Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
NiborRis
offline
offline
Being able to "group" the tagged replays might be nice, rather than just a long list of jumbled up plays. I mean, yeah, the note could say something like "First down Shotgun Play 1" and so forth but if they're just on the list in the order you tagged them, it would be a jumbled mess. Being able to put them into groups, or perhaps even just put them into whatever order you wanted, would be nice to be able to organize it.
Also, if there could be a kind of one-line note to appear on the page, and then a drill-down longer notepad for multiple lines of text that you would click on to view, might be nice to avoid too much clutter on the page all at once.
How is this page going to appear, and how will it work if I'm Scouting for multiple teams?
Like, say I scout for teams A and B, and I'm currently looking at team X, who is an upcoming opponent of team A.
Will the "scouting" page for team X show up as a tab on team X, or as a tab on team A somehow? Off the top of my head, I'd think as a tab on team X's page, with a dropdown for what team you're scouting from (so for me, I'd see a dropdown of team A and team B). And obviously you'd need team A scouting priv. to see team A's copy of the scouting tab.
Also, if there could be a kind of one-line note to appear on the page, and then a drill-down longer notepad for multiple lines of text that you would click on to view, might be nice to avoid too much clutter on the page all at once.
How is this page going to appear, and how will it work if I'm Scouting for multiple teams?
Like, say I scout for teams A and B, and I'm currently looking at team X, who is an upcoming opponent of team A.
Will the "scouting" page for team X show up as a tab on team X, or as a tab on team A somehow? Off the top of my head, I'd think as a tab on team X's page, with a dropdown for what team you're scouting from (so for me, I'd see a dropdown of team A and team B). And obviously you'd need team A scouting priv. to see team A's copy of the scouting tab.
ijg
offline
offline
Can the jokers please leave so we can have a useful discussion...
Bort, the scouting bar, top threats, and results are easy enough to get by clicking on the matchup bar or the team name on your schedule. Not sure those add much unless I didn't follow what you had in mind.
What would be great is an easy way to sort run vs pass plays, 1st vs 2nd vs 3rd down plays, etc. as part of the replay tagging idea. I know you can get most of this from monsterkill's script, but if there were drop down buttons where you could just select by down or run vs. pass or by formation and have it spit out the relevant plays, that would make things so much easier.
Other thing is what will access be to the scouting notes? Can anyone on the team see it? Only GMs? Only permitted GMs? We do all this manually now on our private forum to keep game planning secret. I think for this to be useful it has to be only made accessible to permitted GMs like assigning right to AI, depth chart, finances, etc.
Bort, the scouting bar, top threats, and results are easy enough to get by clicking on the matchup bar or the team name on your schedule. Not sure those add much unless I didn't follow what you had in mind.
What would be great is an easy way to sort run vs pass plays, 1st vs 2nd vs 3rd down plays, etc. as part of the replay tagging idea. I know you can get most of this from monsterkill's script, but if there were drop down buttons where you could just select by down or run vs. pass or by formation and have it spit out the relevant plays, that would make things so much easier.
Other thing is what will access be to the scouting notes? Can anyone on the team see it? Only GMs? Only permitted GMs? We do all this manually now on our private forum to keep game planning secret. I think for this to be useful it has to be only made accessible to permitted GMs like assigning right to AI, depth chart, finances, etc.
iBlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah, it could take a bit out of scouting, but it's true that even the fans know that "Wes Welker gets the ball a lot," or "they like to run to the weak side frequently."
What if we somehow built up a "tendencies" chart or something? Run vs pass, etc.
Just give percents for run/pass, or would the chart say something like Rush out of Strong I 30%, out of single back, etc? Because that would be alot more helpful.
Yeah, it could take a bit out of scouting, but it's true that even the fans know that "Wes Welker gets the ball a lot," or "they like to run to the weak side frequently."
What if we somehow built up a "tendencies" chart or something? Run vs pass, etc.
Just give percents for run/pass, or would the chart say something like Rush out of Strong I 30%, out of single back, etc? Because that would be alot more helpful.
forestrobin
offline
offline
If you're going to put the outcomes of the last X games, it would be nice to have basic statistics about those games, such as those found in the Box Scores (e.g. Pass Attempts/Completions, Rush Attempts/Completions, Yards etc.).
Pretty similar to the information you can get from the Game Scout Greasemonkey script, and should be pretty easy to do as all the information is there already - just needs totalling up for whatever X is chosen.
Pretty similar to the information you can get from the Game Scout Greasemonkey script, and should be pretty easy to do as all the information is there already - just needs totalling up for whatever X is chosen.
