User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Achievements (Account and Player)
Page:
 
TTGarner10
offline
Link
 
And yes, I've given MMOB the same chance I gave GLB in its season 1 debut; however, with all the flaws MMOB has aside, I find myself checking out that achievement tab after every game.

And it makes sense, in the real world of sports, some agents are obviously better than others -- mainly based on experience and time in the league. Obviously, that is going to give his players some sort of edge.

Why not mimic that?

Give the people who have played this game for a while something to show for that, more than those killer 75 pixel trophies.

At this piont, the game is all about AI. If you aren't the OC or DC, you essentially do nothing except click "Show Score" and marvel at your "4 tckls". Thrilling....
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
The problem with this type of system is it rewards players who get to play against more gutted teams, and encourages players to try and go to leagues where they are at the top of the level cap so they can try and pwn to get xp faster.

I have players on a team where the HB ran for over 1,000 yards in a single game this season. Should he get an extra 150 xp for that one game?


If it were some sort of non game effecting awards (like certificates or medallions on an awards page) then I'm all for it. However, with current competitive imbalances and lack of competition control I don't want to see stats effecting how fast someone levels. Also, I believe performance based xp is on the NGTH list.
 
TTGarner10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
The problem with this type of system is it rewards players who get to play against more gutted teams, and encourages players to try and go to leagues where they are at the top of the level cap so they can try and pwn to get xp faster.

I have players on a team where the HB ran for over 1,000 yards in a single game this season. Should he get an extra 150 xp for that one game?


If it were some sort of non game effecting awards (like certificates or medallions on an awards page) then I'm all for it. However, with current competitive imbalances and lack of competition control I don't want to see stats effecting how fast someone levels. Also, I believe performance based xp is on the NGTH list.


I don't care if getting 50 INTs gave me a 15xp, Just give me something else to look at.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Performance-based XP is on the NGTH list, so take that out.

Any kind of performance-based tangible reward is thoroughly skewed by differences in competition.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Performance-based XP is on the NGTH list, so take that out.

Any kind of performance-based tangible reward is thoroughly skewed by differences in competition.



This is backward thinking though. You are in fact correct, but if they FIX those "differences in competition" then other ideas can then become do-able. I know that they have put their best foot forward with the restructuring of BBB leagues and A leagues coming.......but the real problem is that there are too many high level players in the lower tiers still. Putting a league cap on the HIGH side would help. The real problem is level 50+ guys in anything lower than AAA TBH.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Originally posted by dmfa41

Performance-based XP is on the NGTH list, so take that out.

Any kind of performance-based tangible reward is thoroughly skewed by differences in competition.



This is backward thinking though. You are in fact correct, but if they FIX those "differences in competition" then other ideas can then become do-able. I know that they have put their best foot forward with the restructuring of BBB leagues and A leagues coming.......but the real problem is that there are too many high level players in the lower tiers still. Putting a league cap on the HIGH side would help. The real problem is level 50+ guys in anything lower than AAA TBH.


Not necessarily, most of the players on my team have been with the team at least 2 seasons (if not longer). I hope to be promoted to AA actually, but lost in first round. I don't feel that I should tear apart good agents from the team b/c of level.
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by TTGarner10

Originally posted by Deathblade

This wasn't stolen from that terrible baseball game...


Ok, lets move away from the fact the game is a flop. However, do you not find it a bit foolish not to take away one of the few positive aspects and apply to a game many of us have been playing for a year?


Is it a positive aspect though?

I disagree with the whole "you need to do this to make a player that does this" thing. Your idea doesn't exactly have that, but it does give people an advantage.


People who can afford it would also make 100 players each season and just retire them once they get the achievements.
 
Link
 
I don't mind this suggestion, but it should really not affect stats/experience. People will abuse the lower leagues to get these accomplished.
 
TTGarner10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Performance-based XP is on the NGTH list, so take that out.

Any kind of performance-based tangible reward is thoroughly skewed by differences in competition.


Ok, 50 INTs gives your $50.

The reward for accomplishment is not what I'm pushing for. I am pushing for the ability to track your progress, as an agent, in all categories.

When you retire a player, you have absolutely nothing to show for it. Absolutely nothing, even though you may have played them for a full calendar year. However, if you at least have some sort of achievements tracker, at least i'd have something else to look at.

In a game that is nothing more than numbers and stats, I don't understand why more stats would be a problem.
 
mikelj
offline
Link
 
Problem is this rewards guys who put their lvl 55 LB in a shitty league to pad stats, you would have to do different pts for different leagues, say usa pro more pts than africa pro, etc...LOTS of work. I do like the idea though, but not sure how to implement
 
Link
 
Stats are STILL meaningless in this game. Somebody wake me when the leagues become competitive enough for stats to matter.
 
mikelj
offline
Link
 
It would be cool to have a spot for your lifetime as an owner. Listing all your players numbers...something like that would be kinda cool...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TTGarner10


When you retire a player, you have absolutely nothing to show for it. Absolutely nothing, even though you may have played them for a full calendar year.



You have the experience of playing the game as well as the relationships you formed with owners, GMs, and your fellow players. Getting a shiny "achievement" marker pales in comparison to those.
 
mikelj
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by TTGarner10



When you retire a player, you have absolutely nothing to show for it. Absolutely nothing, even though you may have played them for a full calendar year.



You have the experience of playing the game as well as the relationships you formed with owners, GMs, and your fellow players. Getting a shiny "achievement" marker pales in comparison to those.


Good point, but would still be nice to be able to see your retired players info.
 
TTGarner10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by TTGarner10



When you retire a player, you have absolutely nothing to show for it. Absolutely nothing, even though you may have played them for a full calendar year.



You have the experience of playing the game as well as the relationships you formed with owners, GMs, and your fellow players. Getting a shiny "achievement" marker pales in comparison to those.


negative.

you need more friends.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.