User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #1 > Simple question.... " Should Ron Mexico EVER be allowed to play in the NFL again?"
Page:
 
Gustoon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cornerbackX24
Originally posted by gustoon


Thanks for pointing out that Dogs are animals.
Its funny , but certain people from certain societies have the exact same ethic , if you can call it ethics about this.
Fortunately your views are in the minority.


What do you mean by certain ppl from certain societies? Implying over here in Germany we have a different attitude towards animals? Or just implying I am a scrub?

My take on that is he served his time and should be able to play in the NFL again if he (still) has the tools.


Yeah, I know you come from Germany ???
I'll spell it out for you , in some of the Ghettos and Redneck country, dog fighting is seen as acceptable.
Who has the biggest meanest dog on the block = status.
I guess some people are more forgiving than others, I like to think that I am, but once again, When it comes to anything or anyone that doesn't have a voice to speak up, I find that totally abhorrent.


Originally posted by Festus
Originally posted by gustoon

Originally posted by cornerbackX24


Good god its dogs. Animals. Do you have a bad feeling when you order that DoubleWhooper w/ cheese?


Thanks for pointing out that Dogs are animals.
Its funny , but certain people from certain societies have the exact same ethic , if you can call it ethics about this.
Fortunately your views are in the minority.


As I've pointed out, dog fighting is legal in Japan. But not everybody is required by law to participate in dog fighting. Only those who willingly want to.


Dr Doolittle is involved then ?
Japan is world renown for its stance on whaling and other practices that the rest of the world gave up on years ago. Eating monkey brains whilst the animal is still alive ??? Hannibal Lector anyone ?
 
Festus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gustoon

Dr Doolittle is involved then ?
Japan is world renown for its stance on whaling and other practices that the rest of the world gave up on years ago. Eating monkey brains whilst the animal is still alive ??? Hannibal Lector anyone ?


Allow me to ask.

Why are you placing the same value on an animal as you would a human?

 
tkired
offline
Link
 
monkey brains is China. they also like to eat them dogs. cultures treat different animals differently. Vick made dogs fight, killed some losers. Our nice little government kills people.

anyway, the NFL is predicated on violence, Ray Lewis or Leonard Little are more deserving of lifetime bans than vick, tbh
 
Gustoon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Festus
Originally posted by gustoon


Dr Doolittle is involved then ?
Japan is world renown for its stance on whaling and other practices that the rest of the world gave up on years ago. Eating monkey brains whilst the animal is still alive ??? Hannibal Lector anyone ?


Allow me to ask.

Why are you placing the same value on an animal as you would a human?



Where did I say that?
This isn't about me. Its about Vick.

We all have our own ideal's on life and how to coexist with it. Generally most western people are aghast at any sport that involves animals fighting , take the same concept to other parts of the globe and its accepted as being the 'norm'.
Vick though committed a crime in a country that frowns upon such cruelty. If he was just Joe public he would serve his time in the big house and it would all be done with. But Vick was one of the most recognised faces in the NFL and a role model for alot of children, and with that wealth and fame that he so coveted, comes responsibility. He got caught, and as far as I'm concerned, part of his punishment should be that hes not allowed to step onto an NFL football field.
Goodell though, will probably let him back in.
 
Festus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gustoon

Dr Doolittle is involved then ?
Japan is world renown for its stance on whaling and other practices that the rest of the world gave up on years ago. Eating monkey brains whilst the animal is still alive ??? Hannibal Lector anyone ?


Originally posted by FESTUS
Allow me to ask.

Why are you placing the same value on an animal as you would a human?



Originally posted by
Where did I say that?


"Eating monkey brains whilst the animal is still alive ??? Hannibal Lector anyone ?"
"ANY crime against children or animals , where they do not have a voice , deserves the full force of the law , my opinion."

Originally posted by
This isn't about me. Its about Vick.


Yet it's all about you and what you think. You've already determined that Vick doesn't deserve a second chance.

