User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add 10 season decline to the NEVER going to happen list
Page:
 
LoperK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tpaterniti

You can criticize it but Bort has told me plainly that it is never going to happen. But by all means discuss to your hearts content.


What I have said many times is that players are going to decline in some way at some point. They are not going to live forever and keep getting better until every stat is at 100, because that would be really dumb and would make the HOF pointless. I'm still up for suggestions on things they can do after they start to "get old" (coaches, "legacy", etc)

You can add 100% FP refund on retirements to the "never going to happen" list, though.


Ya 100% FP refund is a retarded idea. I just think this idea needs to be revamped to make it so everybody is happy. That way Bort makes a profit, (which he obviously should) noobies get to get better and be on top, and vets are happy and not left discarded on the side.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Thats super nice to hear Bort and as long as It stays open for re-working then im sure the right thing will happen when the time comes.
In the meantime know your scaring away hardcore MMORPG guys though and throwing money to other devs?
The market is so dam big people are screaming for the long term game.

Everyone alive till all stats are 100 is pretty funny concept...im not sure anyone has suggested that lol.

Would move my Kicker to NT if that were the case


as long as decline is in place your fighting an uphill battle imho.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 21:08:06
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I think you could really bring in a lot of options.

My suggestions, quickly:
- First, have the decline come a little bit later, with a plateau and a decline that starts slow and speeds up exponentially.
- For those that would rather keep building like a MMORPG, they "retire" their players from the regular game (whatever records they have at that point for HOF) and rather than retire for 70% FP back, their player moves to a legacy league and keeps growing.
- For those that want to retire but not rebuild, they can become a coach in the regular game
- For those that want to retire and rebuild, 70% FP back when they choose to retire.
- For those that want to retire and rebuild a "son", less FP back and enhanced attributes to begin with as a son of a GLB veteran
 
Fandom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tpaterniti

You can criticize it but Bort has told me plainly that it is never going to happen. But by all means discuss to your hearts content.


What I have said many times is that players are going to decline in some way at some point. They are not going to live forever and keep getting better until every stat is at 100, because that would be really dumb and would make the HOF pointless. I'm still up for suggestions on things they can do after they start to "get old" (coaches, "legacy", etc)

You can add 100% FP refund on retirements to the "never going to happen" list, though.


Players MUST decline at some point or the game will get ridiculous fast.

Ten seasons is a good time for the decline to begin IMO.

I'd be more in favor of individual scales for the different positions to more accuratelly reflect pro ball. But a "generic" ten years is MUCH better than allowing players to live on into infinity.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
I think you could really bring in a lot of options.

My suggestions, quickly:
- First, have the decline come a little bit later, with a plateau and a decline that starts slow and speeds up exponentially.
- For those that would rather keep building like a MMORPG, they "retire" their players from the regular game (whatever records they have at that point for HOF) and rather than retire for 70% FP back, their player moves to a legacy league and keeps growing.
- For those that want to retire but not rebuild, they can become a coach in the regular game
- For those that want to retire and rebuild, 70% FP back when they choose to retire.
- For those that want to retire and rebuild a "son", less FP back and enhanced attributes to begin with as a son of a GLB veteran


Agreed on first point, especially about the plateau idea. The 11th season should be pure plateau and the 12th should be decline only about equal to what would have been gained in the 10th. And if they decide to make it 12 seasons before decline, that's no big deal either way to me, either.

Mostly agreed on 2nd point, though I'd have it be a "Senior's League" with no gain or loss. If they played in regular leagues past peak, they restore to their peak stats. It's unrealistic, and for the server space would have to be pay to play; but should satisfy those who are attached to their players (which will, with some players, include me). It won't satisfy the pure WoW types; but it should satisfy those who simply hate the idea of parting with their players.

Agreed about Coaching, and let them do cool things that only coaches can do, such as creating one's own plays.

To those that purely retire and rebuild and don't take any other path, I'd give 80% back.

The "son" idea, starting at a slightly higher level than 1 (probably 2, with the abilities that come with that) seems the best way to handle that, with reduced points back.
 
Fandom
offline
Link
 
The default position should be as close to reality as can be achieved within the confines of a MMORPG.

I understand some things need to be tweaked for expedience. But it does need to at least be in the ballpark of something resembling reality.
 
