User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
HTFC
offline
Link
 
One problem is say;
You get a few teams that build really well and are in the same division.
They all are the same as each other say the top 4 but are better than the rest with higher level players.
However the division they woul get promoted into has the same level players.
The teams that don't get promoted that season will next season lose out and when they get promoted they will be unable to compete with their current squad.

It all depends on how the level-to-level comparison works.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HustonJ
How would the comparative levels work out?

Would it be your individual level against the average of specific opposing players you interacted with during the play?

Would it be your individual level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be your team's average level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be based on the entire roster, or on the players on the field?

There are advantages and disadvantages to each of the above. The most accurate ones would, of course, require more code and processing time.

Honestly, though, I'm just curious about what you have in mind. I don't particularly desire this be added to the system.


Well said. I think these new proposed changes are all good in theory but will be a nightmare to implement. If not implemented right (which I currently I really don't see how it's possible), you are just opening a whole new can of worms.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I like this idea much better than the others. Way to think outside of the box.

I do not think I would penalise a team for a blowout though, nor reward a team for losing in a blowout so I might suggest you scrap options 5 and 6.

Also, For determining team strength, instead of using averages (which can be skewed by hiring some level 1 bench sitters) I would use a 'mean' which is harder to fudge with and if they fudge with it effectively it can be very easily spotted and punished.

 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
If the idea is to keep high ranked players from slumming, using the average level of the league would work fine, I would think.

If my team is playing an equivalent team who just happens to have a low level C, my NT shouldn't be penalized, for example.

1-4 are solid.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise


Remove the "negative" reinforcement part? The bonus would have to be worth it to lure people away from pwning n00bs.
 
rhavec
offline
Link
 
What happens if a team is gutted? Then the rest of the teams in the league who play them won't get good XP? But if the team was actually good before they were gutted those teams would get normal XP?
 
techjunkie
offline
Link
 
I like everything except 5/6 I also like serenity's idea
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Again, this punishes good teams that stay together. Why?

If a BBB team wins back-to-back championships, they could STILL find themselves in a league where they are being punished for leveling wisely.

There are already SOOOOOOOOO many aspects of this game that balance things for lower-leveled players:

1. XP gets harder to earn.
2. Training is more expensive and yields lower results.
3. SP cost become less valuable as stats increase.

As the game advances everyone is already going to end up at EXACTLY THE SAME skill level, why add even more?


Good teams that stick together should win a championship and move up. The idea is not a punishment; it's a reward to players who play better competition.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rhavec
What happens if a team is gutted? Then the rest of the teams in the league who play them won't get good XP? But if the team was actually good before they were gutted those teams would get normal XP?


The changes to trades and cuts should cover in-season gutting pretty well. You can only lose 2 players per day from cuts during the season.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Serenity

I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise


Remove the "negative" reinforcement part? The bonus would have to be worth it to lure people away from pwning n00bs.


Well say in a pro league a team loses their best players. and after 3-4 games manages to bring it some top level talent to get back to the point they were at before.

But during those 3-4 games the other teams get punished for having to play them causing them to fall slightly behind other top teams in the league at no fault of their own.
 
Irish_Eagle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Levels would be based on average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).



Starters could be traded maybe weighted against the "top threats"
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
To me this is positive reinforcement for losing. If you lose, complain and the winners will be restricted.

The current promotion/relegation system will take care of everything, have patience. If there is little patience, perhaps we could speed up the promotion/relegation process and have more teams moved up/down. This would be a much better solution than to tweak the XP system.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BartRock
If the idea is to keep high ranked players from slumming, using the average level of the league would work fine, I would think.

If my team is playing an equivalent team who just happens to have a low level C, my NT shouldn't be penalized, for example.

1-4 are solid.


That's probably a good idea; harder for somebody to throw off a whole league that way by signing some lv 1's or cutting high level players.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by HustonJ

How would the comparative levels work out?

Would it be your individual level against the average of specific opposing players you interacted with during the play?

Would it be your individual level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be your team's average level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be based on the entire roster, or on the players on the field?

There are advantages and disadvantages to each of the above. The most accurate ones would, of course, require more code and processing time.

Honestly, though, I'm just curious about what you have in mind. I don't particularly desire this be added to the system.


I was thinking something like average levels, weighted toward starters, or something along those lines. I agree that it might be more realistic if it was based on the guy you were facing, but it might be hard to deal with, especially for a position like K or P or QB who doesn't have a set opponent.


I already replied but want to reply with some context.

I would do 'mean' weighted on the starters instead of average.

For example:

A team with 2x Lvl 18 DT's + 2x Lvl 17 DE's + 3 x Lvl 16 LB's 2xlevel 10 Safeties and one Level 12 CB and one Level 14 CB

The 'average' level is 14 lvl.
The Mean/Median is 16 lvl

 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Again, this punishes good teams that stay together. Why?

If a BBB team wins back-to-back championships, they could STILL find themselves in a league where they are being punished for leveling wisely.

There are already SOOOOOOOOO many aspects of this game that balance things for lower-leveled players:

1. XP gets harder to earn.
2. Training is more expensive and yields lower results.
3. SP cost become less valuable as stats increase.

As the game advances everyone is already going to end up at EXACTLY THE SAME skill level, why add even more?


Good teams that stick together should win a championship and move up. The idea is not a punishment; it's a reward to players who play better competition.


Agree with this except we as players have no control over who we play. And why should be be punished for playing an inferior opponent? Can we remove the weak teams from our schedule?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.