User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sdspawn
Fine- you caught me. I'm Bort's long lost son. Next season I'm playing CB and winning the defensive MVP to make up for all the Christmas presents I didn't get growing up.


lol....are you honestly saying you think Barry deserves the MVP? What did he do vs the teams that counted that makes him the Most Valuable Player in this league? For a lvl 61 RB IMO he should have been the MVP favorite at the start of the season, but not with the stats he put up this season. Anybody can stat pad vs weaker teams. Look at Sterling Bulldawgs RB Adrian "AD" Peterson who ran for 1,001 yards and 17 TDs vs Manchester Mustangs (http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=595205)

Like I mentioned earlier, I totally would take my MVP trophy if the formula gave it to me. I could be wrong! Barry could be the Most Valuable Player in this league. All those games vs playoff teams he could have been conserving his best stuff for the playoffs. Tomorrow's game vs the Mustangs he could shine. His stat line vs St. John's 14 car, 38. 5 yards, 2.8 avg, 0 TDs.........5 rec, 33.5 yards, 0 TDs could have been a fluke. Tomorrow we will see the leagues MVP show his true colors and lead Glasgow to a win. It could make for an interesting matchup in round 2
 
sdspawn
offline
Link
 
Lvl 60+ players= players built before any of us knew what the heck we were doing. No doubt whatsoever everyone else mentioned in this thread has a better "build"- we're all a lot better at this now. My 2nd generation players blow away my first group.

That said, I'll play devil's advocate to your argument here all night simply because it's my player. Does he deserve the MVP? Yup. Bort says so- it's his formula and Barry gave him what he wanted to see out of an MVP more than the other players. You wanna propose a better formula go for it- I want even agree that it's better than the current one! But one thing I'm pretty sure of is the formula is pretty darn close to what it was last season so everyone had a clue to what Bort wanted.

Please don't misconstrue this as a fight and as you said, you'd hold the title proudly if it was given to you also. If this thread hadn't been started you never would've heard a peep from me singing my back's praises. But I will say this- if there was a stat that counted total dots made small, Barry would've run laps around all of ya!
Edited by sdspawn on Jul 22, 2009 22:22:05
 
brownryango
offline
Link
 
i think the MVP formulas are fucked. i know GLB wants to add something cool to the game that spits out a player at the end of the season, but i don't think it's as easy as that. strength of schedule, play vs. good opponents, important/clutch plays should all be taken into account and i really don't think that's something a formula is going to be able to do.
 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sdspawn
Lvl 60+ players= players built before any of us knew what the keck we were doing. No doubt whatsoever everyone else mentioned in this thread has a better "build"- we're all a lot better at this now. My 2nd generation players blow away my first group.

That said, I'll play devil's advocate to your argument here all night simply because it's my player. Does he deserve the MVP? Yup. Bort says so- it's his formula and Barry gave him what he wanted to see out of an MVP more than the other players. You wanna propose a better formula go for it- I want even agree that it's better than the current one! But one thing I'm pretty sure of is the formula is pretty darn close to what it was last season so everyone had a clue to what Bort wanted.

Please don't misconstrue this as a fight and as you said, you'd hold the title proudly if it was given to you also. If this thread hadn't been started you never would've heard a peep from me singing my back's praises. But I will say this- if there was a stat that counted total dots made small, Barry would've run laps around all of ya!


LOL, I would hold that trophy up proudly if I had it....this isn't a fight at all. I enjoy good banter. Barry is no doubt a good back. I would keep my three guys (on Emps) over him, but like you I'm bias. I agree 1st gen players were at a huge disadvantage as the game has changed a lot since then, but it changes each season. You slow build a guy for three season and by the end of that 3rd season the sim has changed and your work isn't what you thought.

According to GLB Barry 2k9 is the Eastern MVP, congrats!
 
sdspawn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brownryango
i think the MVP formulas are fucked. i know GLB wants to add something cool to the game that spits out a player at the end of the season, but i don't think it's as easy as that. strength of schedule, play vs. good opponents, important/clutch plays should all be taken into account and i really don't think that's something a formula is going to be able to do.


Even I agree with this! Here's the ULTIMATE example of how the formula can get screwy:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=651864&playoffs=0

This guy was LEADING the MVP voting in a USA AA league until the last few games- he still ended up 4th.