Martin
offline
Link
 
I think the decline should be based on positions. Like in real life, at 30, you are almost done as a HB. But you can play up to late 30s,a round 40, as a quarterback. So the game will still be somewhat unrealistic. Also, if all FP boosts were even, I think it would make sense. Add in decline but have it vary by positions, but let FP boosts be equal. After all, the positions that suffer from being the most costly to boost, are the ones that normally have the biggest factors in game.

But if to be far to all, I would say make decline wait a few more seasons, and make it slower. After all, some of us pay for this.
 
Fandom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Martin
I think the decline should be based on positions. Like in real life, at 30, you are almost done as a HB....


My sentiments exactly. Good idea.

Last edited Jun 1, 2008 15:54:36
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tpaterniti

You can criticize it but Bort has told me plainly that it is never going to happen. But by all means discuss to your hearts content.


What I have said many times is that players are going to decline in some way at some point. They are not going to live forever and keep getting better until every stat is at 100, because that would be really dumb and would make the HOF pointless. I'm still up for suggestions on things they can do after they start to "get old" (coaches, "legacy", etc)

You can add 100% FP refund on retirements to the "never going to happen" list, though.


Guys, remember, this is still a business. If they gave back ALL of the FP, then where would the incentive to SPEND be?

Can't ask them to dump all this effort into the game just for the heck of it.

(Not saying anybody here is doing that, just putting it out there)
 
Fandom
offline
Link
 
I read somewhere above where you could have an "offspring" option.

That might be a good idea. Allow players to retire their existing players and have a new player come into the game at HALF (or 35% or 60% or whatever) of their highest level they achieved. Allow them to change positions too.

That could go far to helping with the overpopulation at some positions too.

Note: Allow players to come back in at 70 percent of their peak level (you get 70 percent back on flex points anyway). NOT 70 percent of your stats...just the level. Make them "fifth" year players. That would be just about right because they wouldn't have any of the daily training increases but they could still get a lot of skills from their level increases.

Anyway, that would need to be tweaked somewhat to get it just right...but the point is, that players are not going to want to start over at level 1.

I really don't want to start over at level 1 when my players retire...I can tell you that now.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tpaterniti

You can criticize it but Bort has told me plainly that it is never going to happen. But by all means discuss to your hearts content.


What I have said many times is that players are going to decline in some way at some point. They are not going to live forever and keep getting better until every stat is at 100, because that would be really dumb and would make the HOF pointless. I'm still up for suggestions on things they can do after they start to "get old" (coaches, "legacy", etc)

You can add 100% FP refund on retirements to the "never going to happen" list, though.


Hey Bort, is there any way to possibly tie in the training/game play intensity to factor into when your guys starts to decline instead of a cap of number of years? I think it would be better to see intense guys burn out faster then relaxed guys, I think it is pretty self explanatory to why it could be this way.
 
rc_ziggy84
offline
Link
 
I don't get why people can't understand that this game is not like every other MMORPG.
 
LoperK
offline
Link
 
They just locked my thread...I don't understand why...Everyone was making great ideas.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Thats super nice to hear Bort and as long as It stays open for re-working then im sure the right thing will happen when the time comes.
In the meantime know your scaring away hardcore MMORPG guys though.
The market is so dam big people are screaming for the long term game.

Everyone alive till all stats are 100 is pretty funny concept...im not sure anyone has suggested that lol.

Would move my Kicker to NT if that were the case


This game IS long-term. Christ Bort and Co. are giving back 70% of your money spent to keep playing. Imagine WoW giving back $11 of every $15 spent each month, that's unheard of.

The idea that a player should keep playing beyond 10 years is silly. 10 years is a totally arbitrary number, but once you've hit your peak (and probably the 2 or 3 solid playing years after it) feel free to get 70% of ALL FPs investing in that toon back and make another one.

If Bort's generosity is "scaring away hardcore MMOers" then speaking strictly for myself, I'd say "good".
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
How about instead of a "son" inheriting skills from the father, he gets the higher level equipment from his father. He'd still start at LV1, but might have a lv40 piece of equipment...He'd still have to level up like all the other players, but there would be a small advantage for the first few seasons, and over time other players would catch up, much like real life.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 16:50:33
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.