I like the ideas. Having coaches adds a whole new level to the game. Definitely worth looking into and developing some more, because I think this could be a neat aspect to the game.
Forum > Suggestions > GLB Evolution - Decline, Coaching, etc
tremele
offline
offline
Flaws:
1. Most players have 4 to 5 players on average. Currently I'm guessing there is 50,000 players on this site. So essentially in 8 or 9 seasons you'll have 10k coaches, there is going to be some unemployment issues, lol. So lets say this game keep generating at the same rate. Ever year you will have 5k coaches. You'll be in the same situation now when a lot of people who join in a few seasons from now have no shot at being a coach.
2. The die hards here will love this idea, because they'll put their coaches on their new players for probably the same team so they can gain quicker.
3. I like Borts original idea of after 10 seasons or so retire the player and get 70% back and build back up again. This will accommodate all new players that join in on the game. Besides I'm hoping to own a team and don't want to have get an oc just because they have high attributes and don't have a clue how to game plan against a team. Basically this plan would hurt my team (in the future that is) since I hired a knowledgeable coach instead of one that just had a good player and doesn't know crap about how to run an offense.
1. Most players have 4 to 5 players on average. Currently I'm guessing there is 50,000 players on this site. So essentially in 8 or 9 seasons you'll have 10k coaches, there is going to be some unemployment issues, lol. So lets say this game keep generating at the same rate. Ever year you will have 5k coaches. You'll be in the same situation now when a lot of people who join in a few seasons from now have no shot at being a coach.
2. The die hards here will love this idea, because they'll put their coaches on their new players for probably the same team so they can gain quicker.
3. I like Borts original idea of after 10 seasons or so retire the player and get 70% back and build back up again. This will accommodate all new players that join in on the game. Besides I'm hoping to own a team and don't want to have get an oc just because they have high attributes and don't have a clue how to game plan against a team. Basically this plan would hurt my team (in the future that is) since I hired a knowledgeable coach instead of one that just had a good player and doesn't know crap about how to run an offense.
whotookmybowtie
offline
offline
Originally posted by tremele
Flaws:
1. Most players have 4 to 5 players on average. Currently I'm guessing there is 50,000 players on this site. So essentially in 8 or 9 seasons you'll have 10k coaches, there is going to be some unemployment issues, lol. So lets say this game keep generating at the same rate. Ever year you will have 5k coaches. You'll be in the same situation now when a lot of people who join in a few seasons from now have no shot at being a coach.
2. The die hards here will love this idea, because they'll put their coaches on their new players for probably the same team so they can gain quicker.
3. I like Borts original idea of after 10 seasons or so retire the player and get 70% back and build back up again. This will accommodate all new players that join in on the game. Besides I'm hoping to own a team and don't want to have get an oc just because they have high attributes and don't have a clue how to game plan against a team. Basically this plan would hurt my team (in the future that is) since I hired a knowledgeable coach instead of one that just had a good player and doesn't know crap about how to run an offense.
Not everyone will want to be a coach, especially if they can't get their FP back. I have four players, and I know I'd only want to make 1-2 coaches so that I could use the refund from my other guys to create a few more players to re-start the process with.
Flaws:
1. Most players have 4 to 5 players on average. Currently I'm guessing there is 50,000 players on this site. So essentially in 8 or 9 seasons you'll have 10k coaches, there is going to be some unemployment issues, lol. So lets say this game keep generating at the same rate. Ever year you will have 5k coaches. You'll be in the same situation now when a lot of people who join in a few seasons from now have no shot at being a coach.
2. The die hards here will love this idea, because they'll put their coaches on their new players for probably the same team so they can gain quicker.
3. I like Borts original idea of after 10 seasons or so retire the player and get 70% back and build back up again. This will accommodate all new players that join in on the game. Besides I'm hoping to own a team and don't want to have get an oc just because they have high attributes and don't have a clue how to game plan against a team. Basically this plan would hurt my team (in the future that is) since I hired a knowledgeable coach instead of one that just had a good player and doesn't know crap about how to run an offense.
Not everyone will want to be a coach, especially if they can't get their FP back. I have four players, and I know I'd only want to make 1-2 coaches so that I could use the refund from my other guys to create a few more players to re-start the process with.
GG
offline
offline
There isnt really a flaw tho.
Because in my proposal, you always have the choice to do one of four things...
1. fully retire your player and his name and receive a 70% refund.
