass, so switch to a passing attack. It's 4th and inches, probably going to be a run. No RL player actually goes into a game say "I'm going to attack the play as if it's a pass on every single play.
Great post by Griff...too bad it won't get an real attention.
T
OMG YES. This is my first season OCing and I have been introduced to this silly slider. If you use too much bullet for better dump offs and slants... then the long passes don't make it over the secondary and are picked off/deflected. Too much loft improves long passes but gives the psychic defense time to get on top of your receiver before the ball even reaches him on anything else.
You want to talk about stupid settings, try the Pass/Run/No Focus block on o-linemen. I may be the only person who knows this, but when the offense huddles up, the QB actually tells the players what sort of play they are going to run. So when it's a passing play, the o-linemen are prepared for that and block according, and the same on a running play. The idea that the o-linemen should have one setting for an entire game is ridiculous.
And then there's defensive focus - same issue: pass/run/no focus. Ok, it's 3rd and 15 - probably going to be a pass, so switch to a passing attack. It's 4th and inches, probably going to be a run. No RL player actually goes into a game say "I'm going to attack the play as if it's a pass on every single play.
Great post by Griff...too bad it won't get an real attention.
T
maz621
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Yup. Great post but every post like this dies...unless it spawns a 700 post whine thread.
these threads dont work without the support of the kai they always get what they want changed... ala the QB slots time for the kai signal
http://www.cobrakaidojo.com/cobrakai300dpi.jpg
Yup. Great post but every post like this dies...unless it spawns a 700 post whine thread.
these threads dont work without the support of the kai they always get what they want changed... ala the QB slots time for the kai signal
http://www.cobrakaidojo.com/cobrakai300dpi.jpg
Sooner5900
offline
offline
All good points.
and yes, the passing game at the lower lvl's is a freakin joke...
and yes, the passing game at the lower lvl's is a freakin joke...
griffin8r
offline
offline
Originally posted by maz621
these threads dont work without the support of the kai they always get what they want changed... ala the QB slots time for the kai signal
http://www.cobrakaidojo.com/cobrakai300dpi.jpg
Waiting for Scientist to show up. Scientist is actually pretty supportive of my musings. Will be interesting to see where he lands here.
these threads dont work without the support of the kai they always get what they want changed... ala the QB slots time for the kai signal
http://www.cobrakaidojo.com/cobrakai300dpi.jpg
Waiting for Scientist to show up. Scientist is actually pretty supportive of my musings. Will be interesting to see where he lands here.
griffin8r
offline
offline
Originally posted by cwrujosh
Seriously excellent discourse on the state of the game. Nice job Griff.
I don't like complaining, but if I'm going to do it, it's going to be blow-by-blow detailed, not just vague whining.
Seriously excellent discourse on the state of the game. Nice job Griff.
I don't like complaining, but if I'm going to do it, it's going to be blow-by-blow detailed, not just vague whining.
cwrujosh
offline
offline
Originally posted by griffin8r
I don't like complaining, but if I'm going to do it, it's going to be blow-by-blow detailed, not just vague whining.
Most people on this board confuse observation for complaint. Yes-men are playing a large role in ruining this game. There need to be more testers (or hell even a SINGLE tester) who isn't a company man to point out the serious misgivings in this game.
I don't like complaining, but if I'm going to do it, it's going to be blow-by-blow detailed, not just vague whining.
Most people on this board confuse observation for complaint. Yes-men are playing a large role in ruining this game. There need to be more testers (or hell even a SINGLE tester) who isn't a company man to point out the serious misgivings in this game.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