Originally posted by
We all have our own ideal's on life and how to coexist with it. Generally most western people are aghast at any sport that involves animals fighting , take the same concept to other parts of the globe and its accepted as being the 'norm'.
Vick though committed a crime in a country that frowns upon such cruelty.


While at the same time these same western people will turn a blind eye towards horse racing, dog racing, rodeo and the meat industry.

Cruelty is pretty damn subjective, eh?

Originally posted by
If he was just Joe public he would serve his time in the big house and it would all be done with. But Vick was one of the most recognised faces in the NFL and a role model for alot of children, and with that wealth and fame that he so coveted, comes responsibility. He got caught, and as far as I'm concerned, part of his punishment should be that hes not allowed to step onto an NFL football field.


Thing is, he is Joe Public. To me it doesn't matter if he was one of the most recognized faces in the NFL or if some considered him a role model for their children. Have children? Do you allow them to look up to professional athletes? And since when does wealth and fame come with responsibility? The only responsibility a person has is to try and not cause harm to another. Dog fighting in and of itself, does not cause harm to another unless the dog that is fighting was stolen from another.

It seems to me that you have very little problems with how animals are intentionally used in which injury and death is caused in that use. Like horse racing. Because it's based upon the practice being legal.

Originally posted by
Goodell though, will probably let him back in.


I don't see why that's a problem. The man possesses a right to make a living. Since you want to hold him to the letter of the law, by that definition, he's served his time and paid his debt to society. Now you want to continue punishing him because you find it reprehensible what he did as you put another forkful of steak into your mouth.
Edited by Festus on Jun 11, 2009 08:12:44
Edited by Festus on Jun 11, 2009 08:12:02
 
Gustoon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Festus
Originally posted by gustoon


Dr Doolittle is involved then ?
Japan is world renown for its stance on whaling and other practices that the rest of the world gave up on years ago. Eating monkey brains whilst the animal is still alive ??? Hannibal Lector anyone ?


Originally posted by FESTUS

Allow me to ask.

Why are you placing the same value on an animal as you would a human?



Originally posted by

Where did I say that?


"Eating monkey brains whilst the animal is still alive ??? Hannibal Lector anyone ?"
"ANY crime against children or animals , where they do not have a voice , deserves the full force of the law , my opinion."

Where did I say that?
Once again where does it say that I place human life over animals ???



Originally posted by

This isn't about me. Its about Vick.


Yet it's all about you and what you think. You've already determined that Vick doesn't deserve a second chance.

So provide an argument as to why Vick should play and be completely exonerated.

Originally posted by

We all have our own ideal's on life and how to coexist with it. Generally most western people are aghast at any sport that involves animals fighting , take the same concept to other parts of the globe and its accepted as being the 'norm'.
Vick though committed a crime in a country that frowns upon such cruelty.


While at the same time these same western people will turn a blind eye towards horse racing, dog racing, rodeo and the meat industry.

Cruelty is pretty damn subjective, eh?

Haha , you kidding right ?
Well fed animals in 5 star accommodation that mostly lead a fantastic life. True, some die in horrendous accidents , but they are not starved and train to kill another of its kind....are they.
Terrible comparisons. Fail.


Originally posted by

If he was just Joe public he would serve his time in the big house and it would all be done with. But Vick was one of the most recognised faces in the NFL and a role model for alot of children, and with that wealth and fame that he so coveted, comes responsibility. He got caught, and as far as I'm concerned, part of his punishment should be that hes not allowed to step onto an NFL football field.


Thing is, he is Joe Public. To me it doesn't matter if he was one of the most recognized faces in the NFL
care to contradict yourself some more LMAO!!! or if some considered him a role model for their children. Have children? Do you allow them to look up to professional athletes? And since when does wealth and fame come with responsibility? The only responsibility a person has is to try and not cause harm to another. Dog fighting in and of itself, does not cause harm to another unless the dog that is fighting was stolen from another. OOOPs....looks like I'm wasting time reading this garbage

It seems to me that you have very little problems with how animals are intentionally used in which injury and death is caused in that use. Like horse racing. Because it's based upon the practice being legal.

