Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by TrevJo
In what way do you suggest that he may have misread the play? I don't get it. Are you suggesting that he might be expecting run on a 5WR pass play, even though he is almost certainly set to Pass Focus? Please explain.
Not in this example (the more catastropic step forward one is another matter) however If he rolls "read QB run" on 1/1000 coin flips, then yes I would think it possible simply because of the nature of probability.
However, in this case especially, it's more likely that he simply "dithers" after initially being faked because he hasn't read any play and is therefore indecisive until the ball is pretty much released.
Never mind about the dithering.
I'm just referring to the step-forward issue.
I agree that reading run is almost certainly not what's happening on his particular replay. (Note on this play that 4 CBs step forward.)
Here's what I don't understand about your approach to this issue. On the one hand, the basic reason that you think this is occuring is CBs trying to close the gap to their specified m2m coverage distance. To me, that doesn't seem like it would (even though it could) depend on any fakes, failed vision checks, or a misread play. Yet, every time I see you comment on one of these replays, your stated suspicion is that what's going on is a fake, and/or a failed vision check, and/or a misread play.
I appreciate that we don't know for sure what is going on behind the scenes and there are a lot of possibilities. But it just seems to me like you are not keeping an open mind that it could simply be an issue of how CBs are coded to close/maintain their coverage distance, and it could occur without any fake, any failed vision check, or a misread play.
Originally posted by TrevJo
In what way do you suggest that he may have misread the play? I don't get it. Are you suggesting that he might be expecting run on a 5WR pass play, even though he is almost certainly set to Pass Focus? Please explain.
Not in this example (the more catastropic step forward one is another matter) however If he rolls "read QB run" on 1/1000 coin flips, then yes I would think it possible simply because of the nature of probability.
However, in this case especially, it's more likely that he simply "dithers" after initially being faked because he hasn't read any play and is therefore indecisive until the ball is pretty much released.
Never mind about the dithering.
I'm just referring to the step-forward issue.
I agree that reading run is almost certainly not what's happening on his particular replay. (Note on this play that 4 CBs step forward.)
Here's what I don't understand about your approach to this issue. On the one hand, the basic reason that you think this is occuring is CBs trying to close the gap to their specified m2m coverage distance. To me, that doesn't seem like it would (even though it could) depend on any fakes, failed vision checks, or a misread play. Yet, every time I see you comment on one of these replays, your stated suspicion is that what's going on is a fake, and/or a failed vision check, and/or a misread play.
I appreciate that we don't know for sure what is going on behind the scenes and there are a lot of possibilities. But it just seems to me like you are not keeping an open mind that it could simply be an issue of how CBs are coded to close/maintain their coverage distance, and it could occur without any fake, any failed vision check, or a misread play.






























