User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sithas~Cult~
FireDown!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra

Oh jesus. While Frazier was good. He was far from the "best".


Who was a better college QB?
He won 2 national titles, a FG a way from A 3rd. He was national championship MVP 3 times, and he graduated with a 33-3 record as a starter. He was cheated out of a heisman too, and by the way, he did all this while having severe blood clots, which set him back. Name me one better college QB.


Steve McNair was a better college QB IMO with what he had to work with.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Steve Mcnair was an amazing QB, he was the only person on his offense. i think thats the reason why though, an amazing player on an average team can look all world, especially at QB (like robert griffin at baylor), where as a star player on a star team is given more publicity and known more as a "leader" and "game manager" (like tebow), in terms of career college achievements, Frazier clearly was better, in terms of pure talent, you know i might give it to McNair just for his arm, but i think in the end its a push, and if it wasnt for the blood clots, i think frazier might have been able to do something in the NFL, based off the sole fact that Kordell Stewart started at the Stealers, and i think Frazier was better then him on all levels.
I think if frazier and Mcnair switch places, i dont think history would change much (if tommie's blot clots didnt happen). I think they both had similar talents, good runners, with adequate arms (mcnair with advantage), and both were all time greats. But I can understand where your coming from with McNair, he wasnt in the best situation, but he was an amazing QB.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra

He was far from the "best".


I think when it comes to actual football, you might be mentally retarded. Especially with a comment like that. If you disagree with him being the best, ok fine, but FAR from it?..that's like saying Usain Bolt only has decent speed.



Only decent compared to me
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra

Oh jesus. While Frazier was good. He was far from the "best".


Who was a better college QB?
He won 2 national titles, a FG a way from A 3rd. He was national championship MVP 3 times, and he graduated with a 33-3 record as a starter. He was cheated out of a heisman too, and by the way, he did all this while having severe blood clots, which set him back. Name me one better college QB.


Winning NC's doesn't make you a good college QB automatically. Last I knew it took several other people to be on the field at the same time. I must have missed something... cause when I watched Frazier play, I could have sworn there were 10 other people on offense with him... and when he was on the sideline, there were still 11 other people on the field.

And likewise, just cause you DON'T win the NC doesn't mean you are a bad QB.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Being the national championship MVP 3 times in a row, even though one was a losing effort makes you a good college QB. Hell it makes you an amazing college QB, he was picked over all the players on both teams, as the best player on the field. You couldn't even say it was a fluke, cause 3 times in a row would prove it was far from that.

This play alone against a national championship caliber D, makes him more then a "good qb"

http://m.youtube.com/index?desktop_uri=%2F&#/watch?v=5LNIWaYNJZI&client=mv-google&xl=AdsControl1

or just a small thing that would make him better then good, like maybe starting as QB for quite possibly the greatest NCAA team of all time. There wasn't anything less than a good player starting for Nebraska in 95, their second string could manhandle average teams, and beat good ones. The fact they could lose both their starting, and second string qb to injuries, and still win proves that. We saw what happened to OU after Bradford went down. Tommie Frazier was an amazing QB, and easily considered not just the greatest QB of all time, but greatest player.
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
Spurrier.... Best ever.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by p@nda
Spurrier.... Best ever.


no
 
Sithas~Cult~
FireDown!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by p@nda

Spurrier.... Best ever.


no


no
 
nottom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Who was a better college QB?
He won 2 national titles, a FG a way from A 3rd. He was national championship MVP 3 times, and he graduated with a 33-3 record as a starter. He was cheated out of a heisman too, and by the way, he did all this while having severe blood clots, which set him back. Name me one better college QB.


This is the same argument that people use to claim Roethlisberger is one of the top 3 QBs in the league.
Edited by nottom on Sep 14, 2009 04:55:24
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom
Originally posted by blackshirt54

Who was a better college QB?
He won 2 national titles, a FG a way from A 3rd. He was national championship MVP 3 times, and he graduated with a 33-3 record as a starter. He was cheated out of a heisman too, and by the way, he did all this while having severe blood clots, which set him back. Name me one better college QB.


This is the same argument that people use to claim Roethlisberger is one of the top 3 QBs in the league.


+1

And I didn't say Frazier wasn't a good QB.

I said, winning a NC doesn't make you a good QB AUTOMATICALLY. That guy would not have won any NC's without the awesome team around him. He would have 0 MVP's if it wasn't for the team around him.

And besides, we are talking about college QB's... not "runningbacks-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot". As far as "quarterbacking" goes, he was very average at best.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom
This is the same argument that people use to claim Roethlisberger is one of the top 3 QBs in the league.


No its not the same argument. Roethlisberger doesn't mean the same to his offense as Frazier meant to his, yes both were on successful teams, but they had completely different roles.

Roethlisberger is a top 10 QB in the league though.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
+1

And I didn't say Frazier wasn't a good QB.

