User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > Something about the Bible I honestly want to know
Page:
 
NObodyn0se
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
"In situations where the subject's status is previously determined by specific behaviors, the fallacy does not apply. For example, it is perfectly justified to say, "No true vegetarian eats meat," because not eating meat is the single thing that precisely defines a person as a vegetarian."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman


And the Pope? Is he not a true Scotsman?
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
I'm not a Roman Catholic.

I can speak to the unfaithfulness of Protestant pastors. I can speak to the false teaching of materialism. I can speak to how Christians sin daily not so much in deed but in thought.

Still does not prove the Gospel of Jesus Christ to be fallacious.
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy


But any religion that uses the bible as its basis will be subject to the same criticisms that its a glorified superstition.


Can we use the same textual criticism for Plato, Socrates, Roussaeu(spelling), Marx etc?

I'll submit to you that the reason the bible get's so much criticism is because this book more than any speaks to the conscience? No?
Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 08:52:13
Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 08:49:20
 
NObodyn0se
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
I'm not a Roman Catholic.

I can speak to the unfaithfulness of Protestant pastors. I can speak to the false teaching of materialism. I can speak to how Christians sin daily not so much in deed but in thought.

Still does not prove the Gospel of Jesus Christ to be fallacious.


But The Pope is a Christian, right?
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
I don't know what the Pope stands for directly so I can't make that call objectively. It would be arrogant without evidence to make a call on someones faith IF the deeds aren't out there for everyone to see. We can make a call on unrepented outward sin that flies in the face of doctrine... Once again I'm not a Roman Catholic or really familiar with all it entails.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal


Can we use the same textual criticism for Plato, Socrates, Roussaeu(spelling), Marx etc?

I'll submit to you that the reason the bible get's so much criticism is because this book more than any speaks to the conscience? No?


I don't see anyone claiming that Plato is the infallible word of God though. However, as long as you do not translate the Bible literally (i.e., like Christian Fundamentalists), then most of the textual criticism is moot.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NObodyn0se

But The Pope is a Christian, right?


I was under the impression that the Pope was a Nazi.
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
"In situations where the subject's status is previously determined by specific behaviors, the fallacy does not apply. For example, it is perfectly justified to say, "No true vegetarian eats meat," because not eating meat is the single thing that precisely defines a person as a vegetarian."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman


The thing that defines a Christian is belief in Jesus. One can believe in Jesus and in national socialism. Therefore, your exemption does not apply. Your statement was indeed an example of the No True Scotsman fallacy.
 
NObodyn0se
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by NObodyn0se


But The Pope is a Christian, right?


I was under the impression that the Pope was a Nazi.


He was. The Pope (as in the office, not as in the current dude) is also responsible for some of the worst tragedies in human history.

 
staggart
offline
Link
 
everyone was in the nazi youth if you were in WWII era germany. You really do not have a choice when your leader was a crazed dictator. There are many things being revealed with modern day science to be in fact true. Such as Moses spliting the seas... which was believed to be do to tides. Also the garden of eden is theorized to be south of Kuwait in the persian gulf. It used to reside in a valley which has since been flooded. Also the great flood story is theorized to have taken place in the black sea region
 
NObodyn0se
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by staggart
everyone was in the nazi youth if you were in WWII era germany. You really do not have a choice when your leader was a crazed dictator. There are many things being revealed with modern day science to be in fact true. Such as Moses spliting the seas... which was believed to be do to tides. Also the garden of eden is theorized to be south of Kuwait in the persian gulf. It used to reside in a valley which has since been flooded. Also the great flood story is theorized to have taken place in the black sea region


So you're saying the bible is wrong?
 
staggart
offline
Link
 
I am saying that the stories are true. If there is a God behind them, that is the question for the reader to decide for themselves.
Edited by staggart on Jun 9, 2009 09:20:14
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Sureal

"In situations where the subject's status is previously determined by specific behaviors, the fallacy does not apply. For example, it is perfectly justified to say, "No true vegetarian eats meat," because not eating meat is the single thing that precisely defines a person as a vegetarian."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman


The thing that defines a Christian is belief in Jesus. One can believe in Jesus and in national socialism. Therefore, your exemption does not apply. Your statement was indeed an example of the No True Scotsman fallacy.


To believe in Jesus soley is not what defines a Christian. The Muslims believe in Jesus as well.
 
icebergin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
Originally posted by captobvious

Originally posted by Sureal


"In situations where the subject's status is previously determined by specific behaviors, the fallacy does not apply. For example, it is perfectly justified to say, "No true vegetarian eats meat," because not eating meat is the single thing that precisely defines a person as a vegetarian."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman


The thing that defines a Christian is belief in Jesus. One can believe in Jesus and in national socialism. Therefore, your exemption does not apply. Your statement was indeed an example of the No True Scotsman fallacy.


To believe in Jesus soley is not what defines a Christian. The Muslims believe in Jesus as well.


False. The muslims do not believe in the divinity of Jesus.
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
That was not clarified in the previous statement in regards to divinity. It looked like just believing in Jesus.

Still not the sole definition. It's that Jesus died on the cross appeasing a wrathful God so that all who believes in Him AND the works upon the cross will be saved. Detailed scriptures of the workings of the Holy Spirit which sanctifies does not tell of a entity that coherses Born Again Christians to gas people. Does not tell people to protest in front of funeral homes of fallen soliders or to kill abortion clinic workers/doctors. Does not tell preachers to preach false hope of wealth and 10 steps to better your life... Sorry went off on a tangent.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.