User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Africa A League > Africa A #4 > Pro-Bowl/All Star Team?
Page:
 
John Clancy
offline
Link
 
Have separate votes for each conference. Since this is a Pro Bowl/All star vote and not an All Pro vote, separate conference votes should be used. Have just 1 ballot per team. The Destroyers can't vote for their guys but the rest of the participating teams can. Since a team can't vote for their own guy, logic would dictate that they will cast an impartial vote for the best players, whatever criteria that team wants to use.
 
JBennett23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gameface25
Originally posted by John Clancy

Originally posted by .Homeskillet.


I seriously doubt you'll get commitments from each team, a majority of teams represented would be fin as long as everyone at least tries to be objective.


No voting for your own teams players should take care of this.


this has never worked in any league I have ever been in that did this. FOr a few simple reasons.... The best teams are usually the most active. The most active are usually the ones that take time to participate in these voting systems. Therefore, the good teams will get alot of their players left off because a good chunck of the % of voters cant vote for themselves, and usuallyt eh best players are on the best teams soo.... its all coorelated.

And yes these usually always fail, but Ive seen them work too.

It all usually comes down to different peoples opinions on how to judge things. Do you vote for Clark -El at HB with his gaudy Rushing and Rec stats, or do you vote for the best HB in Lion who plays harder competition? On one hand, you cant fault Clark -El for his conference, on the other, the Lion HB might have the same stats if he played where Clark -El does, etc

It usually ends up a mess







Just have a different team for each conference.
 
Casin
offline
Link
 
As of now we have commitments from

Narobi Death Squad
Ann Arbor Wolves
Ivory Coast
 
Link
 
Sonny Beerbrok, owner of the Ardglass Beerbroks, committing.
 
Link
 
Nile Crocs commenting
 
Blackred
offline
Link
 
As owner and OC of the Kilimangiaro Icemen, I can try...
 
Steaks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Casin
As of now we have commitments from

Narobi Death Squad
Ann Arbor Wolverines
Ivory Coast


FTFY
 
dyepntmaster
offline
Link
 
Convicts commiting
 
nathbear
offline
Link
 
I'll nominate for Carlton Baggies unless Mateinone wants to.
 
mateinone
offline
Link
 
be great if you could nath.. I am seriously busy about 19 hours a day at the moment
 
Casin
offline
Link
 
As of now we have commitments from

Narobi Death Squad
Ann Arbor Wolves
Ivory Coast
Ardglass Beerbroks
Nile Crocs
Kilimangiaro Icemen
Carlton Baggies
Montreal Convicts
Kafulafuta Zambians
 
Casin
offline
Link
 
Still waiting on several other teams before we can really take a shot at this.
 
dyepntmaster
offline
Link
 
Start PMing the owners whom you havent heard from. Not everyone reads this forum.
 
alltyme
offline
Link
 
TT Red Raiders will participate.
 
nyg1925
offline
Link
 
im in....Owner Port Elizabeth Dolphins

let me know how it works with the voting
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.