User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A BETTER fix to Head Fake and Juke
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

HBs certainly are capable of beating 3-4 defenders, but that's usually by cutting back against the grain while the defenders overpursue.


This. And I wouldn't even call that a 'Juke' moreso than just good field vision.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
This. And I wouldn't even call that a 'Juke' moreso than just good field vision.

Yeah, and I have seen Super Elusive HBs do things like this from time to time without the defenders blinking like Christmas trees, so I don't think the change will affect it.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by jrry32

And how exactly would it not solve it? Unless all 3-4 players are standing directly in front of the runner, he wouldn't fake them. That's the key to angles. If you have him boxed him, he'll only juke the guys in front of him.

Because most of those defenders would be in the proposed cone, unless you wanted it extremely small. I'm talking about replays we've seen where the HB is approaching the line of scrimmage and there are 1-2 defenders straight ahead, one ahead and slightly to the left, and another slightly ahead and to the right.


Originally posted by kdalton

I've seen real life players Juke 3-4 defenders at a time.

Really? I watch a lot of football and I can't recall seeing that. In fact, it seems like true "jukes" only happen when a defender is slowing and "breaking down" to engage the ball carrier, then the RB feints in one direction before moving off in the other. HBs certainly are capable of beating 3-4 defenders, but that's usually by cutting back against the grain while the defenders overpursue.


To the 2nd part, watch Gale Sayers, Marshall Faulk, Barry Sanders, Jim Brown, etc. those guys will fake 2-3 defenders if they are in the right spot usually with a stutter step, spin, juke or a head fake leading to a cut back as for the first part, the cone wouldn't be huge and this would actually add some realism to a juke or head fake because he wouldn't be able to beat all those guys, Bort would have to find a way to implement so you are faking in a certain direction so if he fakes left, the guy on the left and middle might buy it but the guy on the right will make the tackle and vice versa, basically, straight ahead will be the easiest to get faked and as you move further to each side, it gets less and less of a chance until you are at an angle behind where the RB is and there would be no way to fake out guys in all directions, at most you could fake a guy out on your left and in the middle or on your right and in the middle.
 
Ccf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by kdalton

I've seen real life players Juke 3-4 defenders at a time.

The key is to make sure the HBcanonly Juke defenders that are in front of him. i've always thought it seemed odd to see the blinking light when a defender is chasing from behind....Where else might he run? It isn't like the defender will think a left turn might happen.

Just change the code so a defender must be between the ballcarrier and the endzone.


Yep or in a certain angle to the ballcarrier. It would be hard to code but it's needed.


 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
To the 2nd part, watch Gale Sayers, Marshall Faulk, Barry Sanders, Jim Brown, etc. those guys will fake 2-3 defenders if they are in the right spot usually with a stutter step, spin, juke or a head fake

Jim Brown was a power runner, not someone who would juke defenders. And even the others wouldn't fake more than 2 defenders at a time. Watch this highlight reel featuring some of Barry Sanders' best runs: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysjr0IspY_M Almost all of the jukes are him beating a defender one on one, with only a couple being two and none being more than two.
 
WiL@ES21
offline
Link
 
+1

I don't think only one defender to be faked per tick is a good idea.

I would suggest only defenders within certain distance with the runners could be faked, say 5 yards.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by jrry32

To the 2nd part, watch Gale Sayers, Marshall Faulk, Barry Sanders, Jim Brown, etc. those guys will fake 2-3 defenders if they are in the right spot usually with a stutter step, spin, juke or a head fake

Jim Brown was a power runner, not someone who would juke defenders. And even the others wouldn't fake more than 2 defenders at a time. Watch this highlight reel featuring some of Barry Sanders' best runs: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysjr0IspY_M Almost all of the jukes are him beating a defender one on one, with only a couple being two and none being more than two.


Jdbolick don't go off of what you hear, Jim Brown was a balanced RB much like Adrian Peterson, if you watch him, he made plenty of guys miss as well as running guys over. And Barry Sanders, Faulk and Sayers did have multiple highlights of them making 2-3 guys miss at one time, they didn't do it every play but if my idea was implemented, they wouldn't do that every play because you'll rarely have 2 guys coming at you from directly in front of you. I can show you one of

Marshall's where he juked two guys:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dulM2B7yp5I
at 2:40

Gale Sayers did it more than a few times:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0DTIuT4Hfs&feature=related
at: 0:40 to 0:58

Like I said Jim Brown could do it all:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6cCXNBeVfc
EDIT: If you don't want to watch the entire video start at 2:55.

Although there is one thing I think should be implemented which is HBs should have to slow down to fake and if they are juking multiple guys, they should have to slow way down.
Edited by jrry32 on Jul 4, 2009 12:04:43
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
From the very beginning all true anti-juke agents have been for is:

1) anti-Juke VAs

2) slow down ball carrier for multiple jukes

3) allow for pinning the ball carrier to sideline and no juking defenders behind ball carrier....

How this gets turned into a nerf I just don't understand....



Edited by CinTex on Jul 4, 2009 12:10:36
 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
Jim Brown was definitely more of a power runner. It's just that there are very few rushers out there that you could say were strictly power or strictly elusive backs.

Almost all of even the greatest ones had to use a combination of some sort; it's just that Brown used more power moves than elusive ones.