I still wish they counted the small dots though....
 
ecrana
offline
Link
 
I've been popping in here every now and then but haven't really had too much time to post so first I want to say that you guys all put up some interesting reading and did a good job with the rankings this season. I'm part of the Bulldawgs organization and just want to say that we had some fun this season and some good games against you all even though we were still scrambling to fill the roster when the season started. Anyway, here are my 2 cents on this.

Originally posted by brownryango
i think the MVP formulas are fucked.


I agree with this in the case of MVP. The way it's set up now it basically counts TDs and hands out the award based mostly off of that as far as I'm concerned. It almost always seems like they're handing out an extra rushing title every season more than a league MVP.

I also agree that this is not something that can be solved with a formula. In real life sometimes an MVP wins because his team was decimated by injuries and he still managed to get them to the playoffs. So that has nothing to do with stats but winning games with less talent and rising above it all. Not exactly something that can be put in a formula.

Originally posted by Ts-Rock
Anybody can stat pad vs weaker teams. Look at Sterling Bulldawgs RB Adrian "AD" Peterson who ran for 1,001 yards and 17 TDs vs Manchester Mustangs (http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=595205)


Since AD is on my team I feel the need to come to his defense even though this was just put out to make a point. If you take away that game from AD and leave everyone else's padded Manchester game he would still have the 2nd highest rushing total. Not to mention that he actually did a good job running against almost every single team that made the playoffs and as far as I could tell he was the only HB to put up good numbers against the Snipers.

Back to the main topic, yes, the formula sucks and is pretty fucked but I doubt it's changing so it's just going to have to be accepted for what it is. Another way for a HB to get an award.

PS - Good luck to everyone who made the playoffs and we look forward to the competition next season.
 
djshutout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sdspawn
Lvl 60+ players= players built before any of us knew what the heck we were doing. No doubt whatsoever everyone else mentioned in this thread has a better "build"- we're all a lot better at this now. My 2nd generation players blow away my first group.

That said, I'll play devil's advocate to your argument here all night simply because it's my player. Does he deserve the MVP? Yup. Bort says so- it's his formula and Barry gave him what he wanted to see out of an MVP more than the other players. You wanna propose a better formula go for it- I want even agree that it's better than the current one! But one thing I'm pretty sure of is the formula is pretty darn close to what it was last season so everyone had a clue to what Bort wanted.

Please don't misconstrue this as a fight and as you said, you'd hold the title proudly if it was given to you also. If this thread hadn't been started you never would've heard a peep from me singing my back's praises. But I will say this- if there was a stat that counted total dots made small, Barry would've run laps around all of ya!


LOL, bort says so! Whatever dude. Sorry that you have to ride the wagon and say, "oh my 1st generation hb sucks cuz I didn't know what I was doing". Lame story all the old players us for sucking at glb. Boo hoo retire his ass and start over then. Dude you say shrinking dots. I can count endless amounts that Speed made Dots shrink, so your shrinking effect doesn't hold water. My Power HB didn't make anybody shrink, he just flat ass runs over your players. There is no shrinking with him! Only when he puts his cleats on your dots face. The MVP race is fucked plain and simple, does barry deserve it NOPE, dude didn't prove shit to me this season. I stop his ass when I played him and I would stop his ass again if I got the chance! I didn't see any shrinking when he played my defense! I think I saw him on the side lines crying! But whatever, hold your trophy high and let everybody see your old ass player holding a trophy that BORT thinks you should have for being to old and should have something handed to them for nothing.
 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
from what I have been able to gather stats that a player gets in a game that is more than 60 pts DON'T count. East Asia only had 4 games that the final score was within 60 pts so IF that is true Speed and Chief only had stats from for games so I can see why they didn't win IF that is the case. I think Barry had 9 games within 60 pts. Again, nobody truely knows the MVP formula so this is just what is floating out there.

I wasn't knocking AD, he is a very fine back. Just using that game as an stat padding example. I must say that I am proud that our guy won the overall rushing title despite the West having 3 CPU teams in it. I was sure AD or someone other back would win with that many CPU teams to go against.

 
sdspawn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djmrely
Originally posted by sdspawn

Lvl 60+ players= players built before any of us knew what the heck we were doing. No doubt whatsoever everyone else mentioned in this thread has a better "build"- we're all a lot better at this now. My 2nd generation players blow away my first group.

