User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Happy Easter Guys!
Page:
 
cliff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot


Your impressions of metaphors are yours alone. To each his own I guess.


No, I'm quite sure they're not mine alone. They may not be yours, but in my experience most people who are into Christianity have the idea that their religion is somehow above the scrutiny that they view other religions with. So even considering those traditions as a metaphor (or anything other than "holy") has never crossed their minds. I'm not saying that's necessarily you, I'm pointing out that just because you may not have considered it doesn't mean there aren't a good number of people who view it that way. I just so happen to be one of them.

Christianity just isn't all that special. Nearly everything that is in the bible has been regurgitated from various other older (and mostly pagan) religions. The only reason it seems mystical or relevant to most people is because even though there are scores of other religions out there they have only been educated in one.

That same metaphor is repeated elsewhere.
Last edited Apr 13, 2009 08:48:45
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Oh look, hey, a gay religious debate.




Get the fuck out of this forum plz. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=3835
 
cliff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Oh look, hey, a gay religious debate.

Get the fuck out of this forum plz. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=3835


Good point.

Message me if you'd like to talk about any of that further (anyone).
Last edited Apr 13, 2009 10:17:31
 
Jackhammer1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cliff
Originally posted by enoch101

Originally posted by Ladyzman


Happy Easter or as My roommate refers to it:
"Happy Zombie Jesus Day"


Give your roommate a copy of the Case for Easter (easier read) or the Case for Christ by Lee Strobel. Good reads.




Hmm ... I was under the impression that Christ (and all the other gods that were resurrected around the spring Equinox) were a metaphor for the change in seasons. The Spring Equinox (Which is what Easter is really in celebration of) is when the days officially become longer than the nights. The change in seasons represented the return of life in nature (hence it's around the time so many 'saviors" are resurrected in religious stories) It's the celebration of good over evil (There's more light than dark now, etc) and has been celebrated in many other religions as well.

If we're going to do some religious reading I suggest "The God Delusion" by Richard Dawkins. Good read as well.


While Easter is currently celebrated on the Spring Equinox or just after, it wasn't always celebrated on that day. Easter is, therefore, not a celebration of the Spring Equinox. They did end up choosing the Spring Equinox as the day to celebrate Easter centuries after Easter was created because of the symbolism involved, but Easter itself was never simply a metaphor for a change in seasons.
Last edited Apr 13, 2009 12:47:33
 
cliff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jackhammer1

While Easter is currently celebrated on the Spring Equinox or just after, it wasn't always celebrated on that day. Easter is, therefore, not a celebration of the Spring Equinox. They did end up choosing the Spring Equinox as the day to celebrate Easter centuries after Easter was created because of the symbolism involved, but Easter itself was never simply a metaphor for a change in seasons.


Correct, not Easter itself. Easter was made by Christians and the holiday itself is a Christian holiday. However, Easter-like festivals have been going on for longer than Christianity has even been around. They took the same ideas from other religions and put "Jesus" (and somehow a chocolate egg laying bunny) as the front man.

For example;
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easter#Anglo-Saxon_and_German

Originally posted by

The modern English term Easter developed from Old English word Ēastre or Ēostre or Eoaster, which itself developed prior to 899. The name refers to Eostur-monath, a month of the Germanic calendar attested by Bede as named after the goddess Ēostre of Anglo-Saxon paganism.[8] Bede notes that Eostur-monath was the equivalent to the month of April, and that feasts held in her honor during Ēostur-monath had died out by the time of his writing, replaced with the Christian custom of Easter.[9] Using comparative linguistic evidence from continental Germanic sources, the 19th century scholar Jacob Grimm proposed the existence of an equivalent form of Eostre among the pre-Christian beliefs of the continental Germanic peoples, whose name he reconstructed as *Ostara.

The implications of the goddess have resulted in scholarly theories about whether or not Eostre is an invention of Bede, theories connecting Eostre with records of Germanic folk custom (including hares and eggs), and as descendant of the Proto-Indo-European goddess of the dawn through the etymology of her name. Grimm's reconstructed *Ostara has had some influence in modern popular culture. Modern German has Ostern, but otherwise, Germanic languages have generally borrowed the form pascha, see below.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jackhammer1


While Easter is currently celebrated on the Spring Equinox or just after, it wasn't always celebrated on that day. Easter is, therefore, not a celebration of the Spring Equinox. They did end up choosing the Spring Equinox as the day to celebrate Easter centuries after Easter was created because of the symbolism involved, but Easter itself was never simply a metaphor for a change in seasons.


Got em! Good to know...In case anyone gets all atheist on me next time Easter rolls around I will have a plan B.
Last edited Apr 13, 2009 14:28:18
 
confidential
offline
Link
 
this forum is so gay just stop talking all of you
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by confidential
this forum is so gay just stop talking all of you


You guys are making me QFConfidential.


Don't let it happen again, capiche?
 
