Well more personal visits by Bort are required. There are teams all over the place seriously over the caps.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Is anything being done about the teams with players way over their cap?
Blamo
offline
offline
Well this team only had two players that needed to be cut... So I'm sure teams with much worse problems are also getting visits. Bort also said he'd just drop the players if it came to that.
cowcards
offline
offline
Originally posted by Blamo
Well this team only had two players that needed to be cut... So I'm sure teams with much worse problems are also getting visits. Bort also said he'd just drop the players if it came to that.
If he's going to do that he has to do it all the way. You can't pick and choose who you want to make cut players and who not to make. He needs to tell people that anyone more than 3 levels over the cap need to be cut or they will be removed.
Well this team only had two players that needed to be cut... So I'm sure teams with much worse problems are also getting visits. Bort also said he'd just drop the players if it came to that.
If he's going to do that he has to do it all the way. You can't pick and choose who you want to make cut players and who not to make. He needs to tell people that anyone more than 3 levels over the cap need to be cut or they will be removed.
jmsne
offline
offline
Originally posted by cowcards
Originally posted by Blamo
Well this team only had two players that needed to be cut... So I'm sure teams with much worse problems are also getting visits. Bort also said he'd just drop the players if it came to that.
If he's going to do that he has to do it all the way. You can't pick and choose who you want to make cut players and who not to make. He needs to tell people that anyone more than 3 levels over the cap need to be cut or they will be removed.
+1000
Originally posted by Blamo
Well this team only had two players that needed to be cut... So I'm sure teams with much worse problems are also getting visits. Bort also said he'd just drop the players if it came to that.
If he's going to do that he has to do it all the way. You can't pick and choose who you want to make cut players and who not to make. He needs to tell people that anyone more than 3 levels over the cap need to be cut or they will be removed.
+1000
recockulous
offline
offline
Funny, the team in our lvl-38 cap league has an avg level of 39. The top 25% of the roster has an avg level of 44. Somebody posted this roster summary:
>>>
after rollover, day 46
10 players above level 38
21 players at level 38
6 players at level 37
<<<
This is all BEFORE boosting. Here's the thread discussing it in the league forum: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2785071&page=1
IMHO, there should be another re-shuffle of the leagues to make sure people are where they're supposed to be assigned. either cut people over the cap, or enforce an avg based on the whole roster... but an avg 39-lvl team doesn't belong in a 38-cap league.
>>>
after rollover, day 46
10 players above level 38
21 players at level 38
6 players at level 37
<<<
This is all BEFORE boosting. Here's the thread discussing it in the league forum: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2785071&page=1
IMHO, there should be another re-shuffle of the leagues to make sure people are where they're supposed to be assigned. either cut people over the cap, or enforce an avg based on the whole roster... but an avg 39-lvl team doesn't belong in a 38-cap league.
MasterBlaster
offline
offline
Calling it a cap implies a hard maximum when what we really have is a changeable median. That makes it much easier for the power gamers to take advantage of the system. Why not make it a hard max with the following rules.
1. To reorg a team to a capped league, all players above the cap must be cut first.
2. You can only sign players at or below the cap unless they already play for your team.
The "already play for your team" is so losing teams aren't forced to cut their best players.
1. To reorg a team to a capped league, all players above the cap must be cut first.
2. You can only sign players at or below the cap unless they already play for your team.
The "already play for your team" is so losing teams aren't forced to cut their best players.
jmsne
offline
offline
Originally posted by MasterBlaster
Calling it a cap implies a hard maximum when what we really have is a changeable median. That makes it much easier for the power gamers to take advantage of the system. Why not make it a hard max with the following rules.
1. To reorg a team to a capped league, all players above the cap must be cut first.
2. You can only sign players at or below the cap unless they already play for your team.
The "already play for your team" is so losing teams aren't forced to cut their best players.
Get rid of number 2, teams got demoted on purpose to play against lower level teams. Teams requested caps well below where they should be playing to win easily... that shouldn't be allowed.
Calling it a cap implies a hard maximum when what we really have is a changeable median. That makes it much easier for the power gamers to take advantage of the system. Why not make it a hard max with the following rules.
1. To reorg a team to a capped league, all players above the cap must be cut first.
2. You can only sign players at or below the cap unless they already play for your team.
The "already play for your team" is so losing teams aren't forced to cut their best players.