That said, I'll play devil's advocate to your argument here all night simply because it's my player. Does he deserve the MVP? Yup. Bort says so- it's his formula and Barry gave him what he wanted to see out of an MVP more than the other players. You wanna propose a better formula go for it- I want even agree that it's better than the current one! But one thing I'm pretty sure of is the formula is pretty darn close to what it was last season so everyone had a clue to what Bort wanted.

Please don't misconstrue this as a fight and as you said, you'd hold the title proudly if it was given to you also. If this thread hadn't been started you never would've heard a peep from me singing my back's praises. But I will say this- if there was a stat that counted total dots made small, Barry would've run laps around all of ya!


LOL, bort says so! Whatever dude. Sorry that you have to ride the wagon and say, "oh my 1st generation hb sucks cuz I didn't know what I was doing". Lame story all the old players us for sucking at glb. Boo hoo retire his ass and start over then. Dude you say shrinking dots. I can count endless amounts that Speed made Dots shrink, so your shrinking effect doesn't hold water. My Power HB didn't make anybody shrink, he just flat ass runs over your players. There is no shrinking with him! Only when he puts his cleats on your dots face. The MVP race is fucked plain and simple, does barry deserve it NOPE, dude didn't prove shit to me this season. I stop his ass when I played him and I would stop his ass again if I got the chance! I didn't see any shrinking when he played my defense! I think I saw him on the side lines crying! But whatever, hold your trophy high and let everybody see your old ass player holding a trophy that BORT thinks you should have for being to old and should have something handed to them for nothing.


I'm actually amazed this thread went this long before a cyber-bully showed. Heaven forbid an entire thread be filled with valid points and courtesy among adults. Let me know when recess is over.

 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
lol....my buddy gets fired up pretty easily, that's why he isn't in here as much. He doesn't hold back much either.
 
djshutout
offline
Link
 
No I don't show up in here! Because of back woods idiots like you from Michigan. You think you deserve the MVP when you don't. I try and stay out of here. Because there are some stupid replies like your arrogant post about how barry is the shit when in fact you say hes sucks, and should retire him. You even said He's old and I didn't know what I was doing. Look at the facts, Our players are running behind a lower level line, Our HB are lower then Barry and they still out performed him!

As far as being a cyber bully please I'm the nicest guy you will ever meet. I just don't like ass clowns that think they need things handed to them. You are simply not looking at the facts and going off that your player was handed something that he really didn't earn.
Cyber-Bully? LOL, I was cool and collected till you made your stupid comments. You can't handle the fact that you are making claims and have no proof to them that will hold water.


WE ALL KNOW IN THIS THREAD THAT SPEED/CHIEF ARE THEN MVPS OF THIS LEAGUE.


This will be the last of my inputs on this, I usually stay out of here for Idiots like yourself. Have fun training barry the rest of the season on the bench watching the elite HB and teams go further in the playoffs.
 
sdspawn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djmrely



This will be the last of my inputs on this, I usually stay out of here


One can only hope....

 
neoliminal
offline
Link
 
1. the MVP formula isn't perfect and probably never will be.
2. we don't know what it's based on, but maybe level/fame/other factor put Barry on top.
3. Barry won it, regardless of what the formula was.
4. give Bort something to work with if you think there's a better system. (you've clearly got the data to make something good.)
5. submit it to Cryptotich who is not a BUG MOD and who is also on our team ;-)
 
djshutout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sdspawn
Originally posted by djmrely




This will be the last of my inputs on this, I usually stay out of here


One can only hope....



The truth hurts don't it....
 
sdspawn
offline
Link
 
Twice now you've said you're done- yet you keep posting. If I photoshop the trophy and put your avatar next to it will you be happy and go away?

I'm honestly TRYING to keep this whole thread light-hearted (actually READ my previous posts before trying to flame me again DJ). Just let it go. Barry gave Bort the best fit for what HE wants out of an MVP, thus he gets the trophy. It doesn't match my exact definition based on stats, either, but do what Bort wants more next year if that's so important to you. I'll tell you this- I'd hand you the MYP on a silver platter in exchange for a win today. We lost, and Barry had a key fumble in that loss. It sucked. I play this GAME to win, just like most here. As stated before, no one would've heard a peep outta me proclaiming to be great if this thread hadn't been started. If I'm gonna brag about something, it'll be related to RL, not GLB, and not in a chat forum filled with anonymous tough guys.

Now I'm actually going to say this is my last post about this topic and mean it. Hopefully DJ can follow suit. GL to all those still hunting for the championship!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.