User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by flknight
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell

Understood.. i guess us starting back ups against these teams that we play towards the bottom of the conference may hurt us in the power rankings. I just see a flaw (And I hope you do as well) when a team that has more losses, lost both to the same top 2 teams, but lost head to head is ranked above the other team.

I can see that you have to have some type of formula but then again if you didn't you would be John Madden and we all know how he would probably have the Green Bay Packers and Brett Farv-ra ranked #1 even though they are not in our league.

Great job flknight....



Ronald,

To be fair, I had to estimate SOS for the first 10 games (.400 for 7-10 wins, .500 for 3-6 and .600 for 0-3) If you had your toughest games early you may not have gotten full credit for your early SOS. Since we don't have a total league week by week schedule w/ results I had to estimate. (If someone would like to go team by team and figure out weekly win/loss plus win percentages for each week, then I can adjust that.)

We'll see how this works, flaws and all, and adjust where we need to. Next season should be more accurate. I'll take suggestions into account.






Understood flknight... not arguing and as I said before you have to make it easy on yourself with the formula. We could argue the BCS all day as well if we wanted to.

Our hardest games were weeks 3(Samuri) - 4(Wolves) - 5(Hitmen) so it may be affecting it that way.

As I also mentioned this takes time to put together so I appreciate it but just wanted to throw it out there that I feel we shouldn't have slipped yet others want to jump in immediately and blast for it. From this point on I will just simply not provide feedback then on the power rankings as it seems to cause debate (And thats a bad thing? Isn't that what these are for?)

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby
Flawless.

Ronald, less crying more football, please.


Again.. same question I gave to GUY...

If you were ranked #2 under the Mato Grasso Wolves.. would you not question it?

 
flknight
star gent
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
From this point on I will just simply not provide feedback then on the power rankings as it seems to cause debate (And thats a bad thing? Isn't that what these are for?)



Yep, Debate is exactly what this is for. I have no issues with conflict. If you have a disageement voice your opinion. That doesn't mean everyone will agree.
 
ElvisMonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Your calling me out yet you don't read the entire post... ok GUY.

If the Mag 7 were ranked lower than the Mato Grasso would you question it? Even though you beat them straight up & a better record?

I guess you wouldn't though since I'm a tool and your not.


I'm not your guy, friend. And if Mag7 were ranked lower than I felt we should be, I'd be the last person to cry and whine about it. ESPECIALLY if I had no problem with where I was ranked a week before. You know why? Because 1. the whole "power ranking" was put together by somebody that, as far as I can tell, doesn't seem to have an axe to grind or an agenda. Whether or not I agree with the results, I appreciate the effort. And 2. I'm not a toolbag.

When it's all said and done, it'll be settled in the playoffs. If I have the desire to make a case that my team is better than any other team, I'll take it up with that team. Not bitch about the guy that put the rankings together.

Anything else?
 
ElvisMonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
From this point on I will just simply not provide feedback then on the power rankings...


OH NOES!! Anything but THAT! Please don't quit "providing feedback"!!!1 ALL THE PLANTS WILL DIE!!!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ElvisMonster
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell

Anything else?


Yes... your a severe tool

 
ElvisMonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by ElvisMonster

Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell


Anything else?


Yes... your a severe tool



Really? That's what you're going to go with? I know you are but what am I? Well played, sir.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ElvisMonster
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell

Originally posted by ElvisMonster


Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell



Anything else?


Yes... your a severe tool



Really? That's what you're going to go with? I know you are but what am I? Well played, sir.


Well I am not your sir... Friend
 
urfrendlipiro
offline
Link
 
great work flknight!
 
advanex1
offline
Link
 
Curious how the Bulls are ahead of the Crocs. The Bulls only loss comes from the Crocs this season.
 
kxrnidge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by advanex1
Curious how the Bulls are ahead of the Crocs. The Bulls only loss comes from the Crocs this season.


The Bulls are ahead because we have more points in his scoring system, which is, and I quote fknights here:

"It's all strength of wins."

By that, I'm assuming we're ahead only because we've beaten equal/better teams than you by more points, but barely.
 
Rarus Mugire
offline
Link
 
^^^^^
Gets it.
 
advanex1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kxrnidge
Originally posted by advanex1

Curious how the Bulls are ahead of the Crocs. The Bulls only loss comes from the Crocs this season.


The Bulls are ahead because we have more points in his scoring system, which is, and I quote fknights here:

"It's all strength of wins."

By that, I'm assuming we're ahead only because we've beaten equal/better teams than you by more points, but barely.


I don't think you guys have played better teams than we have. We have gone through you, the water works, the leopards, and the eagles. Where I believe you guys have only played 1 or 2 of those.

It looks like the rankings are made purely off of points scored and that's it. These rankings just don't make much sense to me.
 
Link
 
*Cheer*..... it's is not just me that has questions! =)

I would think you would look at record 1st - head to head 2nd - then the magical formula of strength of schedule and how teams did vs. common opponents.
 
ElvisMonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
*Cheer*..... it's is not just me that has questions! =)

I would think you would look at record 1st - head to head 2nd - then the magical formula of strength of schedule and how teams did vs. common opponents.


Great idea. When can we expect to see your rankings?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.