User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #2 > Final GLB Rankings By Position Eastern Conference
Page:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
You can't it has to be pieced together - doesn't it?
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 
This list is complete horseshit IMHO. The Current one of the BEST teams in the league only has 2 players. We may have the best defense in all of AA#2 and we have 1 defensive player on the team.

Bort can take his formula and shove it where the sun don't shine. I think this in no way reflects the best players at each position.

Cheeburgers inactive kicker:
9 34 39 1/1 7/7 9/9 9/10 8/12 187 190 27

My kicker
9 34 36 1/1 6/6 10/10 14/14 3/5 219 221 2

I guess tackles is the most important stat for a kicker because that is the only thing he has my kicker beat at.

This is just an example. I am sure there are more examples of this out there.
 
Peacesells
iBuying
offline
Link
 
The problems with stats is that it rewards decent players on bad teams since they get all the statistics. SS for example should never lead a team in tackles..but will if the the teams defense is poor. That doesn't mean the SS is great...just that he has opportunities he shouldn't.

If the team is good and balanced then everyone's stats look average. The BEE O-line for instance. They did a great job all year..but no one shows up as a top player in the stats category.
 
aridhol
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed
This list is complete horseshit IMHO. The Current one of the BEST teams in the league only has 2 players. We may have the best defense in all of AA#2 and we have 1 defensive player on the team.

Bort can take his formula and shove it where the sun don't shine. I think this in no way reflects the best players at each position.

Cheeburgers inactive kicker:
9 34 39 1/1 7/7 9/9 9/10 8/12 187 190 27

My kicker
9 34 36 1/1 6/6 10/10 14/14 3/5 219 221 2

I guess tackles is the most important stat for a kicker because that is the only thing he has my kicker beat at.

This is just an example. I am sure there are more examples of this out there.



lol, why the hell do you care so much? your need for other's recognition of your created players that important to you?
 
Peacesells
iBuying
offline
Link
 
I'd think you have to care a bit...just to play the game. Otherwise...what's the point?
 
tramiken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aridhol

lol, why the hell do you care so much? your need for other's recognition of your created players that important to you?



stfu, just saying
 
Supahfli
offline
Link
 
They got one thing correct at least...

Tyrone Van Wexler is probably one of ,if not the best player in this league. He is the 101st best defensive player in all of GLB!!!


I know how you feel Current, we only had 2 players on that list as well. We had the #1 rushing attack, yet no HB's on the list...oh well.I guess we shouldn't have spread our offense around so much against the gutted teams.
Edited by Supahfli on May 27, 2009 12:39:44
 
Peacesells
iBuying
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Peacesells
The problems with stats is that it rewards decent players on bad teams since they get all the statistics. SS for example should never lead a team in tackles..but will if the the teams defense is poor. That doesn't mean the SS is great...just that he has opportunities he shouldn't.

If the team is good and balanced then everyone's stats look average. The BEE O-line for instance. They did a great job all year..but no one shows up as a top player in the stats category.



Just to add a bit about this.

The BEE had the #1 passing offense in total yards and yards per attempts.

The BEE had the #3 run offense in total yards and the #1 running offense in yards per carry by almost 3 yards.

The BEE completion percentage was 2nd and the team in first only threw half the times the BEE did.

The Bee were #1 in passing TD's and #3 in interceptions.

The BEE by far had the best total offense (combined rush/pass) in the league.

Yet...no one from the O-line is mentioned. Really, the majority of our offense is left out, but it's due to the balanced play.

 
majech
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Peacesells
I'd think you have to care a bit...just to play the game. Otherwise...what's the point?


EXACTLY

It's not a matter of needing recognition, but why add stuff to the game that is ass-retarded? There are way too many things about this game that just don't make any sense, and Bort goes and adds another thing to the list.

We have ST players on our team that get endorsement deals. Seriously, why is our ST DE that NEVER steps foot on the field during defense getting endorsements over our DE's that are among the league leader in sacks? What is really brilliant about the system is that he got the endorsement after being on the team for ONE game in which he made ZERO tackles. Nice system there.
 
Linkzmax
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Peacesells
The problems with stats is that it rewards decent players on bad teams since they get all the statistics. SS for example should never lead a team in tackles..but will if the the teams defense is poor. That doesn't mean the SS is great...just that he has opportunities he shouldn't.

If the team is good and balanced then everyone's stats look average. The BEE O-line for instance. They did a great job all year..but no one shows up as a top player in the stats category.
This, totally this! And it's a feeling I've had for quite a while. It's much easier to shine when you're picking up the slack for everyone else. It's far harder to match those stats when teammates are turning those missed tackles into stops, pancakes into sacks, broken tackles into pancakes, etc.

Then again, in the given example that SS is a KEY player on the team because without him many of those tackles could be scores. So he certainly is a valued player on that team. But that shouldn't necessarily equate to MVP candidacy for a conference.
 
majech
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Linkzmax
Originally posted by Peacesells

The problems with stats is that it rewards decent players on bad teams since they get all the statistics. SS for example should never lead a team in tackles..but will if the the teams defense is poor. That doesn't mean the SS is great...just that he has opportunities he shouldn't.

If the team is good and balanced then everyone's stats look average. The BEE O-line for instance. They did a great job all year..but no one shows up as a top player in the stats category.
This, totally this! And it's a feeling I've had for quite a while. It's much easier to shine when you're picking up the slack for everyone else. It's far harder to match those stats when teammates are turning those missed tackles into stops, pancakes into sacks, broken tackles into pancakes, etc.

Then again, in the given example that SS is a KEY player on the team because without him many of those tackles could be scores. So he certainly is a valued player on that team. But that shouldn't necessarily equate to MVP candidacy for a conference.


Agreed. That is why I've been beating the Sean Cole drum so much. Our defense is very good and has many players that make plays. Despite that, Cole has over 100 tackles. He is not the lone start on a team and just padding stats.

SS is tough though. Typically a SS getting a lot of tackles means that the front 7 are weak, but in the right defense a SS can get a lot of tackles because of the DC getting him to the LOS. If the SS plays a game and has 10 tackles, but 7 of them are for 1 yard gain, that is great defense, but if all 10 of the tackles are for 7 yard gains, that is bad defense. If the first scenario the SS is a stud and should be rewarded.
 
Blink00
offline
Link
 
Hey look, another subjective ranking system. Welcome to online video games.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
zzzzz only one trophy counts.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.