User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cubsluver22
kiss the .gif
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jonw9
Originally posted by cubsluver22

If you had a good offense, you wouldn't need a kicker to do anything but kick extra points. You just don't get it do you man??



Wait! Hold on! Time out!

It sounds like you are saying the kicker's job is to kick!

That is the kind of useful information that should be in the wiki!

Thanks for the tip!

Found it, it was just buried: http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Football_position


You have to have an offense to do anything to be able to utilize a kicker.
 
dcboardr41
offline
Link
 
glad to see one loss makes us dead, good stuff
 
mtbowers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jonw9
Originally posted by cubsluver22

If you had a good offense, you wouldn't need a kicker to do anything but kick extra points. You just don't get it do you man??



Wait! Hold on! Time out!

It sounds like you are saying the kicker's job is to kick!

That is the kind of useful information that should be in the wiki!

Thanks for the tip!

Found it, it was just buried: http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Football_position


Kicker (K) — Handles kickoffs and field goal attempts, and in some leagues, punts as well.


i didnt know that
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cubsluver22

Lmao Kicker?? If you had a good offense, you wouldn't need a kicker to do anything but kick extra points. You just don't get it do you man??


Kicker is the most obvious player since that's the one position where the scouting bar does equal build quality. So when reviewing how good a team is at building you compare kickers.

But I guess reading the forums is too difficult for you...
 
FahQ
offline
Link
 
Kickers are a dime a dozen in my opinion, matta. If you can keep up your stamina high enough to connect on 10+ extra points per game without shanking any, then I'm happy.

I understand that this kicker is your only player in the league, and it is cute that you feel the need to justify that fact and defend yourself. I respect that, but honestly I doubt anybody really gives a shit about your gold bar kicker. Hence the mockery.

No hard feelings. Just being honest with you.
 
CTX
offline
Link
 
SO basically matta, when you say you compare kickers to see how good a team is, you think that if a team has a good kicker they must be good because only good kickers are on good teams. So if I were to have a team of level 1's but have a really badass kicker that team would be good?
Edited by CTX on Jun 24, 2009 09:25:30
 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CTX
SO basically matta, when you say you compare kickers to see how good a team is, you think that if a team has a good kicker they must be good because only good kickers are on good teams. So if I were to have a team of level 1's but have a really badass kicker that team would be good?


Well, they couldn't be any worse!
 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
And like Jesus, the Army has risen from the dead!

Happy Easter everybody!
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CTX
SO basically matta, when you say you compare kickers to see how good a team is, you think that if a team has a good kicker they must be good because only good kickers are on good teams. So if I were to have a team of level 1's but have a really badass kicker that team would be good?


No. You use a kicker's bar to determine how good a builder the team / owner is.

For example, a Lvl 32 kicker with a 69 bar is a horrible build. Why would an owner have a kicker with such a bad build on his team? Probably because the owner doesn't understand how builds work and thinks the kicker is actually an OK build. So what does this tell you? That the owner sucks. QED

 
Rennis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by CTX

SO basically matta, when you say you compare kickers to see how good a team is, you think that if a team has a good kicker they must be good because only good kickers are on good teams. So if I were to have a team of level 1's but have a really badass kicker that team would be good?


No. You use a kicker's bar to determine how good a builder the team / owner is.

For example, a Lvl 32 kicker with a 69 bar is a horrible build. Why would an owner have a kicker with such a bad build on his team? Probably because the owner doesn't understand how builds work and thinks the kicker is actually an OK build. So what does this tell you? That the owner sucks. QED



Strange that you would equate knowing how to build a good kicker to knowing how good a team is. Along with punter, the easiest player to build is a kicker. It does not take a genius to build a kicker. If all else fails and you have to blindly place some SPs I bet you can put them in kicking and be okay. Seriously though congrats on your kicker and kudos on the great build but evaluating a team on the kickers build is kinda out there.

It is almost like evaluating a team on the punters build. Weird thing about that is your Level 32 punter has a 69 green bar. WEIRD.

Matta you a Braves fan ? If so then I take it all back he is right about everything. No way a fellow Braves fan is wrong.
Edited by Rennis on Jun 24, 2009 13:23:06
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rennis


Strange that you would equate knowing how to build a good kicker to knowing how good a team is. Along with punter, the easiest player to build is a kicker. It does not take a genius to build a kicker. If all else fails and you have to blindly place some SPs I bet you can put them in kicking and be okay. Seriously though congrats on your kicker and kudos on the great build but evaluating a team on the kickers build is kinda out there.

