Originally posted by whatspeakyou
Originally posted by MD
Originally posted by fergusonkw
Originally posted by Wenatchee1
Thanks for your efforts Rlott and MD...nice to be a part of an active forum!
I agree.
As much as I like where Rlott ranked us, I feel as though MD's rankings are a little more realistic for us
Mine were just based on builds and ratings, his were based on the first preseason game.
Were using the same script though, you can base it on a few different things and change the weight of certain things.
you can't really base it on builds because the only thing (other than open builds) that's indicative of a build is a scouting bar, and we all know how misleading those can be. Not to mention doing rankings that way doesn't take into account the quality of coordinators, etc. There's really no way to get a solid idea of rankings in a brand new league until the 3rd or 4th week of the regular season, unfortunately.
I agree completely. Generally by the 3rd or 4th week of the regular season Coordinators have there game plan and there depth chart set. The preseason and 1st two games and usually for your OC and DC to get a feel for their players and there is alot of movement in the depth chart. All though it is nice to see how we rank right now and get we feel on where we need to improve before the start of the season, the rankings really are not useful to us right now. This is just me, yall may disagree but I feel we should do the initial preseason rankings based on the previous season and toughness of the schedule and then update them regularly once the reg season starts. Trust me you will see alot of mvoement in those rankings.
Originally posted by MD
Originally posted by fergusonkw
Originally posted by Wenatchee1
Thanks for your efforts Rlott and MD...nice to be a part of an active forum!
I agree.
As much as I like where Rlott ranked us, I feel as though MD's rankings are a little more realistic for us
Mine were just based on builds and ratings, his were based on the first preseason game.
Were using the same script though, you can base it on a few different things and change the weight of certain things.
you can't really base it on builds because the only thing (other than open builds) that's indicative of a build is a scouting bar, and we all know how misleading those can be. Not to mention doing rankings that way doesn't take into account the quality of coordinators, etc. There's really no way to get a solid idea of rankings in a brand new league until the 3rd or 4th week of the regular season, unfortunately.
I agree completely. Generally by the 3rd or 4th week of the regular season Coordinators have there game plan and there depth chart set. The preseason and 1st two games and usually for your OC and DC to get a feel for their players and there is alot of movement in the depth chart. All though it is nice to see how we rank right now and get we feel on where we need to improve before the start of the season, the rankings really are not useful to us right now. This is just me, yall may disagree but I feel we should do the initial preseason rankings based on the previous season and toughness of the schedule and then update them regularly once the reg season starts. Trust me you will see alot of mvoement in those rankings.






























