User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Coverage and Cushions - Please Address this
Page:
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Watch it 1/2 tic by tick (unless you are already on 10fps then its tic by tic)

1 click after ball thrown, CB moves backwards (cut wasmade about two/three clicks previous, CB kept moving away)
2 clicks, he's continuing to move away from receiver.
3rd click he's now motionless.
4th Click, again still motionless.
5th click, moves in concert with wide receiver EG keeps the same cushion he established.
6th click, motionless as is receiver. EG keeping same distance.
7th Click, motionless but wr moves a smidgeon towards pass.
8th click, motionless
9th click begins to close.
10th click, wr and Cb are converging.
11th click they both move the same direction, same speed, gap is kept
12th click wr moves a small bit forward, CB stays in place.
13th click, cb begins to move forward to close on receiver.
14th click, wr still motionless, CB closing.
15th Click WR stays in place, CB closes.
16th click, ball completely in WR's circle. WR motionless still, CB closing.
17th click, wr barely moves, likely possession establising now, CB closing.
18th click, WR still motionless, cb closing, appears catch probably made now.
19th click, CB and WR both move about the same distance towards LoS.
20th Click, WR established possession and is now attempting to break outside, CB closes.
21 and 22 clicks WR moves back towards LoS and gets tackled.

11 'Tics' total. When ball passed, significant time with CB holding a pattern where he stayed a set distance away from the WR instead of closing on them. I've seen it on multiple CB's, all with different builds, and this is something that Wasn't happening until the slider was implemented for Season 10.

It appears sometimes depending on if they thing they have help over the top or not that they'll ignore the slider and the setting chosen by the user. It also seems to happen frequently on 3rd down where more cushion will be provided if the route is short of the first down marker.

Its not the build. I can guaranty that if this same play was run in Season 9 sim, the behaviour would not be the same.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Watch it 1/2 tic by tick (unless you are already on 10fps then its tic by tic)

1 click after ball thrown, CB moves backwards (cut wasmade about two/three clicks previous, CB kept moving away)
2 clicks, he's continuing to move away from receiver.
3rd click he's now motionless.
4th Click, again still motionless.
5th click, moves in concert with wide receiver EG keeps the same cushion he established.
6th click, motionless as is receiver. EG keeping same distance.
7th Click, motionless but wr moves a smidgeon towards pass.
8th click, motionless

9th click begins to close.
10th click, wr and Cb are converging.
11th click they both move the same direction, same speed, gap is kept
12th click wr moves a small bit forward, CB stays in place.
13th click, cb begins to move forward to close on receiver.
14th click, wr still motionless, CB closing.
15th Click WR stays in place, CB closes.
16th click, ball completely in WR's circle. WR motionless still, CB closing.
17th click, wr barely moves, likely possession establising now, CB closing.
18th click, WR still motionless, cb closing, appears catch probably made now.
19th click, CB and WR both move about the same distance towards LoS.
20th Click, WR established possession and is now attempting to break outside, CB closes.
21 and 22 clicks WR moves back towards LoS and gets tackled.

11 'Tics' total. When ball passed, significant time with CB holding a pattern where he stayed a set distance away from the WR instead of closing on them. I've seen it on multiple CB's, all with different builds, and this is something that Wasn't happening until the slider was implemented for Season 10.

It appears sometimes depending on if they thing they have help over the top or not that they'll ignore the slider and the setting chosen by the user. It also seems to happen frequently on 3rd down where more cushion will be provided if the route is short of the first down marker.

Its not the build. I can guaranty that if this same play was run in Season 9 sim, the behaviour would not be the same.


Uhh yeah...that whole bolded part is him changing direction. You know...recognizing the pass is thrown, stopping all his backward momentum, shifting his weight, and beginning to close in. Everything after that, I have no idea what you're talking about. Again, all I see is him changing direction, then making the tackle. 11 ticks I think is one second or half a second. It was either 10 ticks = 1 second or 20 ticks = 1 second...I forgot. That's really not a lot of time. Like I said, he was changing direction. It probably wasn't happening last season as much because CBs were only allowed to cover a WR at a certain distance. I forgot what it was, but there was no 0 yard coverage.