It is almost like evaluating a team on the punters build. Weird thing about that is your Level 32 punter has a 69 green bar. WEIRD.


Exactly. So if you're an owner that grabs a bad kicker, you know it's a bad owner.

Punters are a little different since STR doesn't factor into the punting formula but is still very important for a good punter. If you still have concerns, look at our Punter's yards/punt. It's first in the league.
 
Rennis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by Rennis



Strange that you would equate knowing how to build a good kicker to knowing how good a team is. Along with punter, the easiest player to build is a kicker. It does not take a genius to build a kicker. If all else fails and you have to blindly place some SPs I bet you can put them in kicking and be okay. Seriously though congrats on your kicker and kudos on the great build but evaluating a team on the kickers build is kinda out there.

It is almost like evaluating a team on the punters build. Weird thing about that is your Level 32 punter has a 69 green bar. WEIRD.


Exactly. So if you're an owner that grabs a bad kicker, you know it's a bad owner.

Punters are a little different since STR doesn't factor into the punting formula but is still very important for a good punter. If you still have concerns, look at our Punter's yards/punt. It's first in the league.


If I still have concerns hehe now that is funny. I am going to do myself a favor and never mention kicker or punter again in these forums, since they have been talked about way too much as it is. Here's to hoping you have the best kicker in the league, could be an MVP in it for you. Just like the last kicker that won an MVP...umm what's his name ?
 
mtbowers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rennis
Originally posted by matta

Originally posted by Rennis




Strange that you would equate knowing how to build a good kicker to knowing how good a team is. Along with punter, the easiest player to build is a kicker. It does not take a genius to build a kicker. If all else fails and you have to blindly place some SPs I bet you can put them in kicking and be okay. Seriously though congrats on your kicker and kudos on the great build but evaluating a team on the kickers build is kinda out there.

It is almost like evaluating a team on the punters build. Weird thing about that is your Level 32 punter has a 69 green bar. WEIRD.


Exactly. So if you're an owner that grabs a bad kicker, you know it's a bad owner.

Punters are a little different since STR doesn't factor into the punting formula but is still very important for a good punter. If you still have concerns, look at our Punter's yards/punt. It's first in the league.


If I still have concerns hehe now that is funny. I am going to do myself a favor and never mention kicker or punter again in these forums, since they have been talked about way too much as it is. Here's to hoping you have the best kicker in the league, could be an MVP in it for you. Just like the last kicker that won an MVP...umm what's his name ?


let me google that.......
 
CTX
offline
Link
 
He was Mark Mosley (Washington Redskins baby) and he won it in 1982...but it was a strike year...think that this will be a strike year matta?
 
maristfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by CTX

SO basically matta, when you say you compare kickers to see how good a team is, you think that if a team has a good kicker they must be good because only good kickers are on good teams. So if I were to have a team of level 1's but have a really badass kicker that team would be good?


No. You use a kicker's bar to determine how good a builder the team / owner is.

For example, a Lvl 32 kicker with a 69 bar is a horrible build. Why would an owner have a kicker with such a bad build on his team? Probably because the owner doesn't understand how builds work and thinks the kicker is actually an OK build. So what does this tell you? That the owner sucks. QED



Never, ever, ever use the scouting bars to judge a player. Use the prior season's performance plus games to date to get a better read on what makes a good build.

For example:
I have a lvl 32 kicker, who combined last season and the games so far this season is 29 for 31 with 94% FGM, converting 155 of 161 XP's.

Your lvl 31 kicker is 23 for 30 in the same period with 77% FGM, only attempting(but nicely converting) 36 XP's.

Then I would look at distance of those missed FG's...my K has 1 missed from 40+ and 1 from 50+, your K has 1 missed from 30+, 3 from 40+ and 3 from 50+.

Even with your gold bar, and my kicker without a gold bar, it would be hard to say that your build is superior looking at those numbers.

Most other positions can be scouted the same way, by examining the statistics. It's a bit like Bill James' sabermetrics, determining value of a player based on performance over time and compared to similar players during the same timeframe.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.