No! Once again your total misuse of comparison is just laughable

Originally posted by

Goodell though, will probably let him back in.


I don't see why that's a problem. The man possesses a right to make a living. Since you want to hold him to the letter of the law, by that definition, he's served his time and paid his debt to society. Now you want to continue punishing him because you find it reprehensible what he did as you put another forkful of steak into your mouth.

Goodell >>>IMO <<< is a puppet of the NFL....so far. He is following in the footsteps of some truly great commissioners. In years to come, no one will talk about Goodell.


Some of your ideology is disturbing . Where in the world do you come from ? Not the US
Edited by gustoon on Jun 11, 2009 08:37:45
Edited by gustoon on Jun 11, 2009 08:36:40
Edited by gustoon on Jun 11, 2009 08:35:59
 
Festus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gustoon


Where did I say that?
Once again where does it say that I place human life over animals ???

I never wrote that you placed human life over animals. I would place the value of a human over that of an animal.

On that note, you place animal life on par with human life until it become inconvenient to do so.

It's convenient for you to put a monkey on the same level as a human because you don't eat monkey.
It's convenient for you to put a dog on the same level as a human because you don't fight or kill dogs.
It's inconvenient for you to put a cow on the same level as a human because you happen to eat cow.

Originally posted by

So provide an argument as to why Vick should play and be completely exonerated.


Vick never should have been charged with anything in the first place. The dogs he was fighting and killing belonged to him and no other person.

Every crime requires a victim.

The state screaming "because I said so" does not a victim make.

On that note, every person has the right to not associate with a person who chooses to fight dogs. This includes the NFL. But if you look at it, there are some teams who say they will absolutely not deal with Vick, while other teams are showing some interest.

Even if Goodell were to re-instate Vick, there's no guarantee a team will contract with him.

Originally posted by
Haha , you kidding right ?
Well fed animals in 5 star accommodation that mostly lead a fantastic life. True, some die in horrendous accidents , but they are not starved and train to kill another of its kind....are they.
Terrible comparisons. Fail.


No, not terrible comparisons. Spot on, actually.

In both cases, dog fighting and horse racing, it's use of animals by humans for the needs and wants of humans.

In both cases the animals are intentionally placed in a situation where injures and death can and will occur.

What are the prime motives behind the activities?

1. Profit.
2. Improving the breed to their standards.
3. Entertainment.

1. Profit - After a horse wins a certain amount of races that horse is retired to stud, drawing tens of thousands of dollars in breeding. After a dog wins five consecutive fights (Grand Champion) that dog is put out to stud drawing tens of thousands of dollars in breeding.

2. Improving the breed to their standards - These horses are bred to run fast, placed in competition to win races. The faster the horse, the higher the probability in winning a race. The pit bull (primary dog in US dog fighting) is bred to fight other animals. Not every pit bull that is produced is a fighter. The goal is to create the champion fighting dog, just like the goal is to create the champion racing horse. It's all about breeding the animal to their standards. The dog is not trained to fight, the dog either has it or it doesn't. It's called "game".

3. Entertainment - Gambling or the competition of the race/fight. This is no different than when we watch outdoor nature shows that depict prey versus predator. If people weren't "into it", the market wouldn't call for it.

You deem it acceptable or condone the fact that horses are injured or killed in racing (approximately 600 a year in the US) because you find the event acceptable. You feel that the injuries or death incurred in dog fighting is unacceptable or cruel because you find dog fighting to be unacceptable. In both cases the animals are intentionally placed in those situations where death and injury can and will occur which makes that death and injury intentional at the hands of humans.

