User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Europe West AAA League > Europe West AAA #1 > Season 8 ALPHA Pro Bowl Voting
Page:
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 9873101
Originally posted by Mavooo

Originally posted by cherrie


As I started looking into votes for the Pro Bowl, I found I personally had some issues with the voting system.

You want us to vote for a total of 50 players, but we are only allowed 2 players from our own team.

I would like to suggest either making it ZERO players from your own team, or make it 4.

Also, since we are making MULTIPLE votes for each position, I would suggest that they need to be ranked... For example, voting for 3 QBs, you vote for the first, second, and third best QBs... All 1st place votes are worth 3 points, all second place votes worth 2, and all 3rd place votes worth 1... I really don't like the idea of being forced to vote for 3 players, when I think 1 is much more worthy than the other two, but all 3 get the same just by being on the ballot. If all 16 teams feel one guy is the 3rd best, but there are a lot of guys who are mixed around, the 3rd best guy will get the most votes, although he really wasn't the favorite to be the starter, if you see what I mean.

So, for RB, I would vote:

1. Harald Bluetooth
2. Iowa Jones
3. Badrian Beterson



I was following you until you listed badrian 3rd, then you lost me.


Agree.

Mine goes: Bluetooth, Turbo, Griff.


I have the same except for Griff. I havent decided 3rd yet.

I compare Griff and Dozer and see Dozer averages 6.5 a carry to 5.1 for Griff. Griff has Dozer in TD's but it's close, 34/28.
Dozer is also within 200 yds of Griff with 111 FEWER carries.
Last edited Mar 22, 2009 10:29:27
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
What would be nice is if someone would start a thread that lists players, stats, and links for the positions maybe like a top 10 or something to make it easier to chose the hard positions like FB, O-line and such. I know this would be quite a bit of work but would make filling out a ballot easier. Maybe someone could keep the original post updated and allow people to nominate contenders. I would do it but I think making the shows is time consuming enough for the benefit of the league.
 
Lancelot
offline
Link
 
do you guys think it would be ok to make my choices public or at least what I'm thinking? I'm not submitting my picks until the season is over.

I don't want to alter anyone's votes either if i do show everyone in my rough all-star draft
 
EaglesFan66
offline
Link
 
I don't have to complain about everything, but I have to put my two cents into something when I think it can be done better.

Stop whining every time I try to add something to try to improve it, LRats. I hate men who whine all the time.
 
EaglesFan66
offline
Link
 
As for my RB listing... the point was not the players, but the listing... I only could think of 2 RBs off the top of my head, so I just put a Rome RB on the list to make the point... not that this would be my list... I certainly don't think Iowa is top 3.
 
Lancelot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cherrie
I don't have to complain about everything, but I have to put my two cents into something when I think it can be done better.

Stop whining every time I try to add something to try to improve it, LRats. I hate men who whine all the time.


now you know why men hate getting married. you know how they feel when the women whine
 
tbriggs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cherrie

Also, since we are making MULTIPLE votes for each position, I would suggest that they need to be ranked... For example, voting for 3 QBs, you vote for the first, second, and third best QBs... All 1st place votes are worth 3 points, all second place votes worth 2, and all 3rd place votes worth 1... I really don't like the idea of being forced to vote for 3 players, when I think 1 is much more worthy than the other two, but all 3 get the same just by being on the ballot. If all 16 teams feel one guy is the 3rd best, but there are a lot of guys who are mixed around, the 3rd best guy will get the most votes, although he really wasn't the favorite to be the starter, if you see what I mean.


I guess under this system, if one player is miles ahead of other players (in your opinion, of course), just don't list anyone else at that position. With no ranking system on the ballot, what other choice is there...
 
LRats
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tbriggs
Originally posted by cherrie


Also, since we are making MULTIPLE votes for each position, I would suggest that they need to be ranked... For example, voting for 3 QBs, you vote for the first, second, and third best QBs... All 1st place votes are worth 3 points, all second place votes worth 2, and all 3rd place votes worth 1... I really don't like the idea of being forced to vote for 3 players, when I think 1 is much more worthy than the other two, but all 3 get the same just by being on the ballot. If all 16 teams feel one guy is the 3rd best, but there are a lot of guys who are mixed around, the 3rd best guy will get the most votes, although he really wasn't the favorite to be the starter, if you see what I mean.


I guess under this system, if one player is miles ahead of other players (in your opinion, of course), just don't list anyone else at that position. With no ranking system on the ballot, what other choice is there...


There is no point to putting just one, if the guy really is worthy then he'll be on enough ballots to get into the Pro Bowl. That is why a ranking system is unnecessary, If a player is good enough to get in then he will get in.
 
tbriggs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
There is no point to putting just one, if the guy really is worthy then he'll be on enough ballots to get into the Pro Bowl. That is why a ranking system is unnecessary, If a player is good enough to get in then he will get in.


Sure there is a point. It assures that the player I see as being far and away #1 isn't being weighed the same as the player that I think is a distant third. Imagine if the NCAA didn't use a weighed system for ranking. As bad as that system is now, it would be a lot worse.
Last edited Mar 22, 2009 17:14:34
 
LRats
offline
Link
 
It doesn't matter, if that player is really as good as you think then he'll make it in. All this looks like to me is someone trying to assure one of their players makes it on the team, because I don't see how you could care so much about someone from another team. If your players are really that good, then they'll make it. Don't have to worry.
 
Luke Pass
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cherrie
As for my RB listing... the point was not the players, but the listing... I only could think of 2 RBs off the top of my head, so I just put a Rome RB on the list to make the point... not that this would be my list... I certainly don't think Iowa is top 3.



Funny you point this out especially after you called out HB Jones before our game. He is maybe not in the top 3, but let me add this. Against 'YOUR D' this was Iowa Jones' line on only 22 plays: 17 Carries for 119 yards for a 7 ypc avg. and 1 TD. If our D could have gotten off the field, he could have possibly put up 200 yards on what you claimed was the best D in this league. You won, but could not even slow HB Jones.....so to say 'Certainly not in top 3' sort of disses your self proclaimed rush D.

LMAO......seriously!!
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Basically I was about to say LRats you pick for me, cause I would most likely pick the same as you, except make sure at least 2 Punks get on. After that make sure 2 wolverines on it, after that make sure there 2 Rage players on it. And after that fill it out however the hell you like.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Luke Pass
Originally posted by cherrie

As for my RB listing... the point was not the players, but the listing... I only could think of 2 RBs off the top of my head, so I just put a Rome RB on the list to make the point... not that this would be my list... I certainly don't think Iowa is top 3.



Funny you point this out especially after you called out HB Jones before our game. He is maybe not in the top 3, but let me add this. Against 'YOUR D' this was Iowa Jones' line on only 22 plays: 17 Carries for 119 yards for a 7 ypc avg. and 1 TD. If our D could have gotten off the field, he could have possibly put up 200 yards on what you claimed was the best D in this league. You won, but could not even slow HB Jones.....so to say 'Certainly not in top 3' sort of disses your self proclaimed rush D.

LMAO......seriously!!


Death by statistics!
 
Lohengrin
offline
Link
 
This stuff always causes way more drama than it's worth - I say we just put the entire Portland Rage team down as the Alpha squad and let's move on.
 
LRats
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lohengrin
This stuff always causes way more drama than it's worth - I say we just put the entire Portland Rage team down as the Alpha squad and let's move on.


Not really, this is the only season we had any drama
Last edited Mar 22, 2009 18:40:49
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.