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
Kitna
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah, it could take a bit out of scouting, but it's true that even the fans know that "Wes Welker gets the ball a lot," or "they like to run to the weak side frequently."
What if we somehow built up a "tendencies" chart or something? Run vs pass, etc.
i would like it if it was something like the scouting greasemonkey now
Yeah, it could take a bit out of scouting, but it's true that even the fans know that "Wes Welker gets the ball a lot," or "they like to run to the weak side frequently."
What if we somehow built up a "tendencies" chart or something? Run vs pass, etc.
i would like it if it was something like the scouting greasemonkey now
Originally posted by NiborRis
Off the top of my head, I'd think as a tab on team X's page, with a dropdown for what team you're scouting from (so for me, I'd see a dropdown of team A and team B). And obviously you'd need team A scouting priv. to see team A's copy of the scouting tab.
This is exactly what I'm thinking.
Off the top of my head, I'd think as a tab on team X's page, with a dropdown for what team you're scouting from (so for me, I'd see a dropdown of team A and team B). And obviously you'd need team A scouting priv. to see team A's copy of the scouting tab.
This is exactly what I'm thinking.
Sixx
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
That would be great, imo.
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
That would be great, imo.

RandomBeast
offline
offline
tag replays by play call and formation. This is information anyone could get by looking at the play and then matching it to the playbook, so take the tedious part out and just list the play.
Then let the scout page filter the last 5 games worth of plays (both sides of the ball) by down, distance, yard line, quarter and play call/formation. Or better yet, let the user pick up to 5 games to load into the scout page - so you can tag close matchups or recent losses or your last matchup, etc.
Then let the scout page filter the last 5 games worth of plays (both sides of the ball) by down, distance, yard line, quarter and play call/formation. Or better yet, let the user pick up to 5 games to load into the scout page - so you can tag close matchups or recent losses or your last matchup, etc.
Originally posted by ijg
Other thing is what will access be to the scouting notes? Can anyone on the team see it? Only GMs? Only permitted GMs? We do all this manually now on our private forum to keep game planning secret. I think for this to be useful it has to be only made accessible to permitted GMs like assigning right to AI, depth chart, finances, etc.
Could be added as a GM privilege. "Scout" privilege or some such.
Other thing is what will access be to the scouting notes? Can anyone on the team see it? Only GMs? Only permitted GMs? We do all this manually now on our private forum to keep game planning secret. I think for this to be useful it has to be only made accessible to permitted GMs like assigning right to AI, depth chart, finances, etc.
Could be added as a GM privilege. "Scout" privilege or some such.
Originally posted by RandomBeast
tag replays by play call and formation. This is information anyone could get by looking at the play and then matching it to the playbook, so take the tedious part out and just list the play.
Then let the scout page filter the last 5 games worth of plays (both sides of the ball) by down, distance, yard line, quarter and play call/formation. Or better yet, let the user pick up to 5 games to load into the scout page - so you can tag close matchups or recent losses or your last matchup, etc.
I like the "pick game to analyze" idea. Instead of just last 3/4 games (perhaps that could just be the default)
tag replays by play call and formation. This is information anyone could get by looking at the play and then matching it to the playbook, so take the tedious part out and just list the play.
Then let the scout page filter the last 5 games worth of plays (both sides of the ball) by down, distance, yard line, quarter and play call/formation. Or better yet, let the user pick up to 5 games to load into the scout page - so you can tag close matchups or recent losses or your last matchup, etc.
I like the "pick game to analyze" idea. Instead of just last 3/4 games (perhaps that could just be the default)
Live4TheWarren Brotherhood
offline
offline
Oops sorry just a bit slow, Bort just posted it
Basically exactly what I had. But I still think open build would be nice on the roster.
Originally posted by Bort
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
Basically exactly what I had. But I still think open build would be nice on the roster.Originally posted by Bort
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
Edited by Live4TheWarren Brotherhood on Aug 11, 2009 14:13:00
Edited by Live4TheWarren Brotherhood on Aug 11, 2009 14:12:34
ijg
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
Very good, but FYI, this is essentially what monsterkill script does if you haven't seen it. A more user friendly version would be nice but honestly, I'm not sure this gives me that much new.
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.
I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:
pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff
I think maybe some combination of those would be good?
Very good, but FYI, this is essentially what monsterkill script does if you haven't seen it. A more user friendly version would be nice but honestly, I'm not sure this gives me that much new.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























