User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 14 Minor Leagues > Lv 14 Minor League #9 > Showdown for the Eastern Conference
Page:
 
haleykrl DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by egobruiser
Originally posted by cometsline_74

im not accusing anyone of anything im just saying it does look a little suspicious and you guys cant say it doesnt...but regaurdless hopefully we meet up in the playoffs and may the best team win!


I don't think it looks suspicious. Unless he sabotaged your AIs, there really isn't much he can do to change game outcomes at this level. He more than likely cannot tell me anything I couldn't easily figure out by watching film or even checking your player lolbars. If I was some mastermind and underhanded, I would have waited until the playoffs to gain information, wouldn't you think? If he was sharing information, I just screwed myself because I couldn't get the stuff I needed later to win in the playoffs in theory. This game really didn't decide anything except home field, which in GLB is basically just monetary.

Either way, might as well drop it and move on. League has been pretty fun so far, let's finish off these last few games and enjoy ourselves. Hopefully if nothing else, we all learned something from all of this and it helps us all to have fun in the future.


Agreed,

When this was brought to my attention I didn't think much of it b/c it does happen, and has happened to my team before. But the only difference was the agent said something about it early in the season. When I checked in this morning I had noticed the agent was now a GM, being unable to get in touch with the agent we took him off the depth chart and altered some AI's just in case.

I personally do not like benching players and hurting development, but I stand by the decision as the right move. This whole drama could have been avoided w/ a simple pm on Day 1 stating the issue at hand.

We will look for a better matchup in the playoffs, best of luck on your journey.

small rant, say no to the trophy whores, it diminishes the value of them for those who actually earn them
 
LFCJDB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cometsline_74
im not accusing anyone of anything im just saying it does look a little suspicious and you guys cant say it doesnt...but regaurdless hopefully we meet up in the playoffs and may the best team win!


I can say it doesn't look suspicious. Christ I had a guy on my team a couple years ago that was the DC of another team in our league and it didn't matter. I never suspected him of anything and if he was doing something underhanded then shame on him. A good owner offers an entire team GM status for the chance at a trophy, something a lot of owners do by the way, and suddenly I'm a cheater. The damage is already done, you guys cost Peterson experience points as well as significantly weakened your team in some sort of attempt to protect your team and punish me. I really don't get it, and since there isn't anymore game experience the rest of the way you can leave him on the bench. The way you guys handled this was bush league.
 
LFCJDB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by haleykrl
Originally posted by egobruiser

Originally posted by cometsline_74


im not accusing anyone of anything im just saying it does look a little suspicious and you guys cant say it doesnt...but regaurdless hopefully we meet up in the playoffs and may the best team win!


I don't think it looks suspicious. Unless he sabotaged your AIs, there really isn't much he can do to change game outcomes at this level. He more than likely cannot tell me anything I couldn't easily figure out by watching film or even checking your player lolbars. If I was some mastermind and underhanded, I would have waited until the playoffs to gain information, wouldn't you think? If he was sharing information, I just screwed myself because I couldn't get the stuff I needed later to win in the playoffs in theory. This game really didn't decide anything except home field, which in GLB is basically just monetary.

Either way, might as well drop it and move on. League has been pretty fun so far, let's finish off these last few games and enjoy ourselves. Hopefully if nothing else, we all learned something from all of this and it helps us all to have fun in the future.


Agreed,

When this was brought to my attention I didn't think much of it b/c it does happen, and has happened to my team before. But the only difference was the agent said something about it early in the season. When I checked in this morning I had noticed the agent was now a GM, being unable to get in touch with the agent we took him off the depth chart and altered some AI's just in case.

I personally do not like benching players and hurting development, but I stand by the decision as the right move. This whole drama could have been avoided w/ a simple pm on Day 1 stating the issue at hand.

We will look for a better matchup in the playoffs, best of luck on your journey.

small rant, say no to the trophy whores, it diminishes the value of them for those who actually earn them


There was no issue. I accepted his honorary offer yesterday, and I didn't see any confilct of interest being as I have absolutely no say in either teams gameplanning. Nothing about my role changed. The first time I heard of any problem was a PM I received while the game was already in progress. You guys totally overreacted and you could have avoided this with a PM when you first noticed this.

