User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Coverage bug? Dubbed "CB with cement shoes"??
Page:
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by TrevJo

In what way do you suggest that he may have misread the play? I don't get it. Are you suggesting that he might be expecting run on a 5WR pass play, even though he is almost certainly set to Pass Focus? Please explain.


Not in this example (the more catastropic step forward one is another matter) however If he rolls "read QB run" on 1/1000 coin flips, then yes I would think it possible simply because of the nature of probability.

However, in this case especially, it's more likely that he simply "dithers" after initially being faked because he hasn't read any play and is therefore indecisive until the ball is pretty much released.


Never mind about the dithering.
I'm just referring to the step-forward issue.
I agree that reading run is almost certainly not what's happening on his particular replay. (Note on this play that 4 CBs step forward.)

Here's what I don't understand about your approach to this issue. On the one hand, the basic reason that you think this is occuring is CBs trying to close the gap to their specified m2m coverage distance. To me, that doesn't seem like it would (even though it could) depend on any fakes, failed vision checks, or a misread play. Yet, every time I see you comment on one of these replays, your stated suspicion is that what's going on is a fake, and/or a failed vision check, and/or a misread play.
I appreciate that we don't know for sure what is going on behind the scenes and there are a lot of possibilities. But it just seems to me like you are not keeping an open mind that it could simply be an issue of how CBs are coded to close/maintain their coverage distance, and it could occur without any fake, any failed vision check, or a misread play.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
The part that definitely has to be a bug is when he freezes after he gets beat. You can come up with at least a possible explanation for why he stepped up, but there is no way he should stop afterwards.
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Step-forward bug, then the bullshit excuse of pump fake.


Does any of the coders actually watch football?
A CB gets pump faked in m2m but yet the FS, who is playing zone and actually looking at the QB, doesn't bite?
You gotta be kidding me.

CB playing man isn't looking at the QB, they're watching their man. Now if this were happening to FS/CB in zone, I could see this but not with a guy playing m2m.

Why can't you just admit it's a problem and fix it or at least come out and say you're looking into it, instead of telling everyone it's not a bug. And if you still don't think it's a bug then take Sunday off and watch a few games to see how CB's react.

It seems like every season there's a new excuse and this season is "pump fake/failed vision check". And last season it was "needs more vision".

How bout maybe it's a "sim problem" or is that not possible?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
A very simple fix would be to prevent CBs from coming forward on the snap of the ball. It wouldn't address the root of whatever is causing this, but testers can try to figure that out on the test server. In the meantime it's ridiculous that teams are still being screwed by this bug when a potential solution is obvious, even if it's just a temporary one. Putting that patch on the problem while trying to figure out what causes it is better than doing nothing while supposedly trying to figure out what causes it.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Its a defiant pump fake, what made it worse was the step forward issue which may or may not be a bug.

Yeah pump fake isn't realistic the way it is (fakes man0to0man guys, and not zone guys, and that should be reversed)
but thats the way its been forever in this game, and it seems to be intended to be that way, so just bad idea, not a bug.
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
Its a defiant pump fake, what made it worse was the step forward issue which may or may not be a bug.

Yeah pump fake isn't realistic the way it is (fakes man0to0man guys, and not zone guys, and that should be reversed)
but thats the way its been forever in this game, and it seems to be intended to be that way, so just bad idea, not a bug.


Uhhh yeah it's a fucking bug if it's a pump fake on a guy in man2man. When you're in man2man you're not looking at the QB.
If you are, you're going to find yourself out of a job.

I don't give a shit if this is how it's been in this game, that's not how it should be at all. So that makes it a bug.

Show me where a CB is covering his guy man2man and he falls for a pump fake every time and I'll show you a guy that doesn't have a job as a NFL CB anymore.

The sim is broke, it's a bug and needs fixed but yet hasn't been.

Like I stated before, the coders need to watch a real football game for once and see how things work in real life.
If they can't figure it out by watching a game, then maybe they need to find someone that knows football to help them out.

Either way it's a bug and by the looks of it, will not get fixed.

 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Whatever dude...

