Originally posted by 9873101
Originally posted by Mavooo
Originally posted by cherrie
As I started looking into votes for the Pro Bowl, I found I personally had some issues with the voting system.
You want us to vote for a total of 50 players, but we are only allowed 2 players from our own team.
I would like to suggest either making it ZERO players from your own team, or make it 4.
Also, since we are making MULTIPLE votes for each position, I would suggest that they need to be ranked... For example, voting for 3 QBs, you vote for the first, second, and third best QBs... All 1st place votes are worth 3 points, all second place votes worth 2, and all 3rd place votes worth 1... I really don't like the idea of being forced to vote for 3 players, when I think 1 is much more worthy than the other two, but all 3 get the same just by being on the ballot. If all 16 teams feel one guy is the 3rd best, but there are a lot of guys who are mixed around, the 3rd best guy will get the most votes, although he really wasn't the favorite to be the starter, if you see what I mean.
So, for RB, I would vote:
1. Harald Bluetooth
2. Iowa Jones
3. Badrian Beterson
I was following you until you listed badrian 3rd, then you lost me.
Agree.
Mine goes: Bluetooth, Turbo, Griff.
I have the same except for Griff. I havent decided 3rd yet.
I compare Griff and Dozer and see Dozer averages 6.5 a carry to 5.1 for Griff. Griff has Dozer in TD's but it's close, 34/28.
Dozer is also within 200 yds of Griff with 111 FEWER carries.
Originally posted by Mavooo
Originally posted by cherrie
As I started looking into votes for the Pro Bowl, I found I personally had some issues with the voting system.
You want us to vote for a total of 50 players, but we are only allowed 2 players from our own team.
I would like to suggest either making it ZERO players from your own team, or make it 4.
Also, since we are making MULTIPLE votes for each position, I would suggest that they need to be ranked... For example, voting for 3 QBs, you vote for the first, second, and third best QBs... All 1st place votes are worth 3 points, all second place votes worth 2, and all 3rd place votes worth 1... I really don't like the idea of being forced to vote for 3 players, when I think 1 is much more worthy than the other two, but all 3 get the same just by being on the ballot. If all 16 teams feel one guy is the 3rd best, but there are a lot of guys who are mixed around, the 3rd best guy will get the most votes, although he really wasn't the favorite to be the starter, if you see what I mean.
So, for RB, I would vote:
1. Harald Bluetooth
2. Iowa Jones
3. Badrian Beterson
I was following you until you listed badrian 3rd, then you lost me.

Agree.
Mine goes: Bluetooth, Turbo, Griff.
I have the same except for Griff. I havent decided 3rd yet.
I compare Griff and Dozer and see Dozer averages 6.5 a carry to 5.1 for Griff. Griff has Dozer in TD's but it's close, 34/28.
Dozer is also within 200 yds of Griff with 111 FEWER carries.
Last edited Mar 22, 2009 10:29:27





























