User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #1 > Congratulations, MPHD - SA AAA #1 League Champions.
Page:
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrogish
Originally posted by Anarcho

Why shouldn't he eventually be rewarded for his patience and hard work?


It's not like the guy's been suffering up until this point. He's only lost, what, 2 games in 5 seasons?


Well he sure did suffer last season in the playoffs.

My point was that he built his team a certain way, why should he feel bad about continuing to run his team the same way just because the sim changed in his favor? Of course he hasn't been suffering much up to this point. It's because he's worked hard. Just because the sim changes for his benefit doesn't mean he should have to find some other way to win.

If the sim ever decides to play to our strengths, I'll do that 100 times a game until someone stops us.
Last edited Apr 5, 2009 14:29:45
 
Samythe41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho


If the sim ever decides to play to our strengths, I'll do that 100 times a game until someone stops us.


Man, you're right, I'll sneak right now to the suggestions forums and ask for a sim update :

every pass to a hb that is built like a wide out and has scatback VA should be a home run.

(If you don't get what I'm talknig about, check my team page)
Last edited Apr 5, 2009 14:49:34
 
jrogish
offline
Link
 
There's a difference between running the ball 70 times and running the same exact play 70 times.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrogish
There's a difference between running the ball 70 times and running the same exact play 70 times.


I thought taut did a great job mixing up his offense. He had some pitches and some passes out of Strong I. When we first played them in the regular season, he ran a ton of Off Tackle instead of the Slam.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
off tackle=slam

We actually ran the off tackle the whole season when we called on strong i formations, not the slam. THe HB slam was more of our staple in the running game.
Last edited Apr 5, 2009 17:53:09
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
off tackle=slam

We actually ran the off tackle the whole season when we called on strong i formations, not the slam. THe HB slam was more of our staple in the running game.


Off tackle =/= slam. One you can potentially stop with a blitzing CB. The other you are effed either way.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by NRS

Yeah Yeah Yeah run the Strong I right 60 times and win a trophy.... GLB is awesome!




In all fairness, it isn't like taut JUST started spamming the running game this season. His team is built for it. He planned this in a time where the running game was terrible. Why shouldn't he eventually be rewarded for his patience and hard work?

Even if it comes at my expense...


yes, but taut had never spammed the SI slam in any game ever the way he did against us. Spamming the running game is one thing, spamming one exploitative play is another. That said, I knew we couldn't do the same to him, or I probably would have done the same thing. Bottom line is MPHD was/is the best team in this league with or without that play. I took it as a compliment that taut felt he needed to do that against us to guarantee the win. He deserves it and I wish him and his team nothing but the best up in Pro.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 

Well, this is a tired topic in my mind, but here are my thoughts "for the record."

1) The slam is overpowered. But only by the smallest amount.

Most teams have not really focused on run defense, and of the ones that have tried, only a few have gotten it right.
If you have excellent run defenders, you can stop even the best slammers frequently enough to keep them from rolling right through you, assuming that you have sufficient offense yourself to do something with the ball.

For evidence, see the MEM vs HHW game in USAPro. MEM has one of the very best O-lines, and probably the best powerback in GLB. They were held to 3 FGs and a TD, and forced to punt twice. And they were slamming like nobody's business. If HHW had been able to generate any real offense, they would have crushed MEM. Sadly, they simply tried to slam in return and were even less effective

The reality is that the slam has always been a good play, but it was by far the best play this season because very few defenses had the personnel and tactical knowledge to defend it adequately.

I actually draw a parallel between this and the "over-powered" DEs of season 6. Most folks did not have OTs who could stop some of these DEs at all, and many folks thought it was an exploit that these fast and agile DEs could seemingly sack them at will. The fact was, a good OT could slow those guys down or even shut them out, especially when combined with good game plans.

This situation is a bit more extreme, because there are very few teams that seemed to be able to contain the slam effectively enough...and most teams simply didn't try because of all the hype.

How many folks were using the 4-3 Strong shift SS+MLB+CB2 blitz, when they had proven time and again that it was not effective enough? There are other defenses, and there are things you can do to put the occasional stop to the slam, which is all you really need to do in order to beat it.

Here is the problem with the above defense:

The slam runs inside, so CB2 is generally not a factor in the play, because he just can't get there.

The only way he can be relevant is if he is insanely fast and agile, with a few other important attributes thrown in, and then only if the HB is relatively slow (60s). He also needs to be on run-focus or he tends to just bail out of the blitz.
So that is basically out, as it hamstrings your pass defense and is not achievable in most cases.

