User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Mod Only > RNG (Random Number Generator)
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Because not flat-out saying, "as of now, I can guarantee that there is no intentional mechanic in place where all the time, work, and money you put into raising skills. SA's, VA's, and equipment is hampered by something you can't see and/or control," the obvious conclusion when you look at 2 players who are similarly-built and one is out-performing the other is that one player is pre-determined to be better and the other one is fucked.

I have a player or 2 which I've been banging my head against the wall trying to improve and nothing seems to work. If the answer is, "nothing you can do, you're fucked," that's a pretty shitty deal right there. Now imagine if I wasn't a mod and have spent the better part of 6-12 months and upwards of $50+ on a player to figure that out.

As annoying as it is to me, if I had not only spent the time but also paid the $ for that, I'd quit on the spot.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
If I come out and say "NO THERE IS NO SPECIAL ATTRIBUTES" I limit all options related to it for any current or future ideas.


You can say there aren't any right now without hampering that.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
See, even the dumb troll gets it:

Originally posted by David Stern
the entire draw of a game like this is the player creation. If we wanted random shit we would just go play PRS. Taking away our ability to have total control over our players, is a giant middle finger at me the consumer. I am absolutely raging atm. As I type this I am thinking in my head about players who are built amazing but can't beat level 20 ot's with 15 stamina 20 agility, and a CPU next to there name.


When you don't actually play the game, if you take away building (even a small bit of it), it's not even a game anymore.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
LOL, no players are "totally fucked" by some hidden attribute they can't control in any way whatsoever. I will tell you that. I really just don't want to take ideas related to the concept off the table. There are lots of ideas out there about superstars popping up after a time, training combos making a difference, initial roll modifiers as a bonus, etc and I think a lot of them are interesting. If I tell you "OMG HIDDEN ATTRIBUTES ARE DILDOS" I can no longer investigate or work with those ideas.

Also, ever wonder what the "clutch" VA does? It's a hidden attribute of sorts.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Also, ever wonder what the "clutch" VA does? It's a hidden attribute of sorts.


So players have a hidden clutch factor? *scratches head*
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Also, ever wonder what the "clutch" VA does? It's a hidden attribute of sorts.


Clutch is a perfect example of where I think the line is. Do we know "exactly" what Clutch does? No. Can we put points in it, play around with it, figure it out well enough, and feel like putting points there affects something? Yes.

If there's things behind-the-scenes which we can't see or control whatsoever, then the feeling of control is completely gone.


Also, when you're talking about some positions which are pretty cookie-cutter, if you have an EXTREMELY similar build to someone else, the only difference is the uncontrollable stuff. If it's random, fine, but if it's always going to go the way of one player and never the other, the other player effectively is totally fucked by it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
So players have a hidden clutch factor? *scratches head*


Players have a clutch attribute as part of their player object. You can't see it, but it's there. The clutch VA increases it, which affects a bunch of rolls.

Idea: what if the clutch attribute did not start at the same point every game? A player could have a better or worse game that day due to that factor. Wow, interesting idea, kinda mirrors real life!

This is the kind of stuff I'm talking about - ideas that are interesting but have no chance if I tell everyone it won't exist.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
But see, Bort, that falls under the "random stuff happens" umbrella. Random is fine. Random is good.

It's when you say, "Player X has an attribute he can't see or have any clue how to adjust without doing some real meta-gamey testing and at least partially because of that, he is better than Player Y in every situation" that I see a big problem.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
But see, Bort, that falls under the "random stuff happens" umbrella. Random is fine. Random is good.

It's when you say, "Player X has an attribute he can't see or have any clue how to adjust without doing some real meta-gamey testing and at least partially because of that, he is better than Player Y in every situation" that I see a big problem.


Ah. Player Y is not better than Player X in every situation, unless he has set himself up to be better of course. Confirm that.

I like random, though. Ever notice some players in the NFL take a play off from time to time (T.O. lol)? That would be interesting. Streaky is one of my favorite VA's. What if players had a natural streakyness factor?

I also like the idea of players perhaps having an intrinsic ability that comes out after some amount of time, sort of like the superstar idea (one of them) that was epic for a while. I think that's a neat idea that could be investigated, and I don't want to throw it out the window.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Ya know what, lets roll with that Clutch example a bit more because I really do like how that is handled.

Lets say there is or eventually will be other behind-the-scenes things we can't really affect normally. Those would be PERFECT things to have new VA's for.

Just give people some modicum of an idea that they're in control of their player no matter what and everyone is happy.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Lets say there is or eventually will be other behind-the-scenes things we can't really affect normally. Those would be PERFECT things to have new VA's for.


Now you're getting the picture!
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ah. Player Y is not better than Player X in every situation, unless he has set himself up to be better of course. Confirm that.

I like random, though. Ever notice some players in the NFL take a play off from time to time (T.O. lol)? That would be interesting. Streaky is one of my favorite VA's. What if players had a natural streakyness factor?

I also like the idea of players perhaps having an intrinsic ability that comes out after some amount of time, sort of like the superstar idea (one of them) that was epic for a while. I think that's a neat idea that could be investigated, and I don't want to throw it out the window.


OK, so you can confirm that there is nothing in place behind the scenes that pre-determines one player will always, say, run a route faster, block better, or throw more accurately than another player with the same exact skills, SA's, VA's, and equipment? If there is/ever will be something behind the scenes, it'll be like what you describe there, to make things more random?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ah. Player Y is not better than Player X in every situation, unless he has set himself up to be better of course. Confirm that.


Pretty sure there is a bug with the code somewhere then.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Pretty sure there is a bug with the code somewhere then.


Quiet, you. I want an answer to my question first

If that part is confirmed, then we can move onto the portion of this discussion where there's a bug to be fixed.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I agree that any "hidden" stuff is or will be random like I'm talking about. I think game to game and play to play randomness to be very important and interesting ideas, that mirror real life events. Sometimes players show up for the game, other times don't for whatever reason. Abilities to affect those factors are my favorite ones, actually. I love the streaky ability, though it might need some updates to work less all or nothing. I also like clutch. Some players tend to come up big more often in real life.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.