User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #3 > Cuzco has changed the league status
Page:
 
CarawayDotCom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 85
You gotta be kidding me. You don't feel bad about using a cheap system to get your way? It's not about that exploit being existent or not, it's about all the owners in this SA league especially in our conference, keeping AA #3 a fair and respectable conference, and you had to go and f**k it all up.


Blame your owner for using our Av, not us.
Last edited Mar 19, 2009 18:42:27
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmorgalis
If I were looking for a treatise on Darwinism, Social or otherwise, I would not be playing dot football.


Colored Dot at that
 
alladinsane
offline
Link
 
It was suggested that we all type a gentlemans agreement *not* to use this exploit and I see several owners/gms saying that they would never use it. That kind of perceived integrity is admirable and I think that if enough team leaders feel that strongly, perhaps the suggestion has merit and should be pursued.

That being said, there would have to be exact definitions of what the exploit is: Is it wrong to use it once? twice? A certain number of times consecutively?

Exactly what kind of conduct would be considered using the exploit? What ways are we going to be able to label any future nerfs as exploits? I would certainly be willing to commit to a gentlemans agreement for our team as long as it is not something merely to prevent a single team from being successful. I am sure our owner (because I am just a lowly gm) would most likely do the same. I still see the problem of enforcement though. Other than ostracism, we don't have alot except maybe with the GLB owner/gm ratings forum and discouraging agents from signing with the disputed team. That leaves open the possibility of collusion, but I don't think it would be a problem with this group as you all seem to take your integrity to heart.

Ultimately, I am afraid that I see no enforceable consequences for this and just a repetition of endless and useless flame wars. Unless someone smarter than me has any great ideas, we may be dealing with attacks similar to the OP (not attacking bedder here, just noting the tone of the OP) and what was once a pretty sportsmanlike group of (admittedly online) friendly rivals will turn into a squabbling mosh pit of bitter and impermeable enemies that will lose enjoyment of the game that brought many of us together. I can't do the Rodney King thing here, but I wish there was an agreeable solution.

Be well
 
microbe
offline
Link
 
Ok normally I am quiet on these forums, but this is getting way out of hand. I don't like to get involved in issues like this (I just let my players play the game) but this is completely ridiculous. I even went searching through the forums for other threads about this exploit. Sure I found a couple of threads, but it seems to be nothing of the magnitude that people are making it out to be. Keep in mind that I am not an OC or DC for any team nor have I ever been and so I don't know exactly what can and cant be set as far as AI is concerned.

First the plays run by a team using this exploit should have no effect on the other teams offense. If you can't score in this game, you are probably going to get beat anyway. Very rarely do we see a team score less than 20 and win a game (other than maybe the D Leagues. It just doesn't happen in GLB.

Second, in real football, you run the ball when you have a lead. So if you get a lead early it makes sense for the AI to start running the ball nonstop. And its not unheard of for an offense to be completely lopsided and either throw almost every down or run it.

Third, if you think a team is going to run the ball with their power backs, put in a defense that will work against it. Yes it is a risk because it opens up the rest of the field for the offense, but if they are running it like that it should work. And thats part of the game, risk and reward. If you guess wrong, you get beat by it. The same goes for blitzing. What seems to be the real issue to me is the lack of ability to construct AI settings to make in game adjustments. There should be a way to put in if/when scenarios that may not exist currently (again I have no experience as a OC or DC so I don't know if these may exist or what the current system looks like)

Lastly, please stop ruining the forums with this crap. I want to enjoy coming on here and reading the posts again. I am not just saying this because I play for Cuzco, I would feel the same way if it was a different team involved. While I do not particularly agree with our play calling, I also wouldn't get so worked up over another team doing the same thing to us. If it bothers you this much maybe there should be some sort of agreement not to do it.

This game in essence meant nothing since both teams are going to go into the playoffs with a home game or two (most likely anyways).
 
tincan
offline
Link
 
Defense would be stack the line and run blitz the right side. Up your tackling and get them in the back field. Just thought I would throw that in . There is no way in hell that every team would pull that play out of their offensive scheme. I would Imagine that your WRs would be pissed if you ran it all the time and I'm sure that Bort will fix it for next season or before. Then where will you be? I can see strength and tackling coming back into the builds for the d-line. As you well know Alladin, honor is often lost upon the weak, Archimedes once said "Give me a lever and I can lift the world". I will leave you with those thoughts.
 
mwoods07
offline
Link
 
The only suggestion I can make is to let it die. If you can't do that, so be it. I think both sides were wrong, some have apologized for things, so maybe it is time to let it be.

