Originally posted by 907s Finest
Originally posted by Daudy
Rushing QBs are pretty hard to stop actually. That is, hard to stop without making your defence stupidly weak elsewhere.
Then again, I'm a rookie DC. I wouldn't know anything 
No they are the easiest thing to stop especially at low levels were WRs usually drop passes and QBs lack the vision to make the big throws. I'm sure as a DC you will eventually figure it out? 
I agree that at the lower levels recievers drop a lot of passes and Pocket Passing QBs don't have rounded builds, but if you disregard the passing game completely in order to sell out to the QB run, you're going to get nailed. Much like what your team is doing with a 14.8 yards passing average. ;P You have to remember as well, your D opponents don't have rounded builds either, so really PDs aren't too common - it's all whether or not you drop it or not.
In the lower levels, it's not so much about throwing the long bomb, it's about throwing the pass to an open man for a completion and letting them run through the defence. This isn't Peewees, passes generally do stick more often than not!

Are you prepared to give up a big gain or a score everytime one sticks by selling out your defence to stopping the rollouts? Also, one of the more common ways to stop outside runs (QB runs included) is to blitz CBs. If you use the Dime formation, for example, for it's extra CBs against a 2WR set, you suddenly have only one MLB in the middle. Now, presuming the SS covers the TE, MLB covers the HB, who covers the FB? As I said, not such a big problem here - but the one LB in the middle suddenly leaves you open to the inside run as well. You could get people to play flat zones which means they also defend flat passes and screens there, but that doesn't help with the inside run.
The main reason for this effectiveness is because QB rollouts get an additional lead blocker. Out of SB, they get the HB (as opposed to the HB having nobody to lead block for him). Out of the I and SI, they get the HB AND the FB (as opposed to only one blocking for the other). Don't get me wrong, the HB is not the best blocker in the world, but an extra man lead blocking does wonders. Assuming the two lead blockers engage one defender each (which doesn't happen all the time mind you) and you have someone to make the tackle, that's already three people. Now consider that the QB can rollout both sides, that's practically 6 personnel already just dedicated to stopping those outside runs. There are lots of factors unaccounted obviously (ie DEs and CBs pancaking or getting around their blockers) but you are using a fair few people to stop only three. Stopping the QB rollout is not the same as stopping outside runs from a HB. Byron Dolphins - 61 TFLs on HB plays out of 250 (almost one every four plays) and only 1 out of 13 on QB run plays. It's not a very good sample, I'll be the first to agree. But don't underestimate the effectiveness of an extra lead blocker. Don't get me wrong, you could easily stop the QB run if you completely sold out to it. But I suppose the best thing about it is that it keeps opponents guessing.
I have no beef with any of you, your teams or players, but I feel strongly on this issue. I've looked at it from an OC's point of view (rather than DC's) and why it's so effective - mostly because it keeps defences guessing between the lesser of two (or more) evils.
On a side note: I'm enjoying this league. The first time I've had any co-ordinating role in a long time in a lower league + obviously my first stint DCing. Doing the Offence and Defence for the Dolphins was originally a casual thing of mine (as I'm usually busy with other teams), but things are getting pretty interesting so I might just start putting some more time into it. (Which might mean we do worse hahahahaha!)