Originally posted by wbudwhite
I like the fact that you say I have no class but it is you that are using such high class tactics as name calling. Exactly how do you expect me to rank your team when it looks like it does on paper. You levels are a lot more spread out than usual slow build teams and unless you are willing to open all your builds (and have every other team as well) than how do you expect me to rank you? And to tell you the truth even if that did happen if you think I am going through 16 teams and looking at all the builds to do meaningless rankings , your nuts.
As far as the shots that I took at you, do you deny any of them as being true?
I took a lot of time to explain exactly how I do the rankings so there would be no confusion as to what I look at. I complemented your team but for some reason you are not willing to acknowledge that fact all. Do you expect me to rank you higher above other teams even though on paper you are not up there, just because I "know" your team. Is that fair to other teams in a new leauge that I know very little about them?
Here are your exact ranking as of yesterday. Average Starter on Offense 12th, Average Starter of Defense 11th, Special Teams 8th, Average Back up on offense 12th, Average Back up on Defense is 12th, Starters for Total Team 11th, Total Team Average 12th, Chemistry 10th. If you ask me I think it was generous to rank you 10th.
I do these pre-season rankings as a service to the other teams to let them know where they stand so they can continue to recruit while we are still in the off season. Also When doing PRE season rankings I have no games to reference. If you win a few games early these get totally different. I really think you are putting too much weight in them.
I do these because for some weird reason I enjoy doing them but, if I get called negative names for putting in about 5 hours worth of time it really is not worth it to me. I will stop doing them and some one else can do them.
If anybody would like to see the ranking spreadsheet the measures everybody please PM me with your e-mail address and I can send it to you.
I really think the only thing that pissed you off was the fact that I told your playoff story to a new group of people and you are embarrassed about it. But that is just my opinion. You beat my team, all you have to say is that. 5/18 you can really shut me up.
John
You lied about our playoff story, and that annoys me. If you want to tell our playoff story, go watch every one of our first three playoff games, count the number of times we ran the strong I slam and our number of total offensive plays, and post it here. If you want to take digs at us then, go ahead. But posting crap about us i-slamming all the way through the playoffs is libellous and you fucking know it. BTW, every time you see 'run right' in the play by play it is NOT necessarily a strong I slam.
The comment about needing to resolve our TE situation is pretty stupid. We have a blocking TE and receiving TE that are both lvl 40+ that do their jobs pretty darn well.
----
But the truth is that my response (and I suspect alloy's, though he is displaying more patience) was only influenced in small part by the above. The true absurdity of the rankings is that you continue to base them almost solely on player level.
Last season, I found your rankings...cute. Privately I thought it was hilarious that someone would think that player level was an accurate way to rank teams. Scouting bars are also far from accurate but a far better measure than levels. In the preseason you don't have a lot to go on, making those rankings is really tough, so it was mostly just amusing that you chose the less accurate of the two sets of numerical data to make your rankings. If you look back at those posts in the forum, we offered the same polite 'thanks' for your rankings that others are offering this season, even though you were obviously way underrating our team. You had your method and were sticking with it, and like many others have pointed out this season (and I said last season), it's nice to have someone to do rankings to start conversation, even if they're flawed. And it's really tough to get them right, even if you are using the better numerical data to base things on.
But this season... c'mon. Our players have barely changed. Are you telling me that you didn't learn ANYTHING about the quality of our builds or tactics last season? You think that our players are going to perform like average players their level? You think our gameplanning is going to be average? You played in our conference, you watched our team win the games we won (including in the regular season, don't go all Islam on me here), but you still think that the level of our players is a good indication of their skill level. Please. This is why alloy posted about you being a slow learner, and he's right.
Player level is a pretty poor indication of player quality. People do all kinds of crazy crap with their builds. People pour SP's into SA's when their player is level 6. People apply their skill points slowly across all attributes without any regard for softcapping. I've even seen QB's put points into kicking. You can't possibly have failed to notice this by now -- anyone who's done any recruiting has to have noticed the vast difference in quality of build in the marketplace for players at the same level. We don't have to be a 'slow build' team that started every single player at the exact same time for our players to be built well. Like I said and everyone (but you?) knows, the scouting bars give a better (but not exactly great) indication of the general quality of build. Even more importantly, you had all of last year's results to learn from but chose to ignore.
-----
The part of your post about shutting you up if we beat you is pretty LOL. We beat you twice last year, and all that got us was whining about gaining more yards (in the regular season) and complaining about the strong-i slam (playoffs).
I don't expect to accomplish anything with you via this post, but I hope the others who are slamming me/Valhalla will at least consider that we spent all of last season being respectful, patient and appreciative of your misguided rankings and all it got us was whining, continued GLB ignorance, and untruthful potshots in your rankings.