On a side note, you can't make a team do one thing or another. I don't think it would be in the spirit of the game for a team to say "you can run this play because it can't be stopped". With that being said, let's go on, if a team decides that is the only course of action they can take to win, then so be it...Life is a vicious circle, what goes around comes around! I think the most agreeable solution is to let the teams that want to win and move on using the exploit do it, and no one get all pissed about it and start another day like today. In the end, you can't stop a team from doing it anyway, so why bother trying?

Oh well, just trying to make peace somehow. I'll be truthful and say I think Cuzco and Cartel are pretty evenly matched, however Cuzco was not stopping the running game so unless they could score more in the end, it probably wasn't going to happen. It's hard to predict a winner as Cuzco was still going to score strong I or not...but the yardage Cartel was getting from the I form might have sealed the deal.
 
alladinsane
offline
Link
 
Hey...did tincan just call me 'weak?'

Oh..its ON now!

oh no you didnt!

j/k

----------------------------------------------------------
I think there have been some good conciliatory posts here and still think that revenge is a dish best served cold. There is only one problem though:

The SHARKS are going to whip both of you in the playoffs!
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Thats right. I went there. Oh yes I did
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tincan
Defense would be stack the line and run blitz the right side. Up your tackling and get them in the back field. Just thought I would throw that in . There is no way in hell that every team would pull that play out of their offensive scheme. I would Imagine that your WRs would be pissed if you ran it all the time and I'm sure that Bort will fix it for next season or before. Then where will you be? I can see strength and tackling coming back into the builds for the d-line. As you well know Alladin, honor is often lost upon the weak, Archimedes once said "Give me a lever and I can lift the world". I will leave you with those thoughts.


What do you think I set? I had a feeling that they would try that, and since their TE doesn't go out much, it doesn't matter who I blitzed. I was hoping they wouldn't run that exclusively, but I thought they would feature it. You run that play four times you get a first down. Plain and simple. Kill morale on the other team, which ruins the rest of the units. Not too hard to understand why it's an exploit.

 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
I dont have no dog or any business in this fight..but hey i will jump in any way...I dont know the parties involed..and never really spoke to either one

But I throw out a couple of points

1) I have own a team since season 2..been a gm since season 1 ..and I have yet to see where teams say they will not use a certain play in a league or any other forum

2)seasons 6-8 we had to play a team that used the strong formation as their only formation..we did pretty well against them

3) we play in a conference where everyone uses the strong I off tackle...a lot...hell we use it.

4) to stop it..and I wont go into a lot of details..if you D-C a team then you should know what I am saying
to stop the off tackle from the strong I or to slow it way down..there is twos things you can do...have a high scoring offense..score fast and often to take the run away from your opponent...or run blitz in waves...blitzing in waves being the key

5) if both teams was in agreement not to use it....then either one should have used it..but if no agreement was made..then it is a free for all

6) scouting is time consuming...but it is worth it wight in gold.....but this falls back to 5..if a agreement was put in place..from all teams or owners or what or who ever not to use it..and when I say use it I mean over..over..over..I have face teams that used over and over and over..hell it was the only play they used from the strong..so I set for the strong to use the goalline...it was shut down..but as I was saying if an agreement was in place not to use it all season then you use all of sudden..then yea kinda low

Again I use it..teams I play use it...can it be stoped or slowed down..hell yes it can...goes back to scouting..and picking up on tendencies...
I think i know a thing or 2 about one's word being good and all that since I make my living at it...in my line of work..or I should say the people I work around..away from work when it comes to "honor" or whatever you want to call..they are the best at..and most I dont even know

so flame away or whatever
Last edited Mar 19, 2009 20:30:43
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by microbe
Ok normally I am quiet on these forums, but this is getting way out of hand. I don't like to get involved in issues like this (I just let my players play the game) but this is completely ridiculous. I even went searching through the forums for other threads about this exploit. Sure I found a couple of threads, but it seems to be nothing of the magnitude that people are making it out to be. Keep in mind that I am not an OC or DC for any team nor have I ever been and so I don't know exactly what can and cant be set as far as AI is concerned.