Nobody asked him to offer GM spots, he just offered. Nobody asks me for them either, I offer them. I think it's a nice thing to do for agents who spend time and flex building quality players. I don't think of them as trophy whores at all. Without quality agents then owners and GMs don't have anything to gameplan with.

 
haleykrl DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDBrick
A good owner offers an entire team GM status for the chance at a trophy,


disagree
 
LFCJDB
offline
Link
 
It's a players league. Guys spend a lot of flex making a great player. Why shouldn't they get a reward for their time. Now that there are designations between the GM jobs it makes even more sense to me. You can be the greatest gameplanner ever, but without well build players you won't win a championship. Good agents are just as important as good GMs.

Edit: The quote makes it sound as if all good owners offer spots, I meant that in this situation "a good owner" referring to Egobruiser specifically. Owners can do whatever they want, but I don't see any shame in recognizing agents as an important part of the team. I don't think the agents that accept my offers are trophy whores.
Edited by JDBrick on Jul 21, 2009 16:03:34
 
haleykrl DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDBrick

I didn't see any conflict of interest


srsly,

Originally posted by JDBrick

You guys totally overreacted and you could have avoided this with a PM when you first noticed this.

this was noticed the day before the game, but was no big deal as at the time it was just a player on both sides, which happens. But when we checked in this morning a little more than an hour before the game we noticed you were now a GM. A decision was made and we stand behind it.

And like I said, this could have been avoided Day 1 with a PM from you stating the issue.

Originally posted by JDBrick

Nobody asks me for them either, I offer them. I think it's a nice thing to do for agents who spend time and flex building quality players. I don't think of them as trophy whores at all. Without quality agents then owners and GMs don't have anything to gameplan with.


Players build quality players to win games and earn player trophies. GM's gp against said quality builds to earn playoff spots and ultimately win the gold. Handing them out like skittles only cheapens the ones that were actually earned.

Edited by haleykrl on Jul 21, 2009 16:03:58
 
LFCJDB
offline
Link
 
If I thought that there was going to be a problem then I would have PMd one of you. I didn't think anything of it being as I was doing nothing wrong as far as sharing info and what not. You guys are only ultimately hurting yourselves, so you can justify all you want but I will still feel you handled it poorly. To each his own. Leave him on the bench please.

As far as the conflict of interest goes, yeah I am serious. The situation wasn't any different than it was when I just had a player on each team. I have no responsibilities. I also don't care if I get a trophy. I have my own. I accepted because it was a gracious offer and it would have been rude not to. I already told the owner that if it made him feel better I would remove the GM banner. After reading your comments on the situation I think I'll keep it. Cheapens the trophy, are you serious. This is a computer game, not the NFL.

What exactly did you gain by benching your best HB?
Edited by JDBrick on Jul 21, 2009 16:12:58
 
tremele
offline
Link
 
This has gotten out of hand more than it should have. First off this was no excuse or attempt to discredit Rivendell's success this season. They are a great team and I have much respect for them as I always have. I'll keep an eye out on them, they know how to build a successful team.

What happened is a thread was created a few days ago and an agent pointed out that we have a player that is also on Rivendell's team. We all agreed it was just a coincidence and a mistake. Then all of a sudden he was a GM on there team right before the game. If that didn't look fishy to any owner I don't know what does. I sent him a PM right before I took him off the depth chart then we did some major adjustments to the AI since our game plans could have been in jeopardy.

To the people who said why didn't you ask first. Well we didn't have enough time and what do you think someone would say if you accused them of it. Even if they were trying to steal information about a team its not like they would give up and put there hands in the air and say you caught me. If you could get someone to do that then you should be a judge.

I just took the safe approach, I assumed it wasn't a big deal but you know what they say when you assume something.

I'm sure it was just a terrible coincidence but I guess it's just better to be safe than sorry.

Hopefully we can meet Rivendell in the playoffs and give them our best as I'm sure that is all they want in the first place. Anyways congratulations to Rivendell on the game and their season. Best of luck to you the rest of the way.

 
LFCJDB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tremele
This has gotten out of hand more than it should have. First off this was no excuse or attempt to discredit Rivendell's success this season. They are a great team and I have much respect for them as I always have. I'll keep an eye out on them, they know how to build a successful team.

What happened is a thread was created a few days ago and an agent pointed out that we have a player that is also on Rivendell's team. We all agreed it was just a coincidence and a mistake. Then all of a sudden he was a GM on there team right before the game. If that didn't look fishy to any owner I don't know what does. I sent him a PM right before I took him off the depth chart then we did some major adjustments to the AI since our game plans could have been in jeopardy.

To the people who said why didn't you ask first. Well we didn't have enough time and what do you think someone would say if you accused them of it. Even if they were trying to steal information about a team its not like they would give up and put there hands in the air and say you caught me. If you could get someone to do that then you should be a judge.

