User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #2 > Coach/Coordinator of the year?
Page:
 
GotMilk
offline
Link
 
I understand your point of view. What I meant is that the Sharks came from a lower league and they made another great season. That's why I nominated my owner even if Brisbane staff did an awesome job. Good luck for your game
 
Mr Mojo Risin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Dave - its fine to be a homer, but there is being a homer and just being rude.

There are plenty of GM's and Owners that have done a hell of a job with their teams and say that it is "unanimous" that Wes gets the nod for Coach of the Year is beyond ridiculous.

And that is no offense to Wes, he has my vote. But even Wes himself has brought up some other teams that had great years for different reasons (i.e. Pelicans with a great D despite an O that couldn't keep drives going like the Heat could).

You ask for your SS to be nominated to the Pro Bowl despite having lesser stats than others, because he wasn't on the field for as many plays. Yet shouldn't that also mean that a defense that could survive more plays and still be solid get a nomination as well? Can't have your cake and eat it too.


Hey I'm sorry if I'm being a little biased. In no way does that make me a "homer" lol

But seriously, yes some other teams did well, but the amount of dominance we displayed all season just can't be passed up and the reason for that is because of Wes and his great planning and settings. We have great players but if it wasn't for him we wouldn't have did what we did this season that's all I'm saying. He made myself and many other players look great and I'm simply showing my appreciation, that's all.

I'm not trying to offend the others like my good buddy Scace here is making it seem
 
turkishkamel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr Mojo Risin
Originally posted by SCACE

Dave - its fine to be a homer, but there is being a homer and just being rude.

There are plenty of GM's and Owners that have done a hell of a job with their teams and say that it is "unanimous" that Wes gets the nod for Coach of the Year is beyond ridiculous.

And that is no offense to Wes, he has my vote. But even Wes himself has brought up some other teams that had great years for different reasons (i.e. Pelicans with a great D despite an O that couldn't keep drives going like the Heat could).

You ask for your SS to be nominated to the Pro Bowl despite having lesser stats than others, because he wasn't on the field for as many plays. Yet shouldn't that also mean that a defense that could survive more plays and still be solid get a nomination as well? Can't have your cake and eat it too.


Hey I'm sorry if I'm being a little biased. In no way does that make me a "homer" lol

But seriously, yes some other teams did well, but the amount of dominance we displayed all season just can't be passed up and the reason for that is because of Wes and his great planning and settings. We have great players but if it wasn't for him we wouldn't have did what we did this season that's all I'm saying. He made myself and many other players look great and I'm simply showing my appreciation, that's all.

I'm not trying to offend the others like my good buddy Scace here is making it seem


46 pts allowed all season is great, but wes makes a good counter point. the offense helps the D out a ton (#1 in points, #1 in yards). my vote is also for wes, but by the numbers the offense was just as dominant as the D. and both helped each other get there.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GotMilk
I understand your point of view. What I meant is that the Sharks came from a lower league and they made another great season. That's why I nominated my owner even if Brisbane staff did an awesome job. Good luck for your game


Until the leagues are balanced, where you came from (i.e. A being a "lower" league) doesn't really mean anything. There are tons of teams in this league alone that could easily compete with the PRO and AAA top squads.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr Mojo Risin
Originally posted by SCACE

Dave - its fine to be a homer, but there is being a homer and just being rude.

There are plenty of GM's and Owners that have done a hell of a job with their teams and say that it is "unanimous" that Wes gets the nod for Coach of the Year is beyond ridiculous.

And that is no offense to Wes, he has my vote. But even Wes himself has brought up some other teams that had great years for different reasons (i.e. Pelicans with a great D despite an O that couldn't keep drives going like the Heat could).

You ask for your SS to be nominated to the Pro Bowl despite having lesser stats than others, because he wasn't on the field for as many plays. Yet shouldn't that also mean that a defense that could survive more plays and still be solid get a nomination as well? Can't have your cake and eat it too.


Hey I'm sorry if I'm being a little biased. In no way does that make me a "homer" lol

But seriously, yes some other teams did well, but the amount of dominance we displayed all season just can't be passed up and the reason for that is because of Wes and his great planning and settings. We have great players but if it wasn't for him we wouldn't have did what we did this season that's all I'm saying. He made myself and many other players look great and I'm simply showing my appreciation, that's all.

I'm not trying to offend the others like my good buddy Scace here is making it seem


It was more the quote that Wes is the "unanimous" winner. My vote is in for him, but we aren't done voting yet and there are a lot of good cases made for other coaches.