With 0 yard coverage, your CB is looking to stay directly on the WR as much as to his ability allows him. Which means if that WR was running a streak, your CB would need to be with him every step of the way. When he cut back toward the LOS, your CB who was probably ready to run all the way with the WR had to stop all his momentum going one way, and then break on the WR. The WR has the advantage of knowing the route...the defender does not. The closer you play to a WR, the more you are likely to overcommit yourself, and get beat on a certain route. You can't just expect your CB to know every route the WR is going to run, and stay with him 100% of the time, turning on a dime and breaking on the ball perfectly. Each setting has its upside and downside. With 0 yd coverage you will play him closer, but you will have more of a chance to get beat. Playing farther back might give up some shorter passes, but you will have more room for error and will not get beat deep as often.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Aug 14, 2009 03:20:32
 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Post his build so we can laugh at you.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
faked out of your boots yo
 
Link
 
This is something that has been happening LONG before season 10. Maybe you haven't been watching.

Maybe you just screwed up his build this season?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
In season 9, Close coverage was 0 yard coverage. So don't try to make the argument that 0 yard coverage didn't exist. I've multiple CB's of a number of different build types. I'm GM on a large number of teams, I've seen all sorts of builds and different settings, and this started happening after season 9 with the new Season 10 pass coverage slider and whatever other pass coverage changes Bort implemented.

I love the bully/gang mentality that occurs on the forums 'neads moar vision!' and then personal attacks. Just scan back through the history, at the start of most every season going back through season 6ish at least, likely much further, there have always been changes and tweaks to CB coverage. You'll also see Bort had to undo a lot of those changes because they weren't working quite right.

Season 10 we got the slider, and CB's that were working well, of all sorts of builds, started doing this much more often. I know how coverage works, I know how the come backs work, I know about having enough agility to make the turns and etc etc etc. The issue is, why is the cb maintaining a new cushion distance? He recovers from the route and then sits at the new cushion distance. Even though its obvious he knows whats happening because he moves WITH the WR, when the WR moves, the CB shadows the move, but maintains a new distance.

It also happens in the way TE's get covered at times. I've had CB's that cover WR's perfectly fine but you line them up to cover a TE and they give up a cushion, just like LB's and SS's will do occasionally where even though they line up directly across from the TE the give jump out and give the player a cushion and maintain that distances until the ball is nearly caught then they close. Despite the pass coverage distance settings.

AND it happens if you are at 100, 95, 90, 85, 80, etc. I've tested.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure it's a bug, but I think it might have something to do with the cb "shoot forward" problem that happened a couple seasons ago. If you remember, when a cb was set on close coverage, but the play had him starting some distance from the wr, he would shoot forward to get to his coverage distance which put him running towards the line of scrimmage while the wr was running the opposite direction. It looks like now the cb keeps somewhat of the same distance that he starts at, runs in the proper direction, but goes slower than he normally would so that the wr closes the distance to the cb's coverage distance. I think that is what you are seeing at the beginning of the play.

As for the extra space the cb gives the wr right before the catch, it could either be a failed vision check, or it might be that he tried to speed up once the wr closed to the proper distance, and it just so happened that at that time the wr made his cut, so the cb was speeding up right when the wr was stopping.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
WR could have underdog. Those comeback like routes are tough to defend, but at least he made the tackle.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
In season 9, Close coverage was 0 yard coverage. So don't try to make the argument that 0 yard coverage didn't exist. I've multiple CB's of a number of different build types. I'm GM on a large number of teams, I've seen all sorts of builds and different settings, and this started happening after season 9 with the new Season 10 pass coverage slider and whatever other pass coverage changes Bort implemented.

I love the bully/gang mentality that occurs on the forums 'neads moar vision!' and then personal attacks. Just scan back through the history, at the start of most every season going back through season 6ish at least, likely much further, there have always been changes and tweaks to CB coverage. You'll also see Bort had to undo a lot of those changes because they weren't working quite right.

