User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #1 > I'll be seeing more of ya'll next season
Page:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
There are actually a couple of problems with the World League. First, there's nothing really trying anyone to anyone else. It's totally antiseptic because these aren't teams you've played against or even teams who have played against teams you've played against. There is no sense of history or connection there. Then, adding yet another tier makes it almost impossible for any cap 13 team to ever earn their way up to the top. Think about what would be required. If you made the playoffs every single season from 13 through Uncapped, and then were able to get promoted your first seasons in AA, AAA, and Pro, then you'd still only make the World League by your 9th season. And that's if everything goes just about perfectly. You can theoretically get there a season faster if you win your league every single season, but I don't believe that's realistic. So basically the only teams you're going to have in the World League are those who have already been there and just recruited new rosters.


I think with your first point you're discounting the tournaments and friendlies the current pro teams play - they play a lot of games and at least the upper echelons of each pro league seem to play each other a lot today.

Your point about 13 cap teams never being able to make it with their first generation of players is well taken though...although the pro league may increase their chances of getting to pro.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
I think with your first point you're discounting the tournaments and friendlies the current pro teams play - they play a lot of games and at least the upper echelons of each pro league seem to play each other a lot today.

That's kind of my point. Pro teams can already play each other and find out "who's the best" without disrupting leagues, and I don't think anyone would argue that those tournaments produce the same kind of rivalries that teams have within their own leagues. Cincinnati vs. Drygerian was a big deal this season, but did that really feel as important to the Shockers as beating OFG, a conference foe they've battled with for many seasons? You'd have to ask cincredfan, but I really doubt it.

Originally posted by
Your point about 13 cap teams never being able to make it with their first generation of players is well taken though...although the pro league may increase their chances of getting to pro.

"Pro" loses a lot of its luster if it's no longer the highest tier. It would still be an accomplishment, just like getting to AAA, but no longer would you have that sense of having joined the "elite." I just think it's a broken system if you have virtually no chance of starting at the bottom and working your way up. Building two complete waves of players just isn't realistic for most groups who play this game together.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.