2. retire your player to the HOF where his name is reserved and receive, say, a 50% refund.
3. choose to play on with your player for x amount of seasons.
4. evolve your character into a coach.
The choice means there isnt a flaw.
Because in my proposal, you always have the choice to do one of four things...
1. fully retire your player and his name and receive a 70% refund.
2. retire your player to the HOF where his name is reserved and receive, say, a 50% refund.
3. choose to play on with your player for x amount of seasons.
4. evolve your character into a coach.
The choice means there isnt a flaw.
Krunchy
offline
offline
Dumb idea. 20 seasons???? That means for the next two years the Pro leagues will be locked down by season one players.
And who needs 50,000 coaches. This game is about PLAYING football, not coaching it.
And who needs 50,000 coaches. This game is about PLAYING football, not coaching it.
HSKRCHMPS
offline
offline
Originally posted by Krunchy
Dumb idea. 20 seasons???? That means for the next two years the Pro leagues will be locked down by season one players.
And who needs 50,000 coaches. This game is about PLAYING football, not coaching it.
You don't ever seem to bring anything to these conversations other than your rants and bitching! I would agree with you Krunch that 20 seasons is a little excessive, but all in all, it is a terrific idea. I would say that the majority of NFL players are in the league, on average, 10-12 years. Why not retire your player into the HOF and let him pursue a coaching career? It just adds that much more reality to the game. Isn't that what this is about?
The fact that we are gameplanning and such would tell me that this game covers both aspects, being as how we are team owners and such.
Dumb idea. 20 seasons???? That means for the next two years the Pro leagues will be locked down by season one players.
And who needs 50,000 coaches. This game is about PLAYING football, not coaching it.
You don't ever seem to bring anything to these conversations other than your rants and bitching! I would agree with you Krunch that 20 seasons is a little excessive, but all in all, it is a terrific idea. I would say that the majority of NFL players are in the league, on average, 10-12 years. Why not retire your player into the HOF and let him pursue a coaching career? It just adds that much more reality to the game. Isn't that what this is about?
The fact that we are gameplanning and such would tell me that this game covers both aspects, being as how we are team owners and such.
Krunchy
offline
offline
Originally posted by HSKRCHMPS
You don't ever seem to bring anything to these conversations other than your rants and bitching!
I think you should re-read my post, and my other posts. Take this one for example:
Originally posted by Krunchy
Dumb idea. 20 seasons???? That means for the next two years the Pro leagues will be locked down by season one players.
And who needs 50,000 coaches. This game is about PLAYING football, not coaching it.
I very clearly gave 2 good reasons why this is a bad idea. That's constructive my friend, and to say that I don't bring anything constructive to these boards is a downright lie.
You don't ever seem to bring anything to these conversations other than your rants and bitching!
I think you should re-read my post, and my other posts. Take this one for example:
Originally posted by Krunchy
Dumb idea. 20 seasons???? That means for the next two years the Pro leagues will be locked down by season one players.
And who needs 50,000 coaches. This game is about PLAYING football, not coaching it.
I very clearly gave 2 good reasons why this is a bad idea. That's constructive my friend, and to say that I don't bring anything constructive to these boards is a downright lie.
HSKRCHMPS
offline
offline
Krunchy, maybe you should not be so harsh with your criticism then. I agreed with you that 20 is too high. I also gave a strong and valid reason why this is a good idea. I have read a ton of your posts. Maybe it's the fact that your wording seems somewhat harsh regarding certain suggestions, so for that, I apologize.
Last edited May 28, 2008 09:23:17
Cedo
offline
offline
Nothing here appeal me neither the admin. 12 month of play is enough. I don't see the point of debating always and always the same things...
naraic
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I like it...I have thought of trying to introduce a "coach" class into the game at some point, somehow based on existing or retiring players.
If you could basically "re-class" your player into a Lv1 coach and level him up over time to give bonuses to training, morale/chemistry bonuses, etc, it would be cool. The coach's initial stats could even be based on the player's career length and quality.
May I suggest a charge when converting to be a coach there be a flex charge to prevent everyone doing it.
Also may I suggest that for every year playing the coach will get an extra 2SP and for every season over certain benchmarks in terms of performance they get an extra SP in coaching a relevant skill.
Each team should have a playbook which can be get a bonus from a good coach and a starting coach should start off giving bonuses to the plays that he had in a playbook when playing for over x years
I like it...I have thought of trying to introduce a "coach" class into the game at some point, somehow based on existing or retiring players.
