User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Fix the pathetic "jukes/headfakes" already, pretty please?
Page:
 
Cmfix64
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kite188
The first replay you can also see the MLB running side by side with the HB, then he just gets juked out. again, i understand if it was a diving tackle, but there shows no signs of a diving tackle.

If anything, I think the jukes should only be activated when the defender is ahead of the HB, pretty much looking at each other straight in the eyes.

It just pisses me off when they get juked out when coming from an angle and even from behind.


it wasn't necessarily a juke, coulda been a headfake and in all likelihood thats what it was and he slowed down like he should but barely... in fact he was barely affected by it
Last edited May 10, 2009 19:45:32
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cmfix64
Originally posted by tjsexy82

Originally posted by Cmfix64


These are poor examples tbh, no defender was juked while behind the runner and none were more than 4/5 yards away and every time he was caught from behind...the last had probably the closest thing to an arguement but those head fakes on the CB while he was being blocked could easily have happened


Yeah, I'm just addressing the problem on a larger scale because I've seen it happen in ridiculous situations. I didn't watch any of the particular plays he linked.


the only probably with arguing like that is we don't know the defenders stats... or the runners... or even the situations... i know there was a fix to reduce the angle of effectiveness and that seems to have helped... but like the play i linked in my edit thats just ridiculous and i agree there are situations for both arguments, but if its happening on both sides its likely just a big difference in the necessary stats to juke/avoid being juked


I guess I don't care about attributes because it's a problem that doesn't relate to builds. Even if a HB/WR has 10 in head fake and the CB has 20 vision...I just don't think HB/WR should be trying to fake in certain situations. It's unrealistic to fake when you're by a guy and he's not in your tackling radius, regardless of who it is pursuing you.
 
Cmfix64
offline
Link
 
right but a dot shrinking only means he got faked, many times that's all it means and he rarely has a hiccup those replays nobody was more than 5 yards away... thats a tackling radius imo... at least one to get juked because you need to make a move within that area
 
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
I see no problem with any of those. The players getting juked were fairly close to the HB.


This

The furtherst i seen a defender in the replays was 5 yds.
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
major problem with this:

defenders can tackle HBs while laying on the ground, so juke/headfake would accomplish nothing if this suggestion was implemented. you could fake them out of their cleats and they'd still make the tackle.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
+lots
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wlarson
major problem with this:

defenders can tackle HBs while laying on the ground, so juke/headfake would accomplish nothing if this suggestion was implemented. you could fake them out of their cleats and they'd still make the tackle.


Then go around them?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
Originally posted by wlarson

major problem with this:

defenders can tackle HBs while laying on the ground, so juke/headfake would accomplish nothing if this suggestion was implemented. you could fake them out of their cleats and they'd still make the tackle.


Then go around them?


If only the SIM were that intelligent...

I have no problem with jukes only having a chance to trigger when a defender is coming in from the side or front, and not when they are chasing from behind.

However, that means that the HB should pretty much IGNORE the player chasing them and just run to daylight or get caught and tackled.

While you may see some jukes happening to players chasing a HB down, I can't even count the number of times a HB has had clear daylight to paydirt and then stops to juke a guy chasing him and doesn't score the TD.

I think we might be able to agree that this is broken both ways.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tjsexy82
Yeah, I agree.

Jukes shouldn't trigger unless the player is within the tackling radius.


It should be a bit more (maybe twice the tackling radius), but otherwise that's a sweet idea.
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
before they fix this i hope my running back can do this this is rediculous i could see while the defender is in front of but when the defender is behind either that or make something fior all defenders to counter like a veteran ability or whatever those other things are called special abilaties i think i havnt played in awile.
 
Link
 
That 2nd one you juked the #$*( out of that FS
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
What's the freaking deal here? I've seen this happen too.

Is this occuring because players with higher tackling have a higher radius to tackle and thus get juked earlier? That's wildly unrealistic..

The jukes are fine but they happen way too early.

Needs a fix IMO
 
Kite188
offline
Link
 
it annoys me that there is no way around this other than a "sim fix" the majority of my defensive players, especially the ones that got faked out like the FS and SS have 65+ vision. and i dont know what you guys think but making a tackle while on the ground is possible and has been done. It usually is done by holding on to the waist as you are going down or by grabbing them by the foot. or sometimes they are not able to tackle them but they are able to slow them down enough for another defender to close up on the ballcarrier.
 
OG-Niner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
I see no problem with any of those. The players getting juked were fairly close to the HB.


 
Colter
offline
Link
 
The only problem I can see with this, is the juked player getting back up and tackling the halfback.
The halfback was pretty close to the defenders, or, close enough.
Guys make cut moves in the back field, primarily on draw plays.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.