I just took the safe approach, I assumed it wasn't a big deal but you know what they say when you assume something.

I'm sure it was just a terrible coincidence but I guess it's just better to be safe than sorry.

Hopefully we can meet Rivendell in the playoffs and give them our best as I'm sure that is all they want in the first place. Anyways congratulations to Rivendell on the game and their season. Best of luck to you the rest of the way.



I wish I would have noticed that thread, but from your comments it seems it wouldn't have mattered. You say you wish I would have explained earlier, but then you say that you wouldn't be able to trust what I was telling you. Its a capped 13 league, espionage isn't going to get you very far. Builds and depth are going to carry you. Consider me punished.
 
haleykrl DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDBrick
You guys are only ultimately hurting yourselves,


Nope, didn't hurt us at all, we were in second and we are still in second, I see no loss whatsoever.

Originally posted by JDBrick

The situation wasn't any different than it was when I just had a player on each team.


hmm, really, no difference at all, can you say no change and then say "when I just had" in the same sentence. Aren't you referring to a change

Originally posted by JDBrick
I have no responsibilities.


ahh I see, well I would have logged into your account to verify that, but I don't know your password. Unless you know a magical way.

Originally posted by JDBrick
I have my own.


ya, but did you earn them, you have already admitted you agree with getting them for free

Originally posted by JDBrick
I accepted because it was a gracious offer and it would have been rude not to.


not rude, I have rejected many offers, but I can understand that some can only earn them one way.

Originally posted by JDBrick
Cheapens the trophy, are you serious. This is a computer game, not the NFL.


who said anything about the NFL, not me, see some owners like to look at a resume before hiring a coach. And when a noob has cheep trophies and claims they earned them only hurts the hiring team.
 
LFCJDB
offline
Link
 
Then the hiring team should be more careful when they interview. Yes, I earned them. I just don't think that they are the end all and be all of GLB. It's a game and it should be fun for everyone.
Edited by JDBrick on Jul 21, 2009 16:48:35
 
haleykrl DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDBrick
Then the hiring team should be more careful when they interview. Yes, I earned them. I just don't think that they are the end all and be all of GLB. It's a game and it should be fun for everyone.


but this isn't a kindergarten playground, not everyone gets a cookie,

imo, it should be earned, and I am sure if you did a pole of GLB Team owners and GM's they would agree
 
LFCJDB
offline
Link
 
I guess I don't think it's weird because the owners I know the best all do it. I have never thought it was a big deal, and that wouldn't change if that was the minority opinion. Out of curiosity this year I ran the exact same offense on two teams with similar rosters. The difference being one roster had better builds than the other. Not ridiculously better mind you, but better. Otherwise they each had rushing QBs and a similar HB tandem etc... Not surprisingly the team with the better builds is about to go undefeated while the other didn't even make the playoffs although their levels were pretty much the same. Builds are important, and agents who do a good job building are an important part of a winning team. I don't have any problem sharing success with them. Anyone who has had to any amount of recruiting knows how hard it is to get well built players and quality agents who don't spend all their time whining on the forum. My guys are important to me and want them to stick around and feel appreciated. Difference of opinion I guess.
Edited by JDBrick on Jul 21, 2009 17:33:09
Edited by JDBrick on Jul 21, 2009 17:31:05
 
NJB
offline
Link
 
Bunch of babies
 
egobruiser
offline
Link
 
I don't value trophies much. They make my home page load slower If Bort removed them tonight, I wouldn't care much.

I use named trophies (DC, co-owner, etc) to my GMs who did the work that required being more than a player owner. I use the generic (or honorary as it is called) to reward the player owners for staying active, contributing to the forums, and properly training and adjusting settings. Bort adjusted the trophies for that purpose, so I feel no guilt about using them as intended. It's probably the least I can do to show some appreciation for making my job as an owner easier. Anyone can sign with a team and either do absolutely nothing or everything possible to annoy teammates, but player owners who help out when possible is harder to find.

The guys who have a chance at generic trophies probably deserve them more than I do. I transferred two sets of offense AIs from another team, made slight adjustments to them early in the season. Rest of the season, I just swapped them out depending on opponents. Only other things I did was just adjusted ticket prices, adjusted EQ funds, and reaped the benefits. I pretty much got to coast all year because I had some great player owners. I feel like a CEO of Microsoft just collecting my check

I don't think there is a right or wrong way of doing trophies, just people have different opinions.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.