User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.


That's ridiculous. Certanly not realistic for a K.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
This is a good example of how important stamina is for a K.

I was always told it wasn't that important yet I realize now that I miss most of my shots in the 4th quarter...

 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.


Yeah, because it's hard to gain back energy from sitting on the bench the entire game. A kicker plays in what, 5 or 6 plays the whole game? His energy is only used to kick as he is hardly ever involved in the contact of the play. A kicker's energy should never go below 95.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 13:37:28
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by Bort


Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.


Yeah, because it's hard to gain back energy from sitting on the bench the entire game. A kicker plays in what, 5 or 6 plays the whole game? His energy is only used to kick as he is hardly ever involved in the contact of the play. A kicker's energy should never go below 95.


I've had my energy go down to 76 one game (where there were tons of kickoffs and FG's)...and my K averages 8.8 plays per game this season...so 5-6 is wrong. Can also be involved in tackling, although that doesn't happen too often.
 
k2skier
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Faux Bear
bad AI.

To make things worse, 95% of short punts seem to go for a touchback, so it's not like there was much of a chance to pin them back inside their own 5. You pushed them back a whopping 3.5 yards.

really lame.

and it doesn't matter that he's not automatic at that distance. Even if he was a 25% FG kicker at that range, you go for the kick.


most of the punters aren't there yet in terms of skills to pin someone in...
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by lawdog

Originally posted by Bort



Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.


Yeah, because it's hard to gain back energy from sitting on the bench the entire game. A kicker plays in what, 5 or 6 plays the whole game? His energy is only used to kick as he is hardly ever involved in the contact of the play. A kicker's energy should never go below 95.


I've had my energy go down to 76 one game (where there were tons of kickoffs and FG's)...and my K averages 8.8 plays per game this season...so 5-6 is wrong. Can also be involved in tackling, although that doesn't happen too often.


I had my kicker go to 61 in a game
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by Firenze

Originally posted by lawdog


Originally posted by Bort




Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.


Yeah, because it's hard to gain back energy from sitting on the bench the entire game. A kicker plays in what, 5 or 6 plays the whole game? His energy is only used to kick as he is hardly ever involved in the contact of the play. A kicker's energy should never go below 95.


I've had my energy go down to 76 one game (where there were tons of kickoffs and FG's)...and my K averages 8.8 plays per game this season...so 5-6 is wrong. Can also be involved in tackling, although that doesn't happen too often.


I had my kicker go to 61 in a game


Heh, i'm not surprised...you've gone for an interesting build with Laurana.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by Firenze


Originally posted by lawdog



Originally posted by Bort





Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.


Yeah, because it's hard to gain back energy from sitting on the bench the entire game. A kicker plays in what, 5 or 6 plays the whole game? His energy is only used to kick as he is hardly ever involved in the contact of the play. A kicker's energy should never go below 95.


I've had my energy go down to 76 one game (where there were tons of kickoffs and FG's)...and my K averages 8.8 plays per game this season...so 5-6 is wrong. Can also be involved in tackling, although that doesn't happen too often.


I had my kicker go to 61 in a game


Heh, i'm not surprised...you've gone for an interesting build with Laurana.


It was actually Legolas who went down to 61
Laurana's lowest was about 67
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by Bort



Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.


That's ridiculous. Certanly not realistic for a K.


I've hit 70% twice and am usually in the high 70s after a game
 
4th Quarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
My initial assumption was that your kicker probably sucks, but I checked... level 17. Would've been a 40.5-yard field goal though... not exactly a chip shot.

Your kicker is 18-for-25 from 40+ yards this year.

Probably should've at least attempted the FG, but 18/25 ain't exactly automatic.


It doesnt matter if the kicker sucks or not. I'd take a 25% chance at 3 points over what will most likely be 10-15 yards of field position.


The AI on 4th down just hasnt been polished yet. Often you'll punt when you should clearly go for it. In our playoff game we were up by 1 point with 2 minutes left on our opponents 35 and had a 4th & 0.5 yards to go. Instead of going for it we punted. The punt yielded 15 yards of field position. Making the 4th and 0.5 yds would have won the game because the other team was out of TOs. Clear choice, but the AI just isnt there yet.

I've got faith though. It'll come.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 14:57:29
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 4th Quarter
Originally posted by Novus

My initial assumption was that your kicker probably sucks, but I checked... level 17. Would've been a 40.5-yard field goal though... not exactly a chip shot.

Your kicker is 18-for-25 from 40+ yards this year.

Probably should've at least attempted the FG, but 18/25 ain't exactly automatic.


It doesnt matter if the kicker sucks or not. I'd take a 25% chance at 3 points over what will most likely be 10-15 yards of field position.


The AI on 4th down just hasnt been polished yet. Often you'll punt when you should clearly go for it. In our playoff game we were up by 1 point with 2 minutes left on our opponents 35 and had a 4th & 0.5 yards to go. Instead of going for it we punted. The punt yielded 15 yards of field position. Making the 4th and 0.5 yds would have won the game because the other team was out of TOs. Clear choice, but the AI just isnt there yet.

I've got faith though. It'll come.


In that scenario you mentioned the CPU did the right thing. You can always look back in hindsight after the punt and then say whether it was good or bad, but you should hope your punter can pin them down around the goalline. With so little time left it makes alot of sense to punt from the 35, which is too far for a fieldgoal to have a realistic chance to go in (for any kicker) and also would give the other team great field position to drive down and score if you neglected to get a first down.
 
Mordred
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VikesRule
In that scenario you mentioned the CPU did the right thing. You can always look back in hindsight after the punt and then say whether it was good or bad, but you should hope your punter can pin them down around the goalline. With so little time left it makes alot of sense to punt from the 35, which is too far for a fieldgoal to have a realistic chance to go in (for any kicker) and also would give the other team great field position to drive down and score if you neglected to get a first down.
You think your odds of winning are better when you have 1st and 10 at the 50 (assuming they went 3 and out) with 1 minute left as opposed to 4th and inches from the 35? You'd have to be crazy to punt and hope your defense could get the ball back in decent field position with that little time left.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.