Just like in horse racing, not all dogs that involved in dog fighting are killed if they lose. If you know anything about dog fighting, most fights don't even end in the death of the dog. Now, some losing dogs are killed because they are not economically feasible for the owner. The owner will take a loss on the animal if the dog keeps losing fights. It's approximately the same with horse racing. I would say that a good amount of horses are sold as pets, but a good many are sold to slaughterhouses as well. One need look no further than Ferdinand. Ferdinand won the Kentucky Derby and The Breeders Cup Classic, was retired to stud shortly thereafter. He was eventually sent to a breeding farm in Japan and he produced no future champions. Ferdinand ended up as a steak on somebody's plate because he was not economically feasible. He was sent to a slaughterhouse because he didn't produce.

Originally posted by
Thing is, he is Joe Public. To me it doesn't matter if he was one of the most recognized faces in the NFL care to contradict yourself some more LMAO!!! or if some considered him a role model for their children. Have children? Do you allow them to look up to professional athletes? And since when does wealth and fame come with responsibility? The only responsibility a person has is to try and not cause harm to another. Dog fighting in and of itself, does not cause harm to another unless the dog that is fighting was stolen from another. OOOPs....looks like I'm wasting time reading this garbage


Let's say you own a dog. Some person comes along and steals your dog. Is that person charged with kidnapping (dognapping) or is that person charged with theft of property? Who's property is it? The dog's...or yours? So who's the victim?

If Michael Vick is fighting dogs, how does that make you a victim?

Originally posted by
No! Once again your total misuse of comparison is just laughable

How is it a misuse of comparisons when it's comparing use of animals? Certainly more valid than your comparison of eating monkey brains to Hannibal Lecter.

Is one aspect of cruelty to be condoned while the other is not?

Originally posted by
Some of your ideology is disturbing . Where in the world do you come from ? Not the US


Why yes I do hail from the US. I just happen to believe in freedom and liberty and not pointing a gun at another's head, threatening to kill them if they don't stop partaking in activities I find disagreeable that do not cause me or another harm.

Edited by Festus on Jun 11, 2009 09:28:48
Edited by Festus on Jun 11, 2009 09:27:57
 
robweiss
offline
Link
 
Cock fighting rocks

Nothing is better than the post fight "winner winner chicken dinner"


Let Vick play
Edited by robweiss on Jun 11, 2009 09:36:07
 
Gustoon
offline
Link
 
Festus , I can't be assed with you now.
Thank god you don't live anywhere near me.
 
Festus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gustoon
Festus , I can't be assed with you now.
Thank god you don't live anywhere near me.


I'll take that as your concession.

Once you step upon the moral pedestal denouncing one person's use of animals while claiming yours is morally superior, you're screwed.
 
robweiss
offline
Link
 
How does a wolf or coyote exert dominance amongst a pack?

How does a grizzly bear exert dominance for a prime fishing spot?

How do rams,elk ,moose and deer exert their ability to mate?

unfortunately when these fights take place in the wild where there is a noticeable discrepancy between the abilities of the combatants and the fight ends fairly quickly . In organized dog fights your taking 2 alpha dogs putting them together and it's a shame they are nearly equal in abilities and the end result is unfortunate but to think that same result never happens in the wild is wrong too. I've come across deer dead in the wild and see the puncture wounds in the neck from another horn. So fatalities happen no matter where the fight takes place.

I could careless though opinions are like assholes everyones got one


 
lolShowtime
offline
Link
 
tl;dr gtfo imo ftw
 
Link
 
There is a difference between how animals fight for dominance in the wild, and a human being setting up a dog fighting ring. These are supposed to be domesticated animals. When was the last time you saw a pitbull running around in the wild, let alone the last time you found a dead pitbull in the wild that was killed because he was fighting for a fishing spot? It doesn't happen. In our society fighting dogs is taboo, and its against the law. It was against the law 7-9 years ago when he started this shit, and its illegal now. Vick broke the law and he knew that what he was doing was against the law.