If you could basically "re-class" your player into a Lv1 coach and level him up over time to give bonuses to training, morale/chemistry bonuses, etc, it would be cool. The coach's initial stats could even be based on the player's career length and quality.
May I suggest a charge when converting to be a coach there be a flex charge to prevent everyone doing it.
Also may I suggest that for every year playing the coach will get an extra 2SP and for every season over certain benchmarks in terms of performance they get an extra SP in coaching a relevant skill.
Each team should have a playbook which can be get a bonus from a good coach and a starting coach should start off giving bonuses to the plays that he had in a playbook when playing for over x years
Jed
offline
offline
Forget the length of time for a moment, I've seen this idea before (turning players into coaches) and would love to see it implemented.
IamJack
offline
offline
I love the idea GG. Bort, this would keep users interested and on the site for much longer.
Cybershot
offline
offline
Originally posted by GG
There isnt really a flaw tho.
Because in my proposal, you always have the choice to do one of four things...
1. fully retire your player and his name and receive a 70% refund.
2. retire your player to the HOF where his name is reserved and receive, say, a 50% refund.
3. choose to play on with your player for x amount of seasons.
4. evolve your character into a coach.
The choice means there isnt a flaw.
Love the general idea, but there is a problem with 20 seasons. Too long for newbies to wait to be at the "top".
There isnt really a flaw tho.
Because in my proposal, you always have the choice to do one of four things...
1. fully retire your player and his name and receive a 70% refund.
2. retire your player to the HOF where his name is reserved and receive, say, a 50% refund.
3. choose to play on with your player for x amount of seasons.
4. evolve your character into a coach.
The choice means there isnt a flaw.
Love the general idea, but there is a problem with 20 seasons. Too long for newbies to wait to be at the "top".
SAGA45
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I like it...I have thought of trying to introduce a "coach" class into the game at some point, somehow based on existing or retiring players.
If you could basically "re-class" your player into a Lv1 coach and level him up over time to give bonuses to training, morale/chemistry bonuses, etc, it would be cool. The coach's initial stats could even be based on the player's career length and quality.
Why not just add a coach class now or allow for the 're-classing' of current Gm's to 'coach' status with coach options, training, and special abilities?
I like it...I have thought of trying to introduce a "coach" class into the game at some point, somehow based on existing or retiring players.
If you could basically "re-class" your player into a Lv1 coach and level him up over time to give bonuses to training, morale/chemistry bonuses, etc, it would be cool. The coach's initial stats could even be based on the player's career length and quality.
Why not just add a coach class now or allow for the 're-classing' of current Gm's to 'coach' status with coach options, training, and special abilities?
Dan4GS
offline
offline
Some great ideas GG. Some ideas that came to mind while reading:
--Why make the players play all twenty years before becoming a coach? I think it should be an option at any point. If a player decides to become a coach before lvl 20, then they could start out as as a (current level/3) coach. Thus, a lvl three player retiring would be a lvl one coach, a level 6 guy retiring would be a lvl 2 coach, and a lvl 18 guy retiring would be a lvl 6 coach. Lvl 20's going into retirement could come in as lvl 7 coaches.
--Because of this, you would have to allow coaches to be created just like players, except you come into the league at level one and boosting would have to be restricted, and experienced earned more slowly.
--Why do this at all? If you make people wait twenty seasons before becoming a coach, then the few teams that do get to hire coaches will have a big advantage. If you're going to open up a new facet to the game, allow all teams to have coaches...just none that have really good ones right now.
Just a few thoughts, hope it helps.
--Why make the players play all twenty years before becoming a coach? I think it should be an option at any point. If a player decides to become a coach before lvl 20, then they could start out as as a (current level/3) coach. Thus, a lvl three player retiring would be a lvl one coach, a level 6 guy retiring would be a lvl 2 coach, and a lvl 18 guy retiring would be a lvl 6 coach. Lvl 20's going into retirement could come in as lvl 7 coaches.
--Because of this, you would have to allow coaches to be created just like players, except you come into the league at level one and boosting would have to be restricted, and experienced earned more slowly.
--Why do this at all? If you make people wait twenty seasons before becoming a coach, then the few teams that do get to hire coaches will have a big advantage. If you're going to open up a new facet to the game, allow all teams to have coaches...just none that have really good ones right now.
Just a few thoughts, hope it helps.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