Get rid of number 2, teams got demoted on purpose to play against lower level teams. Teams requested caps well below where they should be playing to win easily... that shouldn't be allowed.
merenoise
offline
offline
Originally posted by MasterBlaster
Calling it a cap implies a hard maximum when what we really have is a changeable median. That makes it much easier for the power gamers to take advantage of the system. Why not make it a hard max with the following rules.
1. To reorg a team to a capped league, all players above the cap must be cut first.
2. You can only sign players at or below the cap unless they already play for your team.
The "already play for your team" is so losing teams aren't forced to cut their best players.
The problem with this is that some teams are horrible game-planners with bad builds and even with those extra levels will not be competitive. While I fully support making the caps hard within a season or two teams with these people will relegate and when they do they will out level many of the teams in the league they get demoted to. So ultimately the league will be "pure" for 1 season at most. Should the leagues have been hard capped, imo yes. Will this fix the OPs initial complaint, no not really because these same teams will be moving down next season.
The good news is even with the level superiority most of these teams will continue to fail at taking down championships since they aren't skilled game planners. I was in a league last season where a team outleveled my team by 7 levels at nearly every position and 10+ at a few. Needless to say my underleveled team beat them handily and that team did not even host a playoff game although they did make the playoffs. Unfortunately I have a feeling that the OP is out of luck as I don't see all the teams who are over the median being corrected, but the good news is that you still have a fighting chance against these teams in many cases. Where it is most egregious is in the lowest of the minors, level 13, 16, 21 etc. When you are up against a level 38 HB in a capped 13 you will have some issues.
Calling it a cap implies a hard maximum when what we really have is a changeable median. That makes it much easier for the power gamers to take advantage of the system. Why not make it a hard max with the following rules.
1. To reorg a team to a capped league, all players above the cap must be cut first.
2. You can only sign players at or below the cap unless they already play for your team.
The "already play for your team" is so losing teams aren't forced to cut their best players.
The problem with this is that some teams are horrible game-planners with bad builds and even with those extra levels will not be competitive. While I fully support making the caps hard within a season or two teams with these people will relegate and when they do they will out level many of the teams in the league they get demoted to. So ultimately the league will be "pure" for 1 season at most. Should the leagues have been hard capped, imo yes. Will this fix the OPs initial complaint, no not really because these same teams will be moving down next season.
The good news is even with the level superiority most of these teams will continue to fail at taking down championships since they aren't skilled game planners. I was in a league last season where a team outleveled my team by 7 levels at nearly every position and 10+ at a few. Needless to say my underleveled team beat them handily and that team did not even host a playoff game although they did make the playoffs. Unfortunately I have a feeling that the OP is out of luck as I don't see all the teams who are over the median being corrected, but the good news is that you still have a fighting chance against these teams in many cases. Where it is most egregious is in the lowest of the minors, level 13, 16, 21 etc. When you are up against a level 38 HB in a capped 13 you will have some issues.
jmsne
offline
offline
Teams arent going to move down anymore, the bottom two teams stay put the teams from 9-14 go up one level and the teams that make the playoffs go up 2. If they suck at gameplanning or have bad builds they will stick around in the conference again.
Dub J
offline
offline
Originally posted by merenoise
The problem with this is that some teams are horrible game-planners with bad builds and even with those extra levels will not be competitive. While I fully support making the caps hard within a season or two teams with these people will relegate and when they do they will out level many of the teams in the league they get demoted to. So ultimately the league will be "pure" for 1 season at most. Should the leagues have been hard capped, imo yes. Will this fix the OPs initial complaint, no not really because these same teams will be moving down next season.
The good news is even with the level superiority most of these teams will continue to fail at taking down championships since they aren't skilled game planners. I was in a league last season where a team outleveled my team by 7 levels at nearly every position and 10+ at a few. Needless to say my underleveled team beat them handily and that team did not even host a playoff game although they did make the playoffs. Unfortunately I have a feeling that the OP is out of luck as I don't see all the teams who are over the median being corrected, but the good news is that you still have a fighting chance against these teams in many cases. Where it is most egregious is in the lowest of the minors, level 13, 16, 21 etc. When you are up against a level 38 HB in a capped 13 you will have some issues.
Yeah, last season a team I DCed was in a cap 24. We were worried about a couple of teams that had players 15-20 lvl. above the cap. When it was all said and done, lower level super slow builds dominated. lol
The problem with this is that some teams are horrible game-planners with bad builds and even with those extra levels will not be competitive. While I fully support making the caps hard within a season or two teams with these people will relegate and when they do they will out level many of the teams in the league they get demoted to. So ultimately the league will be "pure" for 1 season at most. Should the leagues have been hard capped, imo yes. Will this fix the OPs initial complaint, no not really because these same teams will be moving down next season.
The good news is even with the level superiority most of these teams will continue to fail at taking down championships since they aren't skilled game planners. I was in a league last season where a team outleveled my team by 7 levels at nearly every position and 10+ at a few. Needless to say my underleveled team beat them handily and that team did not even host a playoff game although they did make the playoffs. Unfortunately I have a feeling that the OP is out of luck as I don't see all the teams who are over the median being corrected, but the good news is that you still have a fighting chance against these teams in many cases. Where it is most egregious is in the lowest of the minors, level 13, 16, 21 etc. When you are up against a level 38 HB in a capped 13 you will have some issues.
Yeah, last season a team I DCed was in a cap 24. We were worried about a couple of teams that had players 15-20 lvl. above the cap. When it was all said and done, lower level super slow builds dominated. lol
merenoise
offline
offline
Originally posted by jmsne
Teams arent going to move down anymore, the bottom two teams stay put the teams from 9-14 go up one level and the teams that make the playoffs go up 2. If they suck at gameplanning or have bad builds they will stick around in the conference again.
Yeah just re-read the Wiki on that you are right. That being the case it will work itself out even quicker since teams won't be able to drop down although with some teams at the bottom rung you may end up seeing teams way above the cap if they tank a few seasons. Still it does help level the playing field for the casual user and should help teams that are well managed move up more quickly. Trust me when I say that levels < game plans and builds. It sucks to lose a championship this season to achieve some sort of parity but in the long term it will really help the game.
Teams arent going to move down anymore, the bottom two teams stay put the teams from 9-14 go up one level and the teams that make the playoffs go up 2. If they suck at gameplanning or have bad builds they will stick around in the conference again.
Yeah just re-read the Wiki on that you are right. That being the case it will work itself out even quicker since teams won't be able to drop down although with some teams at the bottom rung you may end up seeing teams way above the cap if they tank a few seasons. Still it does help level the playing field for the casual user and should help teams that are well managed move up more quickly. Trust me when I say that levels < game plans and builds. It sucks to lose a championship this season to achieve some sort of parity but in the long term it will really help the game.
jmsne
offline
offline
no it means that several teams will get stuck playing against the same teams over the cap over and over again. They get to take advantage of the system until they get to uncapped.
GoHooterGo
offline
offline
Originally posted by cowcards
Enforcing a cap would be freakin sweet.
Hottest Avatar yet!
Enforcing a cap would be freakin sweet.
Hottest Avatar yet!
cowcards
offline
offline
Enforce a hard cap right now. Force everyone more than 3 levels, to allow for boosting, above the cap off their respective teams.
Once this is done then it never needs to be worried about again as long as you can only sign players that are at or below the cap.
Everything will balance out. Everything will be fair.
I can see already people complaining in a couple season when Team A's entire team is level 40+ in a 34 cap league because they never got promoted. If they never get promoted though they can't be that good.
No moving down? That sucks I was hoping my team would get demoted. If anyone wants to go to an uncapped league let me know. I would really love to move down.
Once this is done then it never needs to be worried about again as long as you can only sign players that are at or below the cap.
Everything will balance out. Everything will be fair.
I can see already people complaining in a couple season when Team A's entire team is level 40+ in a 34 cap league because they never got promoted. If they never get promoted though they can't be that good.
No moving down? That sucks I was hoping my team would get demoted. If anyone wants to go to an uncapped league let me know. I would really love to move down.
cowcards
offline
offline
Originally posted by jmsne
no it means that several teams will get stuck playing against the same teams over the cap over and over again. They get to take advantage of the system until they get to uncapped.
If a team keeps getting stuck in the same cap they obviously aren't any good and are where they should be.
no it means that several teams will get stuck playing against the same teams over the cap over and over again. They get to take advantage of the system until they get to uncapped.
If a team keeps getting stuck in the same cap they obviously aren't any good and are where they should be.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























