User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Is This Play Broken?
Page:
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Flirting with Cheerleaders.. oh man.. you are so right on that!!!!

I've also looked through a lot of replays and I have not found another one with 5 WR to compare it with. If someone else finds one post a link.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
I think I found the exact same play. My team was 5 wide and ran the same route with 5 WR's. Same man open and step by step shows the same 'D' coverage on the play.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=641740
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Okay now it happened to me too

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=699675

Yes maybe it is broken ;D
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Yet another reason I want to make my own playbook. Other than when playing a team with one of the few running QBs out there, there's virtually no reason for a QB spy like that. That LB could at least play a short/medium middle zone and still keep the QB from running very far (and if he does run, MAKE HIM PAY ).
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=700162

And again
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
I think it's a little bit of both (play call and broken play).

The coverage looks like Cover 2 Man, which means the safety help is over the top in deep 1/2's, while the underneath coverage plays man. Since there are 5 eligible receivers, each underneath defender is assigned to one of them. Against 5 wide, the LB needs to bump over and cover the slot receiver. If you are going to run this against 5 wide, your DE's have better have contain as their first responsibility, because as it was stated, the QB will have big yards if he escapes the pocket.

I can't imagine why the LB would be a spy in this defense, especially against a 5 wide set. That's why I think it's a broken play. If you are in man coverage (which this was for all the underneath defenders), you can't let one guy run free, which against this set means you can't have one guy spying the QB. Either the LB needs to bump over to cover the slot (and a safety has to become the spy, thus negating the 2 deep safety help) or you have to give the QB the opportunity to run if he can break contain. That's why I mentioned the DE's responsibility earlier.

My $0.02.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Originally posted by TrevJo

I saw that play too, same result. The above guy says it's cover-2, which is maybe true, but it looks to me like they are planing man with the SS assigned to the WR who does the out route. (In a true cover 2 zone, the CB should stay down with the WR who does the out route.) If it's man to man, the SS needs to play up tighter. Not sure if that is a problem with the way defense is programmed, or maybe the SS needs to adjust tactics to play tighter man to man.


Not correct, in a cover 2 the safties are in the "umbrellas" to give support over top, he is right where he should be.

http://www.footballtimes.org/Article.asp?ID=167

There are some illustrations for the Tampa-2, the pictures are for max cover of course, but its clear that if you went to man and the (2) was still there where the safties would be, overtop right where they are at.


I know what Cover-2 and Tampa-2 are. As far as where the players line up, I agree it looks like it could be either Cover-2 or Tampa-2. But if you look at the way the players (especially the SS) react to the routes once the inside WR breaks to the outside, that is not how either a Cover-2 or Tampa-2 defense should react. The deep safety should never be the one to come up on the short outside route in a Cover-2 or Tampa-2 defense.

In terms of the alignment, I agree that it looks like Cover-2 (or Tampa-2), or Cover-2-Man. But in terms of the assignments, it's obviously none of those. In terms of the assignments, it look like a Cover-1-Man, with the FS in a deep zone and the LB in a medium zone (or spy assignment), and the CBs and SS in man coverage. (with bad alignment for the SS)
Last edited Apr 4, 2008 13:26:53
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
The play is "broken" because the SS isnt coming up to the line to cover the slot receiver. Only way to stop that type of quick out pass is to have the defensive back play "bump and run" the wide out.

The SS needs to be in man coverage.
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I know what Cover-2 and Tampa-2 are. As far as where the players line up, I agree it looks like it could be either Cover-2 or Tampa-2. But if you look at the way the players (especially the SS) react to the routes once the inside WR breaks to the outside, that is not how either a Cover-2 or Tampa-2 defense should react. The deep safety should never be the one to come up on the short outside route in a Cover-2 or Tampa-2 defense.

In terms of the alignment, I agree that it looks like Cover-2 (or Tampa-2), or Cover-2-Man. But in terms of the assignments, it's obviously none of those. In terms of the assignments, it look like a Cover-1-Man, with the FS in a deep zone and the LB in a medium zone (or spy assignment), and the CBs and SS in man coverage. (with bad alignment for the SS)


I'm not so sure that he's actually covering the short route as much as he is widening to cover his half. If you watch the other safety, they both start to gain width at about the same time; it just happens to be at the exact same time that the WR makes his break to the out.

I agree with your second paragraph...it looks like Cover 2, then post-snap like Cover 2 Man, but the assignments are all wrong. The way that the FS slides to the twin WR side tells me it's cover 2, but the underneath coverage is very much screwed up.

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
The safeties are playing deep zone; the SS isn't going to come up and take the curling WR unless, as one of the examples shows, you're so deep in opponent territory that the curl ends up in the zone and he recognizes it.

One of the two corners on that side should stop and stay with the curled WR, because he has safety help for the two go routes and it's better to have 3 one-on-one coverages than a 2-on-3 with a wide open 9 yard dumpoff. He's not, and since the LB is QB spying and the SS is Cover 2 zoning, there's nobody anywhere near that receiver.
 
Liquidlex
offline
Link
 
There are plenty of things that the defense should do.

What concerns me is that the defense NEVER does them. They never call a different play, the covereage is never different, the players reaction is never different. The underneath WR is always open. 9 yards for free every single time the offense calls that play.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Now, if my team would just run that play every down...
 
God_of_NOPE!!
offline
Link
 
I just realized, thats my team on defense! wow. I should have been in there.
 
SKRONK_King
offline
Link
 
The SS is supposed the have that WR covered but when the receiver makes his cut and the SS runs after him he gets caught up between the WR and CB. A clasic pick and roll.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Yes, but as discussed earlier no one picked up on the free WR. In ever instance that I have seen so far the 5 WR, the inside WR is always running an out and is always open. The FS and SS zone over the top, the LB is doing a middle zone/qb spy. It's definantly a bug until someone shows us a 5WR play that is stopped (other then a dropped pass, which I haven't seen that yet either).

I would also be interested in a 5WR play where the inside WR on the out pattern is NOT passed the ball and the QB sends it someplace else.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.