The play is a very quick hitting play, and the FB heads straight for the hole with the HB right on his heels.

The above defensive formation seems like a good idea because it stuffs two players right into the hole, each on top of each other. However, they are aligned such that the FB engages them directly, which means that they will rarely make the tackle, and if they do it will be a poor quality tackle which allows the HB to dive for another 3-4 yards. You can run that defense all day long, and unless something else happens, you will NEVER stop the slam for less that about 3 yards. If we know nothing else after Season 8, we know that

The elements that can change that equation have to do with your NT or LDE beating their block quickly enough to cause hesitation in the HB, or cause the FB to divert. You need a studly D-line to break the block quickly enough to do that.

Or, you can bring pressure from the weak side...either the DT or ROLB, if quick enough, can catch the play from the backside and either make the tackle or divert the FB, or cause the HB to bounce outside. So bringing quality defenders from that angle helps a lot.

Better yet, you can align your players to attack the play from a different angle entirely. If you have a studly NT, you can bring your LBs from the center of the pitch and have them attack through the C and RG at an angle that the FB cannot shield (this is how I defend it). Send the SS or LOLB straight through to occupy the FB for good measure, but bring your tacklers in from a different direction...it works much better.

So...yes, the play is over powered, but frankly the defenses were unbelievably lazy (speaking very generally) in trying to solve the problem. We have developed a culture where we would rather turn to Bort than try to figure how to fix things ourselves.

That being said, without decent (meaning very good and specifically set up for the task) personnel across your front 7 and safeties, you were likely to get trucked regardless of what you did...which is a bit much, I think we all agree. And you did have to commit to stopping it...you had to send an army if you really wanted a chance to choke it. On some plays I would send 5 blitzers...because you have to break the tempo of the slammer and put them into a passing situation, or endanger the 4 and out...otherwise, it's just a deathmarch.

2) The rest of the running game is underpowered.

Anyone who tried to run something other than the slam against us in the playoffs can probably attest...with a good defense, you weren't going anywhere. The blocking logic was changed for the I-form plays over the offseason in such a way that I-form inside became a TFL about 40% of the time if the defense was stout...even if you had an elite running game.
The offtackle and pitch plays from the I-form are also very easily shut down (unless you had a very specific sort of elusive back, a type which is exceedingly rare in GLB), and tackled for a loss consistently.
The changes in the o-line / d-line interaction crushed the singleback inside plays, also making them losers all too often even if the defense was in a passing defense...and if they were blitzing up the middle you could just forget about it.
The Proset plays are a disaster, a competent defense will TFL those about 60% of the time.

So basically, the running game was extremely difficult to do effectively against top quality defense...except for a single play.

By the time the playoffs rolled around, I think many or most folks knew how to stuff all of those other runs, and stuff them for a loss with alarming consistency.

So in that environment, what is a running team supposed to do? Run plays that you know with certainty will get shut down for a loss quite often against a decent DC? Or run the one running play that could give you consistent yardage?

In my mind, the problem was not so much about the slam as it was about the poor quality of every other running play. The slam has answers, but they require you to make some tough choices. The other plays can frankly be defended with far too great an ease, even against a powerful running team. Much more easily than they were last season, for instance.

This by the way, is my greatest fear for season 9...in an effort to neuter one play, they will make the rest of the running game completely non-viable...it is already borderline in my mind.


Nobody was happy with this sim, and I had several conversations with the folks in power to advocate changes that I thought would be appropriate...but there was so much confusion and lack of understanding over what really comprised the problem that there seemed to be a bit of paralysis while folks tried to chart a path.


So...I make no apologies for a less than elegant path to victory, but in the season of the slam a run-focused team was in a bit of a bind. That being said, I very nearly broke out an all passing offense for the champioNships...I sort of wish that I had, as judging from the passes I threw it would have been pretty effective

But the MPHD have always played what is essentially the slam game...powerful running, ball control, and stiff defense (most of the time). It's an age old philosophy and has given us success for 5 seasons. the fact that this season funneled us down to one play, and the fact that everyone in GLB was worked up over that same play was unfortunate.

I guess there is no point in highlighting the 150 yards passing and 85% completion rate we had in the championship game...the slams overwhelm that statistic entirely

Regardless, let's hope season 9 offers us a better sim.
Last edited Apr 6, 2009 02:41:59
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 


1) The slam is overpowered. But only by the smallest amount.

