User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
- 2 of the plays it's the same WR
- in all of the plays, the CBs have lower fame than the WRs

(...go check WR VAs...)
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I've taken probability & stats classes.

Then I have no idea why you were confused about the significance of something happening three times in a row. Obviously I'm making an assumption, but it's absurd to think that Pump Fake would fire on 1 out of every 4 pass attempts, so 25% seems much too high. We're probably talking more like 5%, which means that it would fire on three consecutive plays once out of every 8000 possibilities. Something with that probability will occur periodically, but obviously be extremely rare, which is why I questioned whether or not there was something else at work.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

I've taken probability & stats classes.

Then I have no idea why you were confused about the significance of something happening three times in a row. Obviously I'm making an assumption, but it's absurd to think that Pump Fake would fire on 1 out of every 4 pass attempts, so 25% seems much too high. We're probably talking more like 5%, which means that it would fire on three consecutive plays once out of every 8000 possibilities. Something with that probability will occur periodically, but obviously be extremely rare, which is why I questioned whether or not there was something else at work.


First of all questioning my stats background isn't helping to make your case, because you are still assuming the chance of a QB successfully pump faking is really low. That has no bearing on whether or not I'm good at statistics, because whether I think it's statistically possible depends on what the actual probability of the fake happening in the first place is.

I don't think it's an absurd assumption at all. Especially on plays where there are 5 WRs...more chances for people to get faked. I've seen QBs who can pump fake with regularity. I'm talking about like 15+ times a game. Couple VAs like Awe-Inspiring, Underdog for the WRs, and Clever Instinct, Fake % equipment, for the QB, and it's really not much of a stretch to assume 1 out of 5 of those corners would have a 25% chance to get faked on one of those plays.

If it was 25%, the probability of it firing it would have a 1/64 chance of firing 3 times in a row. Which is rare, but it would happen (like in this case).

20% would be 1/125

Again, it is highly improbable, but that doesn't mean it will never happen. How often do you see it happen?
Edited by Sik Wit It on Aug 21, 2009 13:38:04
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Btw over 230 leagues with 32 teams apiece is 7,360 teams. 16 games a year 117,760 games simmed at let's say 100 pass attempts a game is 11,776,000 passes a season, and that's just for one season not even counting playoffs or scrimmages. So even a 1/8000 chance doesn't seem too rare anymore does it? With those odds it would happen roughly over 1,472 times a season. Add just pre-season and post-season scrims/playoff games, and it would happen roughly 2,208 times a year.

Now I know, not all of those leagues have QBs able to pump fake, but you get my point right?

I'm not going to say it's not a bug, because you never know with GLB. But it's bound to happen every once in awhile.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
First of all questioning my stats background isn't helping to make your case

Someone who doesn't understand the probabilistic significance of something happening three straight times obviously doesn't have much of a mathematics background. If you're sensitive about that, I suggest that stop saying things that make you look like you have limited knowledge of probabilities.

Originally posted by
because you are still assuming the chance of a QB successfully pump faking is really low.

Yes, I am, because it makes no sense for a powerful SA to be firing all the time. Plus I'm pretty sure GLB agents would have noticed if Pump Fakes were going off every 4 pass attempts or so.

Originally posted by
Especially on plays where there are 5 WRs...more chances for people to get faked.

The QB doesn't get a roll for every CB, he gets one roll and it's only if he passes it that the CBs have to roll.

Originally posted by
I've seen QBs who can pump fake with regularity. I'm talking about like 15+ times a game.

Please do not waste my time by pretending like 25% Pump Fake is a reasonable assertion. Again, people would have noticed if Pump Fakes were happening one out of every four throws. They aren't. I'm not asking you to admit that your speculation was unrealistic, I just want you to drop it.

Originally posted by
Again, it is highly improbable, but that doesn't mean it will never happen.

I didn't say it would never happen. If you cannot use basic reading comprehension to follow along with what is being said, then please do not post at all. I asked if something else could be going on here because it would be unlikely to happen legitimately on three consecutive plays.
 