That said, I did a comparison between Brisbane and Sydney last night, using points scored against and the number of defensive snaps.

It came out to 5 points per 100 snaps for Brisbane, 17 points per 100 snaps for Sydney. So even though their D was on the field more, which obviously has an energy drain effect and probably a field position effect, the points allowed per 100 snaps weren't even close.

Which is why you and I vote for Wes, but that doesn't mean he will win.
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
I think we're comparing apples and oranges here. Wes, no doubt, did a hell of a job as DC for Brisbane. But people, such as Mojo, are voting from an uninformed and biased stand point.

If a DC gets a vote for fewest points scored then wouldn't an OC get votes for most points scored? Even then, what if most points and most TD's aren't synonymous? Do we then give a vote to Special Teams Coach for the FG's _and_ OC for the TD's.

How about the actions as a GM, that people again such as Mojo (no I'm not picking on you, just using you as an example), don't ever see. The scouting that enables goose-eggs? The recruiting that builds depth? The holding together a team who were all once clueless noobs that signed CPU contracts? The managing to bring a brand new team in a very competative league to the finals? Where do those votes go?

Again, I'm not trying to take away from what Wes has done....he's done a remakable job of coordinating a defense. I'm just trying to remove the bias from some people's minds (such as mojo) and help them relize that 1 aspect of the game doesn't exist without the others. Does Wes get my vote as DC of the year? Hell yeah! Can I, in good faith, vote for him in such a general catagory as Owner/Coach of the year? No. I think we need to split this up between Owner, OC, and DC at the very least.

I haven't even touched on the "owner" portion yet. Actions not seen by the general public to be considered a "good owner" or perhaps the "best" would include:

PMing everyone who has gone inactive. Covering level 8/16/24/32 equipment out of one's own pocket. Giving out bonuses. Keeping on top of who is where and what they can be building better. Encouraging the team to communicate via the team forum. Soundly managing finances to not only keep everyone happy but also add stadium upgrades that will address future salary minimums. Having the wisdom to pick those Amazing GM's to begin with....the list goes on. Hell, I'll even throw a vote up for the guy who chose NOT to make Mojo a GM so his actions would only represent himself and not the team (just busting on ya )

Anyway, that being said, if we're going with 1 generic/general vote for the catagory, I'll mull it over. I'm thinking that if the Mustangs move on to round 3, Lutsy get my vote.
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CableJelly
I think we're comparing apples and oranges here. Wes, no doubt, did a hell of a job as DC for Brisbane. But people, such as Mojo, are voting from an uninformed and biased stand point.

If a DC gets a vote for fewest points scored then wouldn't an OC get votes for most points scored? Even then, what if most points and most TD's aren't synonymous? Do we then give a vote to Special Teams Coach for the FG's _and_ OC for the TD's.

How about the actions as a GM, that people again such as Mojo (no I'm not picking on you, just using you as an example), don't ever see. The scouting that enables goose-eggs? The recruiting that builds depth? The holding together a team who were all once clueless noobs that signed CPU contracts? The managing to bring a brand new team in a very competative league to the finals? Where do those votes go?

Again, I'm not trying to take away from what Wes has done....he's done a remakable job of coordinating a defense. I'm just trying to remove the bias from some people's minds (such as mojo) and help them relize that 1 aspect of the game doesn't exist without the others. Does Wes get my vote as DC of the year? Hell yeah! Can I, in good faith, vote for him in such a general catagory as Owner/Coach of the year? No. I think we need to split this up between Owner, OC, and DC at the very least.

I haven't even touched on the "owner" portion yet. Actions not seen by the general public to be considered a "good owner" or perhaps the "best" would include:

PMing everyone who has gone inactive. Covering level 8/16/24/32 equipment out of one's own pocket. Giving out bonuses. Keeping on top of who is where and what they can be building better. Encouraging the team to communicate via the team forum. Soundly managing finances to not only keep everyone happy but also add stadium upgrades that will address future salary minimums. Having the wisdom to pick those Amazing GM's to begin with....the list goes on. Hell, I'll even throw a vote up for the guy who chose NOT to make Mojo a GM so his actions would only represent himself and not the team (just busting on ya )

Anyway, that being said, if we're going with 1 generic/general vote for the catagory, I'll mull it over. I'm thinking that if the Mustangs move on to round 3, Lutsy get my vote.



Great post and I agree with the majority of this.

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CableJelly
I think we're comparing apples and oranges here. Wes, no doubt, did a hell of a job as DC for Brisbane. But people, such as Mojo, are voting from an uninformed and biased stand point.