I agree. The bigger problem is that there is no play recognition. The SI Slam is not the first or last play to be abused in this game. It is asinine that this issue wasn't addressed seasons ago when this type of thing first came up.

The slam runs inside, so CB2 is generally not a factor in the play, because he just can't get there.

Well duh. Anyone who uses the CB blitz to stop the Slam doesn't know what they're doing. In our game, we used this defense on first downs because you typically ran Strong I off-tackle a lot of 1st down.

The play is a very quick hitting play, and the FB heads straight for the hole with the HB right on his heels.

But so are a lot of plays and those same plays aren't constantly defended with 3 guys hitting the hole only to have the HB bounce through and fall 5 yards forward.

2) The rest of the running game is underpowered.

This is your greatest point. Against good run defenses, your running options are almost none.

In my mind, the problem was not so much about the slam as it was about the poor quality of every other running play.

I too am worried about season 9. Play recognition is the only thing that should come out of this. Also, the fall forward dynamic needs toned down just a bit. However, I am worried that there will be too much done to slow the play and combined with the defensive play creator, there will be almost no way to run the ball effectively. Ligers were originally envisioned as a power-running, hell just a power team as well. Look how we dominated our first season just pounding it out. We've since diversified because of two reasons. 1.) you never know what is going to happen with the sim and 2.) at higher levels you SHOULD have to have a balanced offense.

In the end, I OC'd on a bunch of teams this season and none of them ran SI slam more than 10% of the time in any game, ever. Two won silvers and one was the Ligers. All 3 had one of the most effective balanced offenses in their league without abusing one play. However, in our game, had I known that I COULD abuse that play against you guys and done so, I would have. The point is that I knew I couldn't. You guys could stop it and it has nothing to do with tactics whatsoever. You built one hell of a team and you know just like I know that a good OC runs the ball until a team stops you. That's the essence of football at any level. Running is safer and more consistent. If a team can't stop it, you're an idiot to not do it. Congrats on a great team that you built and good luck in the Pros.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by cptafw163

off tackle=slam

We actually ran the off tackle the whole season when we called on strong i formations, not the slam. THe HB slam was more of our staple in the running game.


Off tackle =/= slam. One you can potentially stop with a blitzing CB. The other you are effed either way.


I just noticed that the Fb had a better blocking path in the OT play. i had said that in the FB forum right before season 5 in the preseason. because everyone who owned a FB was pissed that the blocking paths were screwed up. Not for the OT play. But now, the FB paths are a lot better.

--Dan
 
SoCold
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by NRS

Yeah Yeah Yeah run the Strong I right 60 times and win a trophy.... GLB is awesome!




In all fairness, it isn't like taut JUST started spamming the running game this season. His team is built for it. He planned this in a time where the running game was terrible. Why shouldn't he eventually be rewarded for his patience and hard work?

Even if it comes at my expense...


lol that is funny. the strong i right was an exploit well before his team was created. why do you think he built his team that way? who cares they won.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SoCold
Originally posted by Anarcho

Originally posted by NRS


Yeah Yeah Yeah run the Strong I right 60 times and win a trophy.... GLB is awesome!




In all fairness, it isn't like taut JUST started spamming the running game this season. His team is built for it. He planned this in a time where the running game was terrible. Why shouldn't he eventually be rewarded for his patience and hard work?

Even if it comes at my expense...


lol that is funny. the strong i right was an exploit well before his team was created. why do you think he built his team that way? who cares they won.


Hmm. I guess I remember season 3 a little differently than you do...

 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by SoCold

Originally posted by Anarcho


Originally posted by NRS



Yeah Yeah Yeah run the Strong I right 60 times and win a trophy.... GLB is awesome!




In all fairness, it isn't like taut JUST started spamming the running game this season. His team is built for it. He planned this in a time where the running game was terrible. Why shouldn't he eventually be rewarded for his patience and hard work?

Even if it comes at my expense...


lol that is funny. the strong i right was an exploit well before his team was created. why do you think he built his team that way? who cares they won.


Hmm. I guess I remember season 3 a little differently than you do...



I remember it differently too...
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
haha, strong I right exploit before offensive AI. ITT: taut was a tester before testers existed.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
haha, strong I right exploit before offensive AI. ITT: taut was a tester before testers existed.


Taut made this game. Bort is his multi...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.