It makes it a bad game design, not a bug, its doing exactly what it was intended to do
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
It's not a bug because a bug is the code playing out in a way that it's not intended. While the CBs being faked in M2M is really stupid imo, it is working as intended. The intentions are just wrong. Go to suggestions if you want to change it.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Sep 19, 2009 23:53:19
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Trying to nail down what's happening is like trying to nail down scotch mist because there's a whole raft of different responses by CB's at the snap.

There doesn't always appear to be a clear logic to CB behaviour.


And yet instead of working to fix something that has been around for multiple seasons, it is off to the next new fun feature.

Debugging code is not fun, and it takes a special type of person to be good at it. Bort should hire one.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
It's not a bug because a bug is the code playing out in a way that it's not intended. While the CBs being faked in M2M is really stupid imo, it is working as intended. The intentions are just wrong. Go to suggestions if you want to change it.


Oh no, they got to him!
 
Mr. Likable
offline
Link
 
Both CBs 1 and 2, did the same thing.
 
gjwhite66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sixx
When you're in man2man you're not looking at the QB.
If you are, you're going to find yourself out of a job.

Show me where a CB is covering his guy man2man and he falls for a pump fake every time and I'll show you a guy that doesn't have a job as a NFL CB anymore.


I do agree this is a bug, but your rationale is a little off. If the Pump Fake happened right at the snap of the ball, the CB may very well be looking at the QB. That's how aggressive CBs jump routes, because they watch the QB to look out for short plays. That's also why Pump and Go plays work, because the CB looks towards the QB when the WR makes his initial cut (not calling this play a Pump and Go, just using the example). It can and does happen on a regular basis, at every level of football.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
I don't like calling it the step forward "bug". I would rather call it he stepped forward because he is on aggressive coverage and he got burned.

The CB's on the OP's team have some screwy coverage settings. It looks like the play posted was a jump on aggressive coverage at the line, and it looks like speedy gonzalez on the other side plays a few yards off the ball and plays aggressive because he got burned later in the game.

Risk vs reward.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I don't like calling it the step forward "bug". I would rather call it he stepped forward because he is on aggressive coverage and he got burned.

The CB's on the OP's team have some screwy coverage settings. It looks like the play posted was a jump on aggressive coverage at the line, and it looks like speedy gonzalez on the other side plays a few yards off the ball and plays aggressive because he got burned later in the game.

Risk vs reward.


Nope, on semi-agg. AFAIK. your reasoning is crap, BTW. It's most definitely a bug in coverage which has never been fixed because no one knows how to fix it apparently
Edited by Toriq on Sep 20, 2009 12:38:30
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I appreciate that we don't know for sure what is going on behind the scenes and there are a lot of possibilities. But it just seems to me like you are not keeping an open mind that it could simply be an issue of how CBs are coded to close/maintain their coverage distance, and it could occur without any fake, any failed vision check, or a misread play.


So by suggesting lots of possibilities including the one you mentioned I have a closed mind? Cheers.

It could be that, and if you find the original thread then you'll see I said that. I also pointed out that I am interested in the instances of the CB making the "jump" forward at the snap and suggested that there is more than a single modifier at play. The fact that the CB also moves left or right however is pretty indicative of a fake somewhere in the mechanics, which of course requires some kind of vision check fail.

Based on the original replay:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=794992&pbp_id=17111246

Jiro Neil - steps forward and slides to the left, freezes.
Moore Cowbell - steps forward and slides to the right.
Reggie - steps forward then drops back against.
Broke Dogg - steps forward then falls back to the right.
Speedy Gonzalez - tracks normally.

The step forward and slide are different to the freeze element which is what was originally flagged and supports the idea that it was a Pump Fake. The fact he moves to the left at the snap suggests he fell for a head fake / creative route run or similar. Falling one vision check will likely (unintended) cause him to fail more.

However there's a lot going on within that play:
A - With regards to CB1 and CB2 stepping to the outside respectively it'd be interesting to see if this happens on all 5WR sets or just this play. As I suggested elsewhere - it's possible that slight differences in the way formations are drawn might be having side effects.
B - looks pretty obvious that Reggie steps up to close his M2M distance.
C - Why doesn't Speedy step-up? Different settings?

etc
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.