I said, winning a NC doesn't make you a good QB AUTOMATICALLY. That guy would not have won any NC's without the awesome team around him. He would have 0 MVP's if it wasn't for the team around him.

And besides, we are talking about college QB's... not "runningbacks-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot". As far as "quarterbacking" goes, he was very average at best.


If your starting and winning not just one, but multiple MNC, that does make you a good college player. I dont see how you could argue against that. If you can go through 3 years of beating the best while only losing 1 game during the same time period, which just so happened to be a MNC, your good. You can try and give the "runningback-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot", but that just shows you know jack shit about college football. Tommie Frazier excelled as a leader and an option QB, he also could throw a decent football, he was by no means great at it, but the fact is Nebraska didnt have to pass, they were more dominant then any team you could possibly think of in recent history. Nebraska completely ran it down anybodys throat, and nobody could stop them, and Tommie Frazier was a key component in doing that. You can continue giving the team effort thing, but that reasoning works for all teams who've won a MNC. One player definitely can not win a MNC when it comes to college football, but i was never arguing that. Tommie Frazier was the best player, on the best team of arguably college football history. That sole fact alone already makes him one of the best. Then adding in all of his personal accomplishments, leadership abilities, and his state of mind to refuse to lose, those all push him into being the best NCAA QB of all time. Did he have the arm of John Elway or Peyton Manning? No, did he have the speed of Mike Vick or Eric Crouch? Not at all. But he accomplished more then all of those players when it comes to dominating college football. Your argument of winning MNC doesnt make you a good player and its a team effort in the end is cool and all, but by beating the best, you become best, Nebraska did just that and in order to do that, amazing players and talents need to be on your team, and Tommie Frazier was one of those players. Hes the best of all time, you can continue arguing against it, but numerous publications and sports experts would disagree.


runningback-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot, I take it, thats your way of discounting any QB with the added dimension of speed.
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
Google Spurrier you Turds

And Frazier was never a National Championship Game MVP.... There was no National Championship game back then.

 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by p@nda
Google Spurrier you Turds

And Frazier was never a National Championship Game MVP.... There was no National Championship game back then.


I know who spurrier is, but no, hes not the best of all time.

He was MNC MVP 3 times, and yes there was a national championship, it was not the BCS National Championship that we have today, but the game that produced the national champion (#1 in polls), was called the national championship.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra

+1

And I didn't say Frazier wasn't a good QB.

I said, winning a NC doesn't make you a good QB AUTOMATICALLY. That guy would not have won any NC's without the awesome team around him. He would have 0 MVP's if it wasn't for the team around him.

And besides, we are talking about college QB's... not "runningbacks-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot". As far as "quarterbacking" goes, he was very average at best.


If your starting and winning not just one, but multiple MNC, that does make you a good college player. I dont see how you could argue against that. If you can go through 3 years of beating the best while only losing 1 game during the same time period, which just so happened to be a MNC, your good. You can try and give the "runningback-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot", but that just shows you know jack shit about college football. Tommie Frazier excelled as a leader and an option QB, he also could throw a decent football, he was by no means great at it, but the fact is Nebraska didnt have to pass, they were more dominant then any team you could possibly think of in recent history. Nebraska completely ran it down anybodys throat, and nobody could stop them, and Tommie Frazier was a key component in doing that. You can continue giving the team effort thing, but that reasoning works for all teams who've won a MNC. One player definitely can not win a MNC when it comes to college football, but i was never arguing that. Tommie Frazier was the best player, on the best team of arguably college football history. That sole fact alone already makes him one of the best. Then adding in all of his personal accomplishments, leadership abilities, and his state of mind to refuse to lose, those all push him into being the best NCAA QB of all time. Did he have the arm of John Elway or Peyton Manning? No, did he have the speed of Mike Vick or Eric Crouch? Not at all. But he accomplished more then all of those players when it comes to dominating college football. Your argument of winning MNC doesnt make you a good player and its a team effort in the end is cool and all, but by beating the best, you become best, Nebraska did just that and in order to do that, amazing players and talents need to be on your team, and Tommie Frazier was one of those players. Hes the best of all time, you can continue arguing against it, but numerous publications and sports experts would disagree.


runningback-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot, I take it, thats your way of discounting any QB with the added dimension of speed.


I won't tear apart your lame examples. It will take forever and I'm bored with Frazier.

But I will say in response to your last sentance... "runningback-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot" is not discounting any QB with added dimension of speed. It's my way of saying a shitty QB that only made it because of his speed.

On that note.. I'll leave you to wipe the Frazier sperm off your chin. Tell him I said high next time he's fucking you in the ass.
Edited by Godzirra on Sep 15, 2009 21:56:47
Edited by Godzirra on Sep 15, 2009 21:56:19
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.