User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make Carrying Tactics Relevant To Fumble Chance
Page:
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Yes, I do agree with that slider, definitely.

And in reality, I don't think being an elusive or a power back has anything to do with fumbling. I'm trying to do quick google research and while I'm not finding real evidence, I'm seeing a fair share of good share of both style of running backs who had problems fumbling and who were very good at taking care of the ball. It may be a small factor, but I think its more just about how one carries the ball. If they carry the ball the way they are supposed to they aren't going to fumble regardless of what happens, short of a knock out blow, which rarely happens.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by player66
I would say a player trying to fight for more yards has a much higher chance of fumbling (based on my 15 odd years of coaching and playing football).

Very true.


Originally posted by butler312
And in reality, I don't think being an elusive or a power back has anything to do with fumbling.

Franco Harris was a power-type RB and he holds the NFL record for fumbles by a running back. Most of the guys on that list were also power-oriented runners.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 11:33:15
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Gyuri1

My suggestion would be to make the likelihood of a fumble highest when the ball carrier is set to the -100 side of the carrying tactics and lowest when the ball carrier is set to the +100 side of the carrying tactic.

This was suggested in earlier seasons as a response to the power back craze and makes sense both from a game mechanic and realism standpoint.


And on a sidenote, why do the same people with no high level players constantly post in the suggestions forum? Butler312, Mordaloch, and those in the same group, you guys should wait until you have some experience before you start commenting on every part of the game. Unless of course you're multis of experienced players, in which case feel free to carry on.


dont forget about retired players they may have had
 
player66
offline
Link
 
I think a mod needs to take this to Bort because it is a fair and reasonable addition to the game
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by player66
dont forget about retired players they may have had

Sure, but you can tell when they created by their account number. Those two and lots like them are newbs to the game who have no clue what they're talking about, but insisting on giving their opinion in practically every thread. I'm not saying that newbs can't have an opinion, but don't try to argue with people who actually have experience at the game and don't go around polluting every thread with nonsense just because you want attention.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by player66

I would say a player trying to fight for more yards has a much higher chance of fumbling (based on my 15 odd years of coaching and playing football).

Very true.


Originally posted by butler312

And in reality, I don't think being an elusive or a power back has anything to do with fumbling.

Franco Harris was a power-type RB and he holds the NFL record for fumbles by a running back. Most of the guys on that list were also power-oriented runners.


being the power or elusive is only part of it. that is why the slide bar would be the second half. power backs can be stripped becasue the are fighting for yards and that is part of the power back image. I think the slide bar would fit right in to GLB and really make it a more all around game. Give it some balance and make it more realistic
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 11:36:53
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MentalMisfit
guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up


I support this post.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I really don't see the downside. The defenders that have packed on strength/tackling to deal with power backs will either still have a good chance to cause a fumble, or, if the PB uses the other side of the slider, a better chance to make a clean tackle.
 
Mordaloch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by player66

dont forget about retired players they may have had

Sure, but you can tell when they created by their account number. Those two and lots like them are newbs to the game who have no clue what they're talking about, but insisting on giving their opinion in practically every thread. I'm not saying that newbs can't have an opinion, but don't try to argue with people who actually have experience at the game and don't go around polluting every thread with nonsense just because you want attention.


you come on here calling people newbs cause they didn't start in season 1 and have a level 50

guess what buddy the game changes practically every season and some people learn faster then others when i post on a suggestion it's because i know what i'm talking about otherwise i wouldn't post, at any rate at least it encourages discussion not every 3rd season player is a complete newb like your standards suggest.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by MentalMisfit

guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up


I support this post.


Why (keep in mind that the original post on this was about a HB with 60 carrying and 60 strength)?

With the slider, either the high strength/tackling that was added by defenders will make it more likely to cause fumbles to stop the power backs that are trying to break tackles, or the high strength/tackling will make it more likely to stop the power backs from getting anywhere if they are trying to cover the ball up. In either case, that strength/tackling won't be wasted.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
The idea makes perfect sense. Backs in real football due have more fumbles when they attempt to break more tackles and gain extra yards, so it's reasonable that they would do so in GLB as well. Plus it's absurd to expect elusive backs to get 70 carrying when they have to spend more in speed & agility than power backs.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
an option to cover up the ball would add really good balance to the game not to mention it is very realistic. I also feel a RB's strength should have little to do with fumbling it should be about carrying vs tackling
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 11:45:34
 
mastawoo
offline
Link
 
This has been suggested multiple times in the past by multiple agents, including me. Never gets the attention it should in my opinion, just like 90% of the rational and logical suggestions, or most of "epic". Just do what the rest of us sheep do and deal with it until our flex runs out.
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mastawoo
This has been suggested multiple times in the past by multiple agents, including me. Never gets the attention it should in my opinion, just like 90% of the rational and logical suggestions, or most of "epic". Just do what the rest of us sheep do and deal with it until our flex runs out.


I have no job and a lot of time on my hands, this will become something someone will look at by seasons end haha
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Wow, this is my 5th season in GLB. I think I have plenty of time to see how the game works and make comments about it. Excuse me for actually be active in the forums and contributing to the community. And why do you need any experience in GLB at all to comment on who fumbles more in real life? I said in my initial post that I didn't have any facts and that it was just kind of how I felt. It could very largely be influenced by the fact that I'm a Bears fan. When I think of an elusive player I think of Devin Hester, who has lots of problems with fumbles. By comparison, Forte, who is much more towards the power side (although yes, not a true power back, probably considered balanced), didn't have a real fumble all year long.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.