If a DC gets a vote for fewest points scored then wouldn't an OC get votes for most points scored? Even then, what if most points and most TD's aren't synonymous? Do we then give a vote to Special Teams Coach for the FG's _and_ OC for the TD's.

How about the actions as a GM, that people again such as Mojo (no I'm not picking on you, just using you as an example), don't ever see. The scouting that enables goose-eggs? The recruiting that builds depth? The holding together a team who were all once clueless noobs that signed CPU contracts? The managing to bring a brand new team in a very competative league to the finals? Where do those votes go?

Again, I'm not trying to take away from what Wes has done....he's done a remakable job of coordinating a defense. I'm just trying to remove the bias from some people's minds (such as mojo) and help them relize that 1 aspect of the game doesn't exist without the others. Does Wes get my vote as DC of the year? Hell yeah! Can I, in good faith, vote for him in such a general catagory as Owner/Coach of the year? No. I think we need to split this up between Owner, OC, and DC at the very least.

I haven't even touched on the "owner" portion yet. Actions not seen by the general public to be considered a "good owner" or perhaps the "best" would include:

PMing everyone who has gone inactive. Covering level 8/16/24/32 equipment out of one's own pocket. Giving out bonuses. Keeping on top of who is where and what they can be building better. Encouraging the team to communicate via the team forum. Soundly managing finances to not only keep everyone happy but also add stadium upgrades that will address future salary minimums. Having the wisdom to pick those Amazing GM's to begin with....the list goes on. Hell, I'll even throw a vote up for the guy who chose NOT to make Mojo a GM so his actions would only represent himself and not the team (just busting on ya )

Anyway, that being said, if we're going with 1 generic/general vote for the catagory, I'll mull it over. I'm thinking that if the Mustangs move on to round 3, Lutsy get my vote.


well spoken.
 
HotA_Chaos
offline
Link
 
My vote goes to CableJelly, biased I am and have to be. I dont know any other Owners etc. All I can say 100% is this guy puts in so much time I doubt he knows the name of his kids or what his wife looks like.

I also dont know what the other Owners actually do.

Cable PMs all our guys. Keeps up to date on contracts, bonuses. He does everything an Owner should and has to do.

............... And he loves Master D !!
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HotA_Chaos
My vote goes to CableJelly, biased I am and have to be. I dont know any other Owners etc. All I can say 100% is this guy puts in so much time I doubt he knows the name of his kids or what his wife looks like.

I also dont know what the other Owners actually do.

Cable PMs all our guys. Keeps up to date on contracts, bonuses. He does everything an Owner should and has to do.

............... And he loves Master D !!


We're in the same (amazing) boat with our owner KingofVA, and with Wes manning the defense it has been a great season with many more to come! Tough to vote on an owner not knowing what goes on behind closed doors - coordinators much easier b/c you can watch film.
 
HotA_Chaos
offline
Link
 
CableJelly has done the OC/DC and Scouting jobs himself. I think up until maybe a week 2 weeks ago he has selected a few GMs.

................ And yes he really does love Master D !!!!
 
Mr Mojo Risin
offline
Link
 
I am not speaking from an uninformed and biased standpoint, I am speaking from a "truth" stand point.

Just wanted to clear things up.

Scace even then went as far as to back it up even more with his most recent research, so again it's not as "uninformed" as you like to think it is...
 
Mr Mojo Risin
offline
Link
 
And I don't recall ever trying to be a GM, I'm just trying to be the best SS I can be, and with stats and team records and what not I seem to be succeeding in my goal.

edit - I noticed you even mentioned offensive coordinators should get something too. That again should probably be King then. We scored a whole lot this season to go along with our dominant defense.

Now I didn't any quick math so if there was an offense better than Brisbane then by all means please post the info on this topic for me.


The way people around here have been acting towards me you'd swear it was Miami 1969. (Most won't get that of course )

"There's Morrison, always stirring up controversy. Always has to shake things up"

Last edited May 31, 2008 12:19:01
 
Polished Rock
offline
Link
 
Joe? is that you?
 
ptriley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HotA_Chaos
CableJelly has done the OC/DC and Scouting jobs himself. I think up until maybe a week 2 weeks ago he has selected a few GMs.

................ And yes he really does love Master D !!!!



Cablejelly for president!!!!!!HIP HIP HOORAHHH!!!! HIP HIP HOORAHHHH!!!!!!

And HotA_Chaos has Master D envy!!!!!!!

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.