User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Well Brooks, the player's contract is a different issue, having a 250k contract for your player is ridiculous. But to spend 250k to get a level 6 guy over a level 4 guy is a good purchase for the team.

Here's a pure hypothetical, a level 6 corner might be worth 250k to add to my team right now, that's what its worth to me. So how do i get that and can i get that?

So let's say a team wants 250k to buy him. Well i cant do that, because I have to pay 250k to the team and 50k to the player, thats 300k, too high for what I want to pay.

But I might do 200k to the team and 50k to the player, that's in my budget of what its worth to me to get that player.
 
Link
 
Here's the easiest way to solve the problem:

The Trade Analyzer should restrict nothing, keep it fair for the teams that want to deal for what they want to deal for.

Secondly, have the same or similar restriction, but have it hide in the background, and when a "questionable" trade goes through, a email is sent to an admin to make sure that it's not some kind of bogus deal with a newbie that spends 1M on a player under false pretenses or what not.

That way, the teams that know what they are doing and want to do what they are doing, can do it freely, but if somebody tries to obviously cheat in some way, then they are going to get caught and thus should be penalized severely.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
The main reason there are restrictions on prices:

1. Keep the market from over-inflating
2. Protect owners from themselves
3. Help discourage team gutting
4. There are hundreds of trades made every day. We can't review them all, so we let the code help keep them fair.
 
Link
 
Yes those are good restrictions, but not when they restrict perfectly even trades such as the ones I have been doing.

Also, as a tip to other owners that are trying to figure out how to do these trades, you have to stay away from what I just did, because I didnt realize that there is a 10 day waiting period to get back a player that you release or trade to another team.


Here's the deal... I agreed to trade an OT6 and TE6 for 475k to a team. So to make it work, I sent him my CPU QB and Human FB extra, and he sent me 50k and 2 low level human inactives on top of the 475k.

So the plan was to wait for the trade to process last night and then do another trade today where I send his 2 low level humans and 50k for my FB and CPU QB back.

We can't finish the trade now, because of the 10 day rule. So currently I am under negotiations with the other owner to resolve this, it will probably be a solution of having me pay the owner the daily salaries of my players he's holding for me and then trying to give up something small or extra in return for him to let my FB play and gain some exp.

And all we tried to do was a perfectly even trade where I gave him 2 solid starting Level 6 players for fair market price. I didnt try to trade those guys aggressively and I can guarantee you that if you want to put it to the test for experimentation purposes, that I could have got more than 475k by trading them a little more aggressively, so I sold them for less than what the market was willing to pay.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
It's been said before and I'll say it again: add some CPU players to even it out. Don't have any? Sign a few FA's for min salary. Boom, you have a trade.

Think more in NBA terms for these kinds of deals, you may need to throw in a couple of useless pieces to make the trade work out, or hell, even have Keith Van Horn come out of retirement to make this work, but if it makes everything even, it makes everything even.
 
Link
 
Yeah that's the way I was going to do it, for some reason it seemed easier to trade one human in the deal rather than sign new CPUs, but since we couldnt trade back right away, it backfired.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
The Trade Analyzer does not come close to adequately measuring player values. I sold a Level 3 RB for $150k and a Level 5 SS for $250k last week, and had used CPUs that were on my roster to make the transaction.

Now that I do not have CPUs on the roster, people can only submit offers through PM, since the Analyzer has a cap to it. I have 8 guys on my team that teams are offering in excess of 200k+ and it makes it very difficult to finalize a trade. The only way we can execute the deal is for me to sign dummy CPUs and then make the trade the next day.

Thus it takes 2 days to complete one trade and takes money away from one team and gives it to CPU players in the process. And you cannot argue that the trade analyzer is fair, because I have PM after PM proof that the fair market value for all of these players are worth that much to myself and to the other teams.

When I put my SS5 on the block, I had a guy offering $250k within 5 minutes, I probably could have got a lot more than that too from other teams that were banging on my door.

Can something be done about this? Or at least in the short term if I reach an agreement to trade a player, can I PM Bort to make the swap manually?



Thank you for admitting I was right about trades not going through.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It sounds like people are over-valuing players. How is a lv 5 player worth $250k? How much is a level 50 player going to be worth? $250M?


EXACTLY. What they are doing is loading their bank under false pretenses. Next they'll be starting a second team so they can then rape the 2nd teams bank on ridiculous cash trades. It's already happening.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
sounds to me that it's working just fine...
 
Heatherb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert

Look at it this way. MH is on a 10 year contract with my team and he is going to be just about the best WR in this whole game in my opinion.

But in any event, I am sure MH is worth more than 1M and he's not going to be traded for that dollar amount it's going to take a LOT more than that.


Marvin Harrison 6'4" 182lbs WR 8 $80,000.00 11th season, day 16

thats 2k a day. once MH hits lvl 10 and up... lol your gonna get alot of mail from him

and if he is doing all these trades for cash, why is he so broke?

Detroit Demon Lions
USA AA (Eastern Conference)
Cash: $40,288.00
Next Game: 04/06/2008 at Cincinnati Who Dey (in 30:33:20)
Last Game: W 14-7
Last edited Apr 5, 2008 07:27:42
 
Link
 
I have a strategy for when MH hits level 10, and obviously my money is low because I'm spending it aggressively. Therefore it's either going to players as signing bonuses or stadium upgrades because those are the only things an owner can use money for.

Maybe MH got a 500k bonus for signing the 10 year deal, who knows what tricks are up my sleeve?
Last edited Apr 5, 2008 11:08:46
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
.

Maybe MH got a 500k bonus for signing the 10 year deal, who knows what tricks are up my sleeve?


Im pretty sure there is a cap on max signing bonus.
 
Link
 
There is but it's different depending on certain factors. Perhaps there's also max signing bonuses on many players on my team. There's lots of options I'm just pointing out the possibilities.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.