User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
To get this rolling(i'm not an owner so I can only vote for MVP's myself) here are my votes

Offensive MVP - Gavin Dunn - Pirates 1259yds, 14 TDs 6.3 avg for the 4th place Alpha team
Defensive MVP - Brandon Flowers - WWAS 10 ints, 2 TD's, 31 PD for the 1st place Zeta team
Special Teams MVP - Mercury Cromartie - Monsoon 30.7 KR avg, 16.7 PR avg 2 TD's
 
therichone
offline
Link
 
so since I am a Gm but not an owner can I vote?
 
TaintStick
offline
Link
 
I like this idea alot! The only problem I have is that people in the Zeta league know exactly ZERO about the alpha league(At least I do). SHould we start something like pro-bowl teams for both leagues first, with each conference selecting their own pro-bowlers. Then we could have both conferences pick League MVPs from the combination of the pro-bowlers. This would also help with people who don't have time to go research EVERY player in the league, then they only have to scout players in their conference, who they have played against.

Just throwing that out there. Just my opinion, it's probably wrong.
Last edited May 16, 2008 17:06:15
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TaintStick
I like this idea alot! The only problem I have is that people in the Zeta league know exactly ZERO about the alpha league(At least I do). SHould we start something like pro-bowl teams for both leagues first, with each conference selecting their own pro-bowlers. Then we could have both conferences pick League MVPs from the combination of the pro-bowlers. This would also help with people who don't have time to go research EVERY player in the league, then they only have to scout players in their conference, who they have played against.

Just throwing that out there. Just my opinion, it's probably wrong.


i like that idea. we have time to refine this, no one has to rush. Offensive MVP, Defensive MVP, SPECIAL TEAMS MVP, and perhaps rookie of the year (someone under level 9?) to be voted by each and anyone, and then alpha and zeta probowl ballots to be determined by every team owner. not to be a dick, but perhaps when we agree on final rules and all that, we start a new post as this is getting clogged already (and i'm ocd, thus disliking clutter).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by therichone
so since I am a Gm but not an owner can I vote?


what do you say, perhaps every team gets one GM vote as well?

 
Link
 
or better yet, for a "rookie of the year" we could only choose from the expansion teams, as they have gotten shafted all year and could use some lovin'.
 
aeakers
offline
Link
 
For rookie of the year, why not limit it to players who did not play Season 1?

Maybe each team nominate a few of their guys so everyone does not have to search hard?
 
joe87
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of a "Pro Bowl" team for each Conference. If it was just one team, all votes would be homer votes for one of the conferences. We know about the teams in our conference because we game plan against them.
 
Link
 
that would work as well for ROY
 
joe87
offline
Link
 
I see a potential problem with the MVP voting.

Teams like the Hitmen would only give 1 vote to other teams' players, so it gives his MVP candidates an advantage. Maybe a weighted average (the total of each team's vote counts as 1/16 of the total vote) should be used to determine the MVP's.
 
durakbane
offline
Link
 
To keep it simple, I say leave the voting to the owners. If they wanted to, they could ask their team's help by voting in their team forums. Then the owner could either simply vote the way the team picked or vote on their own.
Last edited May 16, 2008 19:04:09
 
revolversw
offline
Link
 
Offensive MVP- Julius Maximus- QB, World Wide All-Stars
Defensive MVP- Horse Cartwright- DT, Manila Hitmen
Special Teams MVP- Moses Prophetson- K, East St. Louis Tire Fires
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of two pro bowl conferences instead of a single one thats a great idea. Think for the pro bowl it should still be the owners, because teams like the hitmen don't have gms. for those votes, teams with gms could do a vote on there team forum or something as stated similar. then think have the MVP voting open to everyone, players, coaches gms owners. RoY is a great idea also, although not sure who is best to define as rookies.
 
JT83
offline
Link
 
I'm for keeping this simple:
* 1 team, 1 vote.
* 1 All-Pro Team
* Can't vote for your own team
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
so it seems we are a bit split on the 1 All - Pro team or 2 Pro Bowl teams, lets hear some more votes.

1 team 1 vote seems to be in agreement for the most part as well as not voting for your own team so far.

lets here some more votes on the format
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.