Link
 
Probability aside, the way Pump Fakes work needs some serious recoding. As stated, CB's running down the field in man coverage generally have their back somewhat turned to the QB, with their main focus being mirroring the receiver's route. Now even if they ARE keeping an eye on the the QB in the early stages of the route, there is no excuse for "stopping" just because you see his arm move.

If the man in front of you is running a standard route (say an in or a post), then why would you stop when you think a pass is coming your way? For every other pass attempt (not fake ones) the QB tends to lead the receiver along his route as opposed to throwing the ball to the exact spot the WR is when he decides to throw there. So again, why does the DB think the ball is coming and stop in his tracks allowing the WR to be led 10 yards away for a routine catch?

Realistically, pump fakes are used in 3 main scenarios:

1. The QB is under pressure due to a blown assignment/blitz, he sees a pass rusher coming towards him, and pump fakes so he leaves his feet anticipating the deflection.

2. The WR is running a "double route" such as a post corner or out/in and up. When the WR makes his 1st cut (provided the QB has time) the QB may perform a pump fake. NOW the CB has reason to try and jump the route and play aggressively, as he could think the route is complete and wants to undercut the ball. Of course in real life he wouldn't stop dead, but rather jump the post or in/out, leaving the WR behind him and about to cut in the opposite direction.

3. This one is more zone coverage, but it is still realistic and a common use. If the QB has 2 WR's on the left side of the field, with his outside man running a streak and a post in the slot, the FS (we'll say hes in Cover 2) will likely need to pick which corner to help out. The QB may notice decent separation for his slot WR and decides he wants to go there, but wants the FS to commit to the outside. So if he wants (and has the time) he can look left, pump the streak to bait the FS away from the middle, and split the Cover 2 shell up the middle of the field.



Now of course I used very specific examples to get the scenarios across but the point remains, this is NOT how pump fakes are used in GLB.
Edited by San Diego Chargers on Aug 21, 2009 15:09:28
Edited by San Diego Chargers on Aug 21, 2009 15:07:07
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
But those plays might not have been pump fakes, but the CB going for the pick. I'm not sure how high is jumping is, or if they are set on aggressive like every other CB, but you have pick-off attempts that look like that, pump fakes, and WR's juking, head faking during the route on creative route running, not to mention VA's that can punish a CB, especially one lower level than the WR.

 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
in the anonymous internet, anyone can claim to be a statistics expert....

Edited by mikeandbrooke07 on Aug 21, 2009 15:25:28
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Sixx
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Just looks like a pump fake.


Pump fake excuse is bs.
When playing man to man, the CB isn't looking at the QB, he's focused on the WR. If it's zone then yeah I can see pump fake coming into play but not in man coverage.

If it's coded with CB's getting pump faked in man coverage then something needs changed there.


Thats the way it is coded in GLB. Pump Fakes happen fairly often in M2M. Just like CB's can break on the ball being throw on the otherside of the field even thought they are suppose to be looking at the WR and not the CB.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Probability aside, the way Pump Fakes work needs some serious recoding. As stated, CB's running down the field in man coverage generally have their back somewhat turned to the QB, with their main focus being mirroring the receiver's route. Now even if they ARE keeping an eye on the the QB in the early stages of the route, there is no excuse for "stopping" just because you see his arm move.


As stated before, it's not pump fakes that need to be reworked. It's CB's in general. Take away the ability of them getting pump faked when in M2M but also take away the ability for them to break on plays that aren't anywhere near them since they should be focusing on the route. Should also take away the ability to get such a good jump on a throwing lane when the ball is thrown that the WR they are covering since the WR isn't going for the catch when the ball is still so far away.





Edited by driftinggrifter on Aug 21, 2009 16:22:04
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Someone who doesn't understand the probabilistic significance of something happening three straight times obviously doesn't have much of a mathematics background. If you're sensitive about that, I suggest that stop saying things that make you look like you have limited knowledge of probabilities.