Jackhammer1
offline
Link
 
"Correct, not Easter itself. Easter was made by Christians and the holiday itself is a Christian holiday. However, Easter-like festivals have been going on for longer than Christianity has even been around. They took the same ideas from other religions and put "Jesus" (and somehow a chocolate egg laying bunny) as the front man. "

This is quite different than you original comment

"I was under the impression that Christ (and all the other gods that were resurrected around the spring Equinox) were a metaphor for the change in seasons. The Spring Equinox (Which is what Easter is really in celebration of)"

Some other things to note about that particular wiki page is at the top of it is this message

"The neutrality of this article is disputed. Please see the discussion on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until the dispute is resolved. "

On the talk page one of the items you see is this

"It is just as probable that the latin root for Easter derives from "Passio", latin for suffering"

There was a pretty good debate from both sides on that talk page. One good quote was this

"Easter as a Christian celebration is totally independent in nature, origin, and observance from pagan traditions. I believe it is accepted scholarship that as the Roman Empire sought conversion of pagans to Christianity following Constantine, the Church incorporated some elements of pagan vernal equinox holidays into Easter (much as Christmas Trees were incorporated into Christmas) to make Christianity more palatable. This is, however, not Easter having its origins in Pagan traditions, but Easter coopting those traditions and bending them to the overall celebration of the Resurrection."

There are many similarities between religions. This in itself does not prove any particular religion false.



Last edited Apr 13, 2009 23:45:29
 
cliff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jackhammer1
"Correct, not Easter itself. Easter was made by Christians and the holiday itself is a Christian holiday. However, Easter-like festivals have been going on for longer than Christianity has even been around. They took the same ideas from other religions and put "Jesus" (and somehow a chocolate egg laying bunny) as the front man. "

This is quite different than you original comment

"I was under the impression that Christ (and all the other gods that were resurrected around the spring Equinox) were a metaphor for the change in seasons. The Spring Equinox (Which is what Easter is really in celebration of)"


Indeed, but that's like saying if you take a Ford truck and paint the word "Honda" on it that it's no longer a Ford. That's what's been done here. No "Easter" itself is not identical ... it's a bad copy.

Originally posted by

Some other things to note about that particular wiki page is at the top of it is this message

"The neutrality of this article is disputed. Please see the discussion on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until the dispute is resolved. "

On the talk page one of the items you see is this

"It is just as probable that the latin root for Easter derives from "Passio", latin for suffering"

There was a pretty good debate from both sides on that talk page. One good quote was this

"Easter as a Christian celebration is totally independent in nature, origin, and observance from pagan traditions. I believe it is accepted scholarship that as the Roman Empire sought conversion of pagans to Christianity following Constantine, the Church incorporated some elements of pagan vernal equinox holidays into Easter (much as Christmas Trees were incorporated into Christmas) to make Christianity more palatable. This is, however, not Easter having its origins in Pagan traditions, but Easter coopting those traditions and bending them to the overall celebration of the Resurrection."


That doesn't help your argument, in my opinion. That last paragraph especially. The bit about "(much as Christmas Trees were incorporated into Christmas) to make Christianity more palatable.". If Christianity is the "truth" or the "way" why is it important to change it to be more likable? Because, as with all religions, what is said isn't as important as how many people you can get believing (and therefore funding) your organization.

Originally posted by

There are many similarities between religions. This in itself does not prove any particular religion false.


But I'm sure you think your religion is "the right one"? Just like every other religious person in the world. Someone is wrong. If just one of these is the "truth", that means all the rest are false. What makes yours the right one? Because that's what you believe?

What's your take on Scientology? In our lifetime we have *seen* someone completely make up a religion and it attract followers. It baffles me how you can't see the same thing could be (and very likely is) true with your religion.

P.S. I'm pretty sure we're annoying people by having this conversation here. Feel free to PM me if you'd like to continue.
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 17:19:06
 
Jackhammer1
offline
Link
 

"P.S. I'm pretty sure we're annoying people by having this conversation here. Feel free to PM me if you'd like to continue."

Have you noticed that people always say this AFTER they made their last point and BEFORE you have a chance to respond? Cliff you could have easily copied, pasted, and PMed me this last response. Instead you made it so that if I poke holes in your argument in this thread, I look like a jerk. I will discuss this topic with you in private, but I will stll call you out for trying to save face by pulling this sneaky maneuver.
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 17:09:10
 
Link
 
hey cliff, gtfo
 
cliff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jackhammer1

"P.S. I'm pretty sure we're annoying people by having this conversation here. Feel free to PM me if you'd like to continue."

Have you noticed that people always say this AFTER they made their last point and BEFORE you have a chance to respond? Cliff you could have easily copied, pasted, and PMed me this last response. Instead you made it so that if I poke holes in your argument in this thread, I look like a jerk. I will discuss this topic with you in private, but I will stll call you out for trying to save face by pulling this sneaky maneuver.


That wasn't my intent. If you read up in the thread, you'll notice I already tried to move this to PM once. When that didn't happen I responded here and asked to move to PM again.

Originally posted by cliff
Originally posted by kurieg

Oh look, hey, a gay religious debate.

Get the fuck out of this forum plz. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=3835


Good point.

Message me if you'd like to talk about any of that further (anyone).


How about this; You make your last point here and then we'll take it to PM, if that'll satisfy you.
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 17:25:10
 
cliff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot
hey cliff, gtfo


If you're not intelligent enough to join the conversation then why click the "post" button? It seems like a waste of everyone's time.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cliff
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot

hey cliff, gtfo


If you're not intelligent enough to join the conversation then why click the "post" button? It seems like a waste of everyone's time.


if i was THAT intelligent i wouldnt have clicked the 'post' button to begin with

...and neither would you.

since it seems you failed in glorious fashion.
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 18:24:43
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.