As for changing this, you would have to be careful, as it would likely lead to no more halfbacks spending points in the Elusive Rushing Special Ability Tree.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Jdbolick don't go off of what you hear, Jim Brown was a balanced RB much like Adrian Peterson

No, he wasn't. I've mentioned this to you before, but I get paid to write about football. I watch more games in a few years than most people will in a lifetime, and I'm very familiar with the NFL's history. Jim Brown would fit GLB's definition of a power back. He was a strong runner with incredible balance who would routinely gain yards after contact, and while he did have above average straight line speed, he was not the type of runner who would juke or change directions easily. Your own youtube link backs that up, because you can see Brown repeatedly running to contact, not trying to juke away from it.

Originally posted by
Marshall's where he juked two guys:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dulM2B7yp5I
at 2:40

Gale Sayers did it more than a few times:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0DTIuT4Hfs&feature=related
at: 0:40 to 0:58

Notice that your own links are backing up what I've said. Even the great elusive runners were usually juking one defender at a time, and neither of us have come up with a single example of them ever juking three defenders at once. This actually backs up Bort's "fix" as a realistic scenario.
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Guys; enough with the argument over whether certain NFL players were power backs or not. Keep the discussion about finding a better fix for Jukes and Head Fakes.
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Bort's fix, to be frank, is not a good sounding one as there are times when a head fake or juke should make multiple guys miss. But something that needs to be fixed is the angle at which a head fake or juke effects a guy and I think that would be a better fix to this problem. A guy chasing a player down will NEVER fall for a head fake so that happening in GLB is screwed up. I think if Bort made it so that certain guys are certain angles to the ballcarrier didn't fall for the fake, it would be better. That way, the ballcarrier could still make 2 guys in front of him miss(like some can) but if a guy was on one side and another is in front, he wouldn't make the guy on the side miss or if a guy is trying to run him down from behind, he wouldn't make that guy stumble. It seems like this would fix multiple problems, thus killing 2 birds with 1 stone instead of just making a bad and unrealistic fix.


I agree; Bort's fix seems very much wrong.

"Oh, there's a problem? Here's a band-aid." -Bort

C'mon, already! Can we actually fix things properly? For once?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by jrry32

Jdbolick don't go off of what you hear, Jim Brown was a balanced RB much like Adrian Peterson

No, he wasn't. I've mentioned this to you before, but I get paid to write about football. I watch more games in a few years than most people will in a lifetime, and I'm very familiar with the NFL's history. Jim Brown would fit GLB's definition of a power back. He was a strong runner with incredible balance who would routinely gain yards after contact, and while he did have above average straight line speed, he was not the type of runner who would juke or change directions easily. Your own youtube link backs that up, because you can see Brown repeatedly running to contact, not trying to juke away from it.

Originally posted by

Marshall's where he juked two guys:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dulM2B7yp5I
at 2:40

Gale Sayers did it more than a few times:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0DTIuT4Hfs&feature=related
at: 0:40 to 0:58

Notice that your own links are backing up what I've said. Even the great elusive runners were usually juking one defender at a time, and neither of us have come up with a single example of them ever juking three defenders at once. This actually backs up Bort's "fix" as a realistic scenario.


Whatever jdbolick, I see a Power runner differently then you do. And you aren't even making a point in the 2nd part, OF COURSE THE MAJORITY OF THE TIME THEY ARE JUKING ONE ON ONE. But my point was that those guys could make multiple guys at once miss and they did. So don't try to say or act like people juking multiple defenders never happens IRL. I don't even know what you're arguing.

Are you arguing that Bort's change is better than mine? If so, you have done little to prove your point. I think you are just arguing for the sake of arguing.

Edited by jrry32 on Jul 4, 2009 13:37:30
 
Roctronic
offline
Link
 
Lets see how his change works out first.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Guys; enough with the argument over whether certain NFL players were power backs or not. Keep the discussion about finding a better fix for Jukes and Head Fakes.

Last time I checked, you weren't a suggestions mod. Go find a hobby.



Originally posted by jrry32
Whatever jdbolick, I see a Power runner differently then you do.

And apparently the rest of the world, given that Jim Brown is generally described as the greatest power runner of all-time.

Originally posted by
But my point was that those guys could make multiple guys at once miss and they did. So don't try to say or act like people juking multiple defenders never happens IRL. I don't even know what you're arguing.

You couldn't find one single example in the highlight runs of the NFL's greatest elusive backs in history where they juked more than two defenders at one time, and there were only a few examples where they even juked two at once. Therefore Bort's solution is realistic by NFL standards, if you care about such things.

Originally posted by
Are you arguing that Bort's change is better than mine? If so, you have done little to prove your point. I think you are just arguing for the sake of arguing.

I pointed out that the one juke per tick is much more realistic than your infinite jukes as long as the defender is within a certain vision cone. I pointed out that there have been instances where multiple defenders in front of a ball carrier blinked like christmas trees, frozen in place until the HB got past them. I also pointed out that implementing a vision cone would be a major coding challenge that would require very significant changes to the programming.

Look, you're obviously getting defensive because I'm poking giant holes in your suggestion, but get over it. Bort's solution is realistic and reasonable. If it doesn't work out, then you can come back later and explain why, along with what you would prefer to see. Until then, this is a bad suggestion.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.