User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > How is JohnnyDollar not an admin of this site yet?
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
The biggest exploit is certain people being able to test stuff out on a secret test server and then use that info for their teams



That is true as well... I'm pretty sure Bort is a pretty smart guy to have gotten this game this far, but sometimes he makes the dumbest mistakes.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
The biggest exploit is certain people being able to test stuff out on a secret test server and then use that info for their teams



Not this one again. Where is it happening? PM me the proof.

Thanks.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
[However, why do I need to guess when I know when this guy is in the game a run is coming?.


I think one of the problems is people have honed the offense more than the defense. On defense we have the ability to sub our NT and LBs in and out. In the 4-3 that is 4 players, in the 3-4 it is 5 players. The problem is there are way too many clone builds out there. Look at a cover LOLB build for instance. If you had two of them, they could catch the QB out of a zone. You may not want to use that same LB against a power back though.

I am not one of the "fix your builds" people, but I don't think we use all the tools available to us. If you have 6 LBs on your roster, 4 different builds seems valid. Right now there seems to be two. The offense is using their personnel, and giving up a TE to run this play. I think if people used different LB combos, instead of just thinking about starters and backups, there would be more flexibility in game planning.
Edited by steellithium on Jul 21, 2009 02:59:55
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by datongw

[However, why do I need to guess when I know when this guy is in the game a run is coming?.


I think one of the problems is people have honed the offense more than the defense. On defense we have the ability our NT and LBs in and out. In the 4-3 that is 4 players, in the 3-4 it is 5 players. The problem is there are way too many clone builds out there. Look at a cover LOLB build for instance. If you had two of them, they could catch the QB out of a zone. You may not want to use that same LB against a power back though.

I am not one of the "fix your builds" people, but I don't think we use all the tools available to us. If you have 6 LBs on your roster, 4 different builds seems valid. Right now there seems to be two. The offense is using their personnel, and giving up a TE to run this play. I think if people used different LB combos, instead of just thinking about starters and backups, there would be more flexibility in game planning.


The added depth chart for defense was a good start, but really it is only helpful on certain situations, like put in your coverage LBs in on 3rd and long and pass rushing NT in on obvious passing downs. But it doesn't really help much in most of the situations, do I put in my run stopping LBs in on first down? He would get killed trying to cover the scat back out of the backfield.

The problem is that in football, many times defensive substitutions are done according to offensive personnel on the field. If a pass catching TE is in, coverage LB runs in, if a power back is in, run stopping LB gets in. Offense can have the ability to put in the right personnel into the game and use him the right way (TEs built like WRs and scat backs in on passing plays), but the defense simply doesn't have the option to do that. I can have the best coverage or run stopping LB in the game, but the best thing I can do is guess when to put him in the game, where as the offense doesn't.

Having 4 different builds of LBs sounds logical, but it simply doesn't work in GLB. A run stopping LB would get killed in the passing game by receiving TEs and scat backs. Due to this guessing game, our LBs pretty much have to be all around and be able to play in all situations.

What I'm saying is that if you have the right weapons on offense, you have the option to use it effectively. But on defense, even if you have the right weapons for the right job, you don't have the options to use them effectively, it's a guessing job most of the time. I'd love to see some enhancement to the DAI where we can put in the right people for the right job.

Something like this would be very helpful: If RB is in the game, use ROLB, if RB1 is in the game, use ROLB1, if RB2 is in the game, use ROLB2. This would be a good start. An further enhancement would be to have the option to adjust defense play calling based on offensive personnel in the game, of course this would be a bit more complicated and might take a little longer to implement.
Edited by datongw on Jul 21, 2009 03:14:46
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

The biggest exploit is certain people being able to test stuff out on a secret test server and then use that info for their teams



Not this one again. Where is it happening? PM me the proof.

Thanks.



PM me proof that it hasn't been happening. It was only disclosed to us in the first place because someone was passing along info to their team. Otherwise, we still wouldn't know.

 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
[
Having 4 different builds of LBs sounds logical, but it simply doesn't work in GLB. A run stopping LB would get killed in the passing game by receiving TEs and scat backs. Due to this guessing game, our LBs pretty much have to be all around and be able to play in all situations.


Here is the the thing. We aren't winning now on the defensive side of the ball. I'm sure you've notice the same thing I have when it comes to 3 and outs. The more you get them, and the better your offense does, your defense plays better the whole game. So the problem has to be rolling the dice vs playing back. If you back your LB up, and contain the line, you won't give up game breakers, but you'll also give up 1rst down after 1rst down, which will destroy your defense over the course of the game.

So if you are saying, I believe they will be 60% likely to run this play in this situation, and you know you can stop it, roll the dice. You aren't going to hold good teams to 0 points anyway. The more times you make them punt, the better chance you have of winning. If you have different sets of personnel to stop different builds, scouting should tell you who to start. Put the best builds on the field for the play you think they are most likely to run. Play the odds, and hope your offense holds up their end of the bargain.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Tony Dungy


The biggest exploit is certain people being able to test stuff out on a secret test server and then use that info for their teams



Not this one again. Where is it happening? PM me the proof.

Thanks.



PM me proof that it hasn't been happening. It was only disclosed to us in the first place because someone was passing along info to their team. Otherwise, we still wouldn't know.



That isn't how it works. You can't make unfounded accusations like that. At least put together a case for it or you will look like an idiot.
Edited by Darkus Black on Jul 21, 2009 03:29:00 (Didn't need the spare ?. Made ME look like an idiot.)
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Tony Dungy



The biggest exploit is certain people being able to test stuff out on a secret test server and then use that info for their teams



Not this one again. Where is it happening? PM me the proof.