Season 10 we got the slider, and CB's that were working well, of all sorts of builds, started doing this much more often. I know how coverage works, I know how the come backs work, I know about having enough agility to make the turns and etc etc etc. The issue is, why is the cb maintaining a new cushion distance? He recovers from the route and then sits at the new cushion distance. Even though its obvious he knows whats happening because he moves WITH the WR, when the WR moves, the CB shadows the move, but maintains a new distance.

It also happens in the way TE's get covered at times. I've had CB's that cover WR's perfectly fine but you line them up to cover a TE and they give up a cushion, just like LB's and SS's will do occasionally where even though they line up directly across from the TE the give jump out and give the player a cushion and maintain that distances until the ball is nearly caught then they close. Despite the pass coverage distance settings.

AND it happens if you are at 100, 95, 90, 85, 80, etc. I've tested.


Yeah I was wrong about there not being 0 yd coverage before the slider. Still though, he is NOT maintaining a new cushion distance. If you wanna do the tick by tick thing, look from the very beginning of the play.

Tick 1-22 - He is letting the WR come to him. Would you rather him lunge forward, to close the distance at the beginning of the play, then get beat deep? Let's not bring up that bug again. (Check out CB2: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=692789&pbp_id=18536512)
Tick 23 - 29 - He is at 0 yd coverage distance, staying with WR
Tick 30 - 40 - He is fooled by the route, and has to change direction
Tick 41+ - He closes in on WR

I really think you're looking at it from a very biased point of view...which is understandable because it's your player. But I don't see him "maintaining the new distance even though he knows what's going on". By the time he realizes what's going on, and changes his direction accordingly, he closes to make the tackle.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
My mistake is I only posted this one play, I've posted multiple plays up, with other players not my own in the past. Its not that it is my player, its that this started in Season 10, and continues. Season 9 I didn't see this occur often at all.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=701730&pbp_id=2479444

Another example (I've posted others) of the CB lining up in M2M on the TE and giving up a HUGE cushion.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=701730&pbp_id=2479444

Another example (I've posted others) of the CB lining up in M2M on the TE and giving up a HUGE cushion.


What were his settings at the time and what was the play called?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
In the DPC its cover man. CB3 on TE.
For his personal tactics its set top -95 on the slider and I was on aggressive for this game to test things.

It's happened to other cb's lined up the same way. Just like it happens to LB's and SS's or anyone else it seems set to cover the TE. Doesn't happen every play but sometimes the coverage whacks out and stays far off their man. I personally think its much the same as what happens in the CB man coverage on WR's sometimes because they maintain the same distance apart and then close once the ball gets closer.

I've posted other replays, different players as well as other people on other teams posting the same thing, generally its a LOLB, SS or the CB that has the weird cushion.

It does not seem the coverage slider is always obeyed. Started in... Season 10.... as I have said. Nevr had this problem with DPC coverages in Season 9.
Edited by Enkidu98 on Aug 14, 2009 13:35:32
 
head1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=701730&pbp_id=2479444

Another example (I've posted others) of the CB lining up in M2M on the TE and giving up a HUGE cushion.


Bad example, you are in cruise mode at that point.

Looks like build issues to me in the first one. Speed to far past agility or very high first step.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
In the DPC its cover man. CB3 on TE.
For his personal tactics its set top -95 on the slider and I was on aggressive for this game to test things.

It's happened to other cb's lined up the same way. Just like it happens to LB's and SS's or anyone else it seems set to cover the TE. Doesn't happen every play but sometimes the coverage whacks out and stays far off their man. I personally think its much the same as what happens in the CB man coverage on WR's sometimes because they maintain the same distance apart and then close once the ball gets closer.

I've posted other replays, different players as well as other people on other teams posting the same thing, generally its a LOLB, SS or the CB that has the weird cushion.

It does not seem the coverage slider is always obeyed. Started in... Season 10.... as I have said. Nevr had this problem with DPC coverages in Season 9.


I think the TE coverage is a known bug. Still not convinced there's a problem with CB/WRs though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.