User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Darkus Black GTFITT (Contains Watchmen spoilers)
Page:
 
Link
 
Watch the movie again. Sometimes watching it more than once helps you understand things
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarcusAurelius
the blue penis represents fate.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ace♠
What I don't understand is how the guy's journal has the info about Adrian and his scheme if he was killed by Manhattan before he could make a log of it?


The fuck you talking about. Manhattan is the one who wrote the journal. Manhattan was schizophrenic; Rorscharch was just an aspect of his personality that he was forced to "kill off." Fight Club was actually based loosely on this book.
 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarcusAurelius
Originally posted by Ace♠

What I don't understand is how the guy's journal has the info about Adrian and his scheme if he was killed by Manhattan before he could make a log of it?


The fuck you talking about. Manhattan is the one who wrote the journal. Manhattan was schizophrenic; Rorscharch was just an aspect of his personality that he was forced to "kill off." Fight Club was actually based loosely on this book.


Now I feel stupid for making such a literal interpretation
 
Link
 
Originally posted by UncookedBacon22
Watch the movie again. Sometimes watching it more than once helps you understand things


 
Ace
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thom Yorke
You dolt, he was taking the journal as the events were happening and he dropped it off at the Newspaper right before he left for Antarctica

That's why he would start monologues with "Rorschach's Journal"


So the kid with smiley face was reading it correct?

Since he droppd it off before going to Antarctica then the part about Manhattan not actually causing the destruction would be missing. So how would the kid who is reading Rorschach's journal come across that forgotten part of the story and relay that information to us the audience?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Thom Yorke
Originally posted by MarcusAurelius

Originally posted by Ace♠


What I don't understand is how the guy's journal has the info about Adrian and his scheme if he was killed by Manhattan before he could make a log of it?


The fuck you talking about. Manhattan is the one who wrote the journal. Manhattan was schizophrenic; Rorscharch was just an aspect of his personality that he was forced to "kill off." Fight Club was actually based loosely on this book.


Now I feel stupid for making such a literal interpretation


The whole movie is just this one crazy guy's delusion. He had two personalities - one of them was this all-powerful god dude (at least he THOUGHT he was all-powerful), and the other one was this nutcase homeless guy. And the tragedy is that one of them killed the other. You are supposed to figure this out. Re-watch the movie, and watch how these two characters interact with each other - it's actually pretty powerful stuff once you realize what's going on behind the scense.
 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ace♠
Originally posted by Thom Yorke

You dolt, he was taking the journal as the events were happening and he dropped it off at the Newspaper right before he left for Antarctica

That's why he would start monologues with "Rorschach's Journal"


So the kid with smiley face was reading it correct?

Since he droppd it off before going to Antarctica then the part about Manhattan not actually causing the destruction would be missing. So how would the kid who is reading Rorschach's journal come across that forgotten part of the story and relay that information to us the audience?


In the book Veidt sends a horrible alien to blow up New York, movie is non-canon

Fuck you
 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarcusAurelius
Originally posted by Thom Yorke

Originally posted by MarcusAurelius


Originally posted by Ace♠



What I don't understand is how the guy's journal has the info about Adrian and his scheme if he was killed by Manhattan before he could make a log of it?


The fuck you talking about. Manhattan is the one who wrote the journal. Manhattan was schizophrenic; Rorscharch was just an aspect of his personality that he was forced to "kill off." Fight Club was actually based loosely on this book.


Now I feel stupid for making such a literal interpretation


The whole movie is just this one crazy guy's delusion. He had two personalities - one of them was this all-powerful god dude (at least he THOUGHT he was all-powerful), and the other one was this nutcase homeless guy. And the tragedy is that one of them killed the other. You are supposed to figure this out. Re-watch the movie, and watch how these two characters interact with each other - it's actually pretty powerful stuff once you realize what's going on behind the scense.


You had me until you misspelled scenes

This is a pretty interesting interpretation. It has some merit imo.
 
Ace
Moderator
offline
Link
 
dammit Thom.
 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
Read the book motherfucker

 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
I'm such an elitist prick
 
Ace
Moderator
offline
Link
 
So who is the one crazy delusional guy?
 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
Dr. Manhattan
 
Ace
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Do you mean Jon before he became Dr.Manhattan or are you speculating again?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.