First the plays run by a team using this exploit should have no effect on the other teams offense. If you can't score in this game, you are probably going to get beat anyway. Very rarely do we see a team score less than 20 and win a game (other than maybe the D Leagues. It just doesn't happen in GLB.

Second, in real football, you run the ball when you have a lead. So if you get a lead early it makes sense for the AI to start running the ball nonstop. And its not unheard of for an offense to be completely lopsided and either throw almost every down or run it.

Third, if you think a team is going to run the ball with their power backs, put in a defense that will work against it. Yes it is a risk because it opens up the rest of the field for the offense, but if they are running it like that it should work. And thats part of the game, risk and reward. If you guess wrong, you get beat by it. The same goes for blitzing. What seems to be the real issue to me is the lack of ability to construct AI settings to make in game adjustments. There should be a way to put in if/when scenarios that may not exist currently (again I have no experience as a OC or DC so I don't know if these may exist or what the current system looks like)

Lastly, please stop ruining the forums with this crap. I want to enjoy coming on here and reading the posts again. I am not just saying this because I play for Cuzco, I would feel the same way if it was a different team involved. While I do not particularly agree with our play calling, I also wouldn't get so worked up over another team doing the same thing to us. If it bothers you this much maybe there should be some sort of agreement not to do it.

This game in essence meant nothing since both teams are going to go into the playoffs with a home game or two (most likely anyways).


Once again you are failing to look at this with a neutral mindset. If one team is running the same play over and over and over again then the opposing teams offense is unable to be on the field for as many plays. Now while that is a very smart gameplan it is not the problem of what was being discussed. The problem is more with the game mechanics not allowing you to tackle for loss that play nor really hold it to less then 3 yards an attempt. So if you continue to run that play over and over again you will never be stopped. You might be slowed down with some of the defensive suggestions but it is virtually unstoppable and that is the issue. Nothing should be unstoppable in all leagues regardless of level (assuming equal levels, etc). The blocking is messed up with that particular play. I am not sure how you search or how long but this has been discussed in many many threads.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Discussion over lets move on

/thread
 
kanzaki
offline
Link
 
I don't own a team or even GM a team in this league but I think I'm fairly active in these forums, and I never saw any agreement to not the strong I off-tackle.

IMO, not an exploit, I do DC on many teams and unless you're running this play with a 50+ a game broken tackles powerback, you can stuff it for 3 and under yards everytime without giving up anything else.

Watching the replays of the game in question, wow... blitz much? If you're going to run your line backers straight into an OL and not expect to be pancaked and ran on, well... you get what you pay for.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geturembedder
Seriously. The fact that the stupid play can be run 4 times in a row and not stopped is as much bull shit as the WR screen was. This has been ongoing since the AI was introduced and you can customize your game plan with whatever play you want to run. It's a known exploit, no way two evenly matched teams should be able to win with one play being ran 4 downs in a row.

It ruins teams, it ruins leagues. You fixed the WR screen, now fix this stupid play once and for all. I don't care what you do, or how you do it, but no way one play should be ran like it can be run.

At this point, I am considering selling off over this, and I was just about to create about twenty new players. I have now joined countless others who will not spend any more flex because of this type of nonsense. This thing can be ran with elusives as well as power backs, so it is the play and not the builds.

I would have sold my team over this but for my players I won't. But now I am in a situation where either i exploit it as well and play boring ass football and let the winner be the back who fumbles the least. Not a game I am willing to play, much less pay for.


unreal
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kanzaki


Watching the replays of the game in question, wow... blitz much? If you're going to run your line backers straight into an OL and not expect to be pancaked and ran on, well... you get what you pay for.


that makes sense
 
ATLFan
offline
Link
 
Exploits suck, teams that use them as Cuzco did in this game suck too. We all want to win, but it can be done with integrity.

Whining sucks, Cartel has started a second thread because crying in one isn't enough. And where I grew up welshing on a bet was an offense deserving of a good beating.

You're both a discredit to SA AA#3, and were both teams that I had the utmost respect for prior to the last 24 hours. Pains me to say, but with our top 2 teams both acting like little girls...

ALPHA >>> ZETA
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.