Again, it all depends on the probability of it happening in the first place, which you are assuming is very low. I'm not a math genius, and my statistics knowledge isn't the best. I'll be the first to admit that. I'm not sensitive about anything. I'm just saying it's beside the point when you are assuming the probability is a very low number like 5%, which definitely is not the case for all QBs.

Originally posted by

Yes, I am, because it makes no sense for a powerful SA to be firing all the time. Plus I'm pretty sure GLB agents would have noticed if Pump Fakes were going off every 4 pass attempts or so.


Again, it depends on the QB and the WRs. I've seen QBs who pump fake with regularity. Combine that with the vision-diminishing WR VAs, and you can get faked quite often. Plus I don't think a valid argument in GLB is "it doesn't make sense". I could spend hours making a list of things that don't make sense in this game.

Originally posted by

The QB doesn't get a roll for every CB, he gets one roll and it's only if he passes it that the CBs have to roll.


If he pump fakes, then all the CBs would have to pass the roll to not get faked.

Originally posted by

Please do not waste my time by pretending like 25% Pump Fake is a reasonable assertion. Again, people would have noticed if Pump Fakes were happening one out of every four throws. They aren't. I'm not asking you to admit that your speculation was unrealistic, I just want you to drop it.


Well if you want to tell me something I've seen with my own eyes is pretending, I don't know what to tell you. I'm telling you, I've seen QBs who pump fake all the time. If you don't want to believe me, fine. But that doesn't mean it's not true.

Originally posted by

I didn't say it would never happen. If you cannot use basic reading comprehension to follow along with what is being said, then please do not post at all. I asked if something else could be going on here because it would be unlikely to happen legitimately on three consecutive plays.


Believe it or not I comprehend what you are saying, and I am entitled to post my opinion wherever I want. And IMO, this is not a bug...just an improbable event occurring in a rare instance. I could be wrong, I could be right. Who knows. I'm just giving my input. If you don't like it, too bad. No need to act like an ass about it.
 
remus7x
offline
Link
 
Pump faked in all probability. To the point that a 25% fire rate on pump fake isn't possible, it entirely is, probably isn't 25% but it is possible. Just because a pump fake happens, it doesn't mean it's always effective. If there is a failed pump fake, you see nothing, so you can't really say you know how often pump fakes happen, just how often an effective pump fakes happens.
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by Sixx

Originally posted by Sik Wit It


Just looks like a pump fake.


Pump fake excuse is bs.
When playing man to man, the CB isn't looking at the QB, he's focused on the WR. If it's zone then yeah I can see pump fake coming into play but not in man coverage.

If it's coded with CB's getting pump faked in man coverage then something needs changed there.


Thats the way it is coded in GLB. Pump Fakes happen fairly often in M2M. Just like CB's can break on the ball being throw on the otherside of the field even thought they are suppose to be looking at the WR and not the CB.


Then that's the point of my bolded statement above. Pump fakes shouldn't affect m2m coverage. If a CB is looking at the QB in man coverage then there's no need for a pump fake cause he's already been burned. So if this is the case, it needs to be changed.
Maybe the coders need to watch an actual football game and see this.
Edited by Sixx on Aug 21, 2009 21:53:58
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Pump Fake or fake, possible exacerbated by Awe Inspiring for first play. CB has less fame than WR. If it was a pump fake that could have contributed.
Next play, possible pump fake or alternate fake from creates routes again. thats also part of that route where i see those kick in. CB again has less fame so Awe Inspiring could be hurting his vision. Could also be got faked out of his shoes.. same receiver both plays so far.
Last play, not the same route, and we see the pump fake didn;t freeze CB3, so pump fake does seem more likely as it went to another player who shows a hesitation in the route.

Can't be sure but its a fake of some sort.

And you do not understand probabilities if you think the odds of something happening three times in a row mean anything.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
I am 90% sure this is a pump fake. I think what you are asking for is a better representation of that, so you know what is happening. I will Pass that on to Bort.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.