I thought the entire point of having the one thread was so Bort didn't have to go through 500 threads. But ya, it might have been smart to divide it into sections, and in it's own subforum. I don't think you'd want it to be a full forum where anyone can post a new topic, though, it would be just as cluttered as the suggestion forum.
Originally posted by blump I thought the entire point of having the one thread was so Bort didn't have to go through 500 threads. But ya, it might have been smart to divide it into sections, and in it's own subforum. I don't think you'd want it to be a full forum where anyone can post a new topic, though, it would be just as cluttered as the suggestion forum.
If one idea had its own subforum, you would be able to organize the ideas far better. Then you would also be able to see which ideas are generating the most comments. If the OP or mods update each idea's OP with good ideas built up through discussion, it would make it really easy to see which ideas are supported or what concerns need to be addressed (and potential solutions proposed).
This would actually make it easier to read for the users, easier to update for the OPs and Mods, and then easier to disseminate into one final post before moving to archives.
Originally posted by Time Trial Originally posted by blump
I thought the entire point of having the one thread was so Bort didn't have to go through 500 threads. But ya, it might have been smart to divide it into sections, and in it's own subforum. I don't think you'd want it to be a full forum where anyone can post a new topic, though, it would be just as cluttered as the suggestion forum.
If one idea had its own subforum, you would be able to organize the ideas far better. Then you would also be able to see which ideas are generating the most comments. If the OP or mods update each idea's OP with good ideas built up through discussion, it would make it really easy to see which ideas are supported or what concerns need to be addressed (and potential solutions proposed).
This would actually make it easier to read for the users, easier to update for the OPs and Mods, and then easier to disseminate into one final post before moving to archives.
Originally posted by Jed Very good idea. I'll wait to see if someone comes along with an actual reason this is bad, and if not, epic it is. Which means this might be implemented by Season 25? Forgive my skepticism, but the epic graveyard has earned it.
Originally posted by jdbolick Originally posted by Jed
Very good idea. I'll wait to see if someone comes along with an actual reason this is bad, and if not, epic it is. Which means this might be implemented by Season 25? Forgive my skepticism, but the epic graveyard has earned it.
So you do or don't support the idea?
I think this idea is awesome, and the skepticism of the epic graveyard is actually being worked on (read project Bort thread).
Originally posted by jdbolick Originally posted by Jed
Very good idea. I'll wait to see if someone comes along with an actual reason this is bad, and if not, epic it is. Which means this might be implemented by Season 25? Forgive my skepticism, but the epic graveyard has earned it.
True... honestly it should just be mentioned to someone in charge and if they like it, make an Admin announcement and just add those folders and those rules to the existing forum. I'm not sure it needs to go to epic... that should be for code changes. Stuff that can be done right now should just be done right now.
Originally posted by JcWildcat So you do or don't support the idea? I think this idea is awesome, and the skepticism of the epic graveyard is actually being worked on (read project Bort thread). I think locking threads and forcing all discussion of a subject into one is completely idiotic and one of the worst things about GLB's forums, so yes, any step away from that is a positive one in my view. As for "Project Epic," it was never a question of Bort not knowing what stuff was in Epic Suggestions, and therefore needing that information pointed out to him. That has always been a place to send ideas when mods get tired of hearing about them.