Thanks.



PM me proof that it hasn't been happening. It was only disclosed to us in the first place because someone was passing along info to their team. Otherwise, we still wouldn't know.



That isn't how it works? You can't make unfounded accusations like that. At least put together a case for it or you will look like an idiot.


no tinfoil hat arguments please, there are dots to consider
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Tony Dungy



The biggest exploit is certain people being able to test stuff out on a secret test server and then use that info for their teams



Not this one again. Where is it happening? PM me the proof.

Thanks.



PM me proof that it hasn't been happening. It was only disclosed to us in the first place because someone was passing along info to their team. Otherwise, we still wouldn't know.



That isn't how it works. You can't make unfounded accusations like that. At least put together a case for it or you will look like an idiot.


You do realize who you are talking to right? He makes idiots look smart.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by datongw

[
Having 4 different builds of LBs sounds logical, but it simply doesn't work in GLB. A run stopping LB would get killed in the passing game by receiving TEs and scat backs. Due to this guessing game, our LBs pretty much have to be all around and be able to play in all situations.


Here is the the thing. We aren't winning now on the defensive side of the ball. I'm sure you've notice the same thing I have when it comes to 3 and outs. The more you get them, and the better your offense does, your defense plays better the whole game. So the problem has to be rolling the dice vs playing back. If you back your LB up, and contain the line, you won't give up game breakers, but you'll also give up 1rst down after 1rst down, which will destroy your defense over the course of the game.

So if you are saying, I believe they will be 60% likely to run this play in this situation, and you know you can stop it, roll the dice. You aren't going to hold good teams to 0 points anyway. The more times you make them punt, the better chance you have of winning. If you have different sets of personnel to stop different builds, scouting should tell you who to start. Put the best builds on the field for the play you think they are most likely to run. Play the odds, and hope your offense holds up their end of the bargain.


I really have no problem with this game having random factors, afterall everything is determined by dice rolls. I spend a lot of time into scouting and that definitely helps, we do have one of the better defenses in the game. But as a DC, I'd just like to see the playing field get even a little.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
You do realize who you are talking to right? He makes idiots look smart.


And he makes smart asses look like idiots.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw

If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


I'll play devils advocate on this one. If this change was made the point would be moot because every rushing QB in the game would be forced into retirement. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player. To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's.

I do think the defensive reactions leave a lot to be desired when the QB is rushing and should be improved, but I don't think forcing a lot of players into retirement due to a change in the sim is the answer. Also I get the realism argument, but lets be fair it's not like the offense can call audibles either, and there are tons of exploitive plays being created with the DPC that offenses would be able to destroy if they could adjust to them.
Edited by Saris on Jul 21, 2009 03:50:12
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Tony Dungy


The biggest exploit is certain people being able to test stuff out on a secret test server and then use that info for their teams



Not this one again. Where is it happening? PM me the proof.

Thanks.



PM me proof that it hasn't been happening. It was only disclosed to us in the first place because someone was passing along info to their team. Otherwise, we still wouldn't know.



that is not how we found out about it and from what I have heard, majority of the testers don't even use it anymore, the only one using it with any sort of regularity is R8 and he doesn't own a team, although he does provide me inside info so my teams can kick ass (j/k)
 
Link
 
The Top 6 Exploits in the game right now:

6.) QB running plays - defense is stunned for too long
5.) RDE secret to getting sacks (D AI alignment and build needed)
4.) HB Screens - completion % is way too high and yards per play way too high - basically a run with no D-line in way
3.) Secret HB build to get Head Fake working at a dominant level (the main 2 attributes needed)
2.) Scripts to compile data - huge time saving advantage for those who know how to use them
1.) Testers who tested every build, play, and alignment under the sun and learned #6 thru #3 faster than everyone else and will probably learn the next exploits faster than us.

Without these exploits, we would have tons of close 20-17 type of games and everyone would have a RNG chance every game and every season. However, the only exciting plays are the long QB runs, the RDE sacks, the long HB screen TDs, and the long HB runs after a Head Fake. Exciting plays need to be more random and not always happening to the same players who find out the exploits in the current sim first. By the time most people figure out the exploit, it is no longer working.

Meh. I'm not complaining, I'm just giving the current state of the game.

I would have used all 6 exploits as much as possible if I could. I have been using #6 and #4 alot, but I didn't find out #3 and #5 around week 12 or 13 (after our season was over and after we had boosted those positions).

If I had #1 or #2, then maybe I wouldn't think they would be that helpful, but from the outside looking in, they seem to be huge advantages that 99% of the agents will never have.


Edited by Tony Dungy on Jul 21, 2009 04:17:09
Edited by Tony Dungy on Jul 21, 2009 03:49:55
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw


I really have no problem with this game having random factors, afterall everything is determined by dice rolls. I spend a lot of time into scouting and that definitely helps, we do have one of the better defenses in the game. But as a DC, I'd just like to see the playing field get even a little.


Honestly, being a DC has been the best part of this game for me. I have won some games, and blown some games too learning it. But watching the plays you just made in the DPC work is a cool feeling. Even when I give up a long gain, I see where my guys were, and think about how I can get them in better position. I like having to consider what to cover and what to pray doesn't get called. I think while offense does have builds worked out better, they aren't better at game planning. They select a pitch right, and don't set up the absolute counter to it in the percentages. I think DC's see which play they fear more than the OC's do.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.