If Vick wanted to eat a pitbull taco he should have taken his ass to Mexico and did the dog fighting thing there where it isn't taboo/illegal. Human beings have animalistic urges, but its not ok if some mongoloid goes around and rapes random women just because its part of their genetic make up. This is similar to T.I.'s situation. They both knew what they were doing was wrong, they did what they wanted anyways, and they have to own up to that. I can guarantee if Vick is re-instated that the NFL will have a PR nightmare brewing with PITA. If the NFL deems the Vick situation as too much of a hindrance from a business standpoint, then they owe it to their shareholders to bring down a lifetime ban on Vick. Bad publicity can really damage the product any business sells, and NFL players are highly marketed by the NFL and their respective teams to help sell the product.
 
Gustoon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derek McFadden
There is a difference between how animals fight for dominance in the wild, and a human being setting up a dog fighting ring. These are supposed to be domesticated animals. When was the last time you saw a pitbull running around in the wild, let alone the last time you found a dead pitbull in the wild that was killed because he was fighting for a fishing spot? It doesn't happen. In our society fighting dogs is taboo, and its against the law. It was against the law 7-9 years ago when he started this shit, and its illegal now. Vick broke the law and he knew that what he was doing was against the law.

If Vick wanted to eat a pitbull taco he should have taken his ass to Mexico and did the dog fighting thing there where it isn't taboo/illegal. Human beings have animalistic urges, but its not ok if some mongoloid goes around and rapes random women just because its part of their genetic make up. This is similar to T.I.'s situation. They both knew what they were doing was wrong, they did what they wanted anyways, and they have to own up to that. I can guarantee if Vick is re-instated that the NFL will have a PR nightmare brewing with PITA. If the NFL deems the Vick situation as too much of a hindrance from a business standpoint, then they owe it to their shareholders to bring down a lifetime ban on Vick. Bad publicity can really damage the product any business sells, and NFL players are highly marketed by the NFL and their respective teams to help sell the product.


+1
Your beating your head against a brick wall in here.
 
Festus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derek McFadden
There is a difference between how animals fight for dominance in the wild, and a human being setting up a dog fighting ring. These are supposed to be domesticated animals. When was the last time you saw a pitbull running around in the wild, let alone the last time you found a dead pitbull in the wild that was killed because he was fighting for a fishing spot? It doesn't happen. In our society fighting dogs is taboo, and its against the law. It was against the law 7-9 years ago when he started this shit, and its illegal now. Vick broke the law and he knew that what he was doing was against the law.

If Vick wanted to eat a pitbull taco he should have taken his ass to Mexico and did the dog fighting thing there where it isn't taboo/illegal. Human beings have animalistic urges, but its not ok if some mongoloid goes around and rapes random women just because its part of their genetic make up. This is similar to T.I.'s situation. They both knew what they were doing was wrong, they did what they wanted anyways, and they have to own up to that. I can guarantee if Vick is re-instated that the NFL will have a PR nightmare brewing with PITA. If the NFL deems the Vick situation as too much of a hindrance from a business standpoint, then they owe it to their shareholders to bring down a lifetime ban on Vick. Bad publicity can really damage the product any business sells, and NFL players are highly marketed by the NFL and their respective teams to help sell the product.


What's the difference between a person fighting dogs and a person running around raping women? In the case of rape, there is a victim. In the case of dog fighting, it's based upon "because I said so".

Ultimately your position comes down the fact that if it's considered taboo then it should be outlawed. If that's the case then you would have no issues with states who have laws that prohibit oral sex and declare such actions as "crimes against nature" punishable by years in prison. Once again, a law based upon "because I said so".

I have no problems with the NFL banning Vick for the actions he committed. It's called freedom of association. But neither should he be punished by loss of freedom, threatened with loss of life and have his bank accounts plundered by the